Skip to content

post your 5 favourite guitarists

Archived

53 replies · 1,090 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Jimi Hendrix Yngwie Malmsteen Slash Van Halen Eric Clapton

0 likes

Barney John Squire Johnny Marr Mick Jones Mark Day

0 likes

Geordie (Killing Joke) Mitch Harris (Napalm Death) Tony Iommi (Black Sabbath) Barney Slash

:thumb:

0 likes

Lou Reed Robbie Krieger Ronnie Wood Johnny Marr John Squire

0 likes

Blues Guitar is the thing that gets me going and guitar in general

I could make a top ten....not all my favorites but they blow me away!

  1. Stevie ray Vaughan (his "Little Wing" has brought me to tears)
  2. Jimi Hendrix (tho he is the greatest hands down)
  3. Clapton (anything "Layla" and before)
  4. Danny Gatton
  5. Keith Richards
  6. BB King/John Lee Hooker
  7. Albert King
  8. Rory Gallagher
  9. Santana/Eddie Hazel (Funkadelic)
  10. Kirk Hammett (insanely talented)
0 likes

James Dean Bradfield Bernard Sumner (1979/80, lazy cunt since then) Lou Reed Evan Dando Will Sergeant

0 likes
  1. Andy Gill
  2. Johnny Marr
  3. Jimmy Hendrix
  4. Jack White
  5. Bernard Sumner (why not?)
0 likes

DiscoShed wrote:

  1. Kirk Hammett (insanely talented)

:nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod:

0 likes

Tim wrote: James Dean Bradfield

:nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod:

Tim wrote: Evan Dando

:nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod: :nod:

Just for the record, if you don't know who mine are from the pictures:

Mike McCready - Pearl Jam James Hetfield - Metallica Jerry Cantrell - Alice in Chains John Frusciante - RHCP Tom Morello - Rage Against The Machine/Audioslave

0 likes
  1. Jimi Hendricks
  2. BB King
  3. Dick Dale
  4. Les Claypool
  5. Johnny Marr
0 likes

Has Bernard Sumner ever actually learned how to play guitar? That is so punk, to play lead guitar for almost 30 years without giving a shit about all that guitar musicianship bullcrap. Nothing worse than watching somebody showoff for a hour or more. So I say Bernard.

0 likes

steve caton kristin hersh hue williams bb king jimmy page

0 likes

Jeff Beck Porl Thompson John Cipollina Jorma Kaukonen Ronnie Wood

0 likes

Kinda like post your top 5 sexually transmitted diseases to me, but I'll TRY....

Steve Hillage Robert Fripp Pat Metheny Larry la londe The bloke who plays "the heat ray" in the musical version of WOTW, playing a fuckin METAL LES PAUL!

0 likes

Digi Mike Binoche wrote: The one and only STEVE HILLAGE by a country mile

What do you recommend, for the uninitiated, Diggy?

0 likes

Mathew Ashman Rory Gallagher John Lee Hooker Chet Atkins Glen Tilbrook

Mathew Ashman is easily as good as Rory Gallagher.:thumb:

0 likes

Jimmy Buffett Jimmy Buffett Jimmy Buffett Jimmy Buffett Jimmy Buffett

0 likes

Has no one mentioned Johnny Greenwood?

oh well....

0 likes

Burt Reynolds wrote: Has no one mentioned Johnny Greenwood?

oh well....

Overrated, methinks.:\ohwell:

0 likes

Christopher Owens wrote:

Burt Reynolds wrote: Has no one mentioned Johnny Greenwood?

oh well....

Overrated, methinks.:\ohwell:

its a musical preferences thing methinks.. ya love em or ya dont.. :dunno:

0 likes

1.) Pete Townshend 2.) Eric Clapton 3.) Stevie Jackson (Belle and Sebastian) 4.) Noel Gallagher 5.) Barney

:guitar:

0 likes

Comrade Shampanyov wrote:

Digi Mike Binoche wrote: The one and only STEVE HILLAGE by a country mile

What do you recommend, for the uninitiated, Diggy?

The Gliassando guitar at the start of Flying Teapot by Gong, it's the single nicest sound a guitar has EVER made, and no arguments PLEASE. Also, The Glorious Om Riff, the salmon song, and errrm Light in the Sky ( is that the song titled Diggy?), just by Steve Hillage. Oh and the full length Blue Room by theORB, has some amazing hillage solos on it, but unless you are familliar with his stlye, you wont recognise it as a guitar.

0 likes

Comrade, I have to agree with the Doctor.

All his choices are classic Hillage :)

0 likes

Neil Young Ian Mackaye Bernard Butler Bob Mould Nick McCabe (Verve) ... are all class :thumb: That newish guitarist in Wilco (Nels something?) can play as well :nod: CTB :bear:

0 likes
  1. Johnny Marr
  2. Johnny Marr
  3. Johnny Marr
  4. Johnny Marr
  5. Bernard
0 likes

Eric Clapton Neil Young Buddy Guy Robert Johnson Johnny Marr

0 likes

David Gilmour Lou Reed Josh Homme Tony Iommi Dean Ween

0 likes

In no order,

Hooky. Johnny Greenwood. Johnny Marr. Noel Gallagher. Barney.

0 likes

Shug wrote: Barney John Squire Johnny Marr Mick Jones Mark Day

Yes..with a bit of Vinni Reilly rounding out the top six,pour moi.

0 likes

Johnny Marr Graham Coxon The Edge Santana Bernard

0 likes

Mrs.Disco wrote:

The Edge

nothing without an effects pedal :nod:

0 likes

The Edge? If remember right-on "The Joshua Tree" he used something called an "Infinite Guitar" It is the size of a pick up and vibrates the strings. This creates infinte sustain. He can hold that note for a long time!!

A good example is "with or Without You" that long "whine" note? Infinite Guitar same with the repeated notes on the outro. beautiful playing but not much technical skill.

0 likes

DiscoShed wrote: The Edge? If remember right-on "The Joshua Tree" he used something called an "Infinite Guitar" It is the size of a pick up and vibrates the strings. This creates infinte sustain. He can hold that note for a long time!!

A good example is "with or Without You" that long "whine" note? Infinite Guitar same with the repeated notes on the outro. beautiful playing but not much technical skill.

It's called an E-bow, it's basically a hand-held elctromagnet that creates a localised feedback sustaining string vibration. I've always wanted to get one, but they aren't cheap. They're used loads - you can hear it being used on stuff by Pearl Jam, Radiohead, Cocteaus, REM, RHCP etc etc. CTB :bear:

0 likes

1.- Barney 2.- Jimi Hendix 3.- Keith Richards 4.- Johnny Marrs 5.- Graham Coxon

:thumb:

0 likes

Geordie Walker Paul Weller Will Sergeant John McGeoch Andy Gill

0 likes

Easy to pick the top one..... :bow: :bow: :bow:

Still pondering the other 4 but prob would have these guys somewhere in it

0 likes

Sumner Marr Squire Hooky and the two guys from the Chameleons sorry i dont know their names

0 likes

Sumner Marr Squire Hooky and the two guys from the Chameleons sorry i dont know their names

0 likes

Rick Banks wrote:

Hooky

:nono: Bassist!!

Guitarists please :shades:

0 likes

[orange]State of Love and Trust [/orange] wrote:

Rick Banks wrote:

Hooky

:nono: Bassist!!

Guitarists please :shades:

Maybe he picked him due his guitar work on "Atrocity Exhibition", "The Sound Of Music" and "Confusion". :D

0 likes

[orange]State of Love and Trust [/orange] wrote:

Mrs.Disco wrote:

The Edge

nothing without an effects pedal :nod:

DiscoShed wrote: The Edge? If remember right-on "The Joshua Tree" he used something called an "Infinite Guitar" It is the size of a pick up and vibrates the strings. This creates infinte sustain. He can hold that note for a long time!!

A good example is "with or Without You" that long "whine" note? Infinite Guitar same with the repeated notes on the outro. beautiful playing but not much technical skill.

Jack must have misunderstood his own thread: Post your 5 favorite guitarists. Not Post the 5 most technically skilled guitarists.

Personally, I've found that the most technically skilled guitarists are often the least interesting guitarists, and those with the most soul aren't very technically skilled; Neil Young may be the best example of that phenomenon.

0 likes

Comrade Shampanyov wrote:

[orange]State of Love and Trust [/orange] wrote:

Mrs.Disco wrote:

The Edge

nothing without an effects pedal :nod:

DiscoShed wrote: The Edge? If remember right-on "The Joshua Tree" he used something called an "Infinite Guitar" It is the size of a pick up and vibrates the strings. This creates infinte sustain. He can hold that note for a long time!!

A good example is "with or Without You" that long "whine" note? Infinite Guitar same with the repeated notes on the outro. beautiful playing but not much technical skill.

Jack must have misunderstood his own thread: Post your 5 favorite guitarists. Not Post the 5 most technically skilled guitarists.

Personally, I've found that the most technically skilled guitarists are often the least interesting guitarists, and those with the most soul aren't very technically skilled; Neil Young may be the best example of that phenomenon.

errr what you on about son

me commenting about the edge has nothing to do with the thread, it's just me throwing in my own opinion on him, seeing as someone mentioned him

0 likes

[orange]State of Love and Trust [/orange] wrote:

Comrade Shampanyov wrote:

[orange]State of Love and Trust [/orange] wrote:

Mrs.Disco wrote:

The Edge

nothing without an effects pedal :nod:

DiscoShed wrote: The Edge? If remember right-on "The Joshua Tree" he used something called an "Infinite Guitar" It is the size of a pick up and vibrates the strings. This creates infinte sustain. He can hold that note for a long time!!

A good example is "with or Without You" that long "whine" note? Infinite Guitar same with the repeated notes on the outro. beautiful playing but not much technical skill.

Jack must have misunderstood his own thread: Post your 5 favorite guitarists. Not Post the 5 most technically skilled guitarists.

Personally, I've found that the most technically skilled guitarists are often the least interesting guitarists, and those with the most soul aren't very technically skilled; Neil Young may be the best example of that phenomenon.

errr what you on about son

me commenting about the edge has nothing to do with the thread, it's just me throwing in my own opinion on him, seeing as someone mentioned him

OK, but this is a subjective poll about favorite guitarists. The Edge is on somebody's favorite guitarists list. Whether he's technically accomplished or not isn't relevant to the thread. Personally, most of the guitarists on your list don't impress me, John Frusciante excepted.

And if I had expanded my list to 10 favorite guitarists, I would have included Neil Young and Johnny Ramone, among others-- neither a technically accomplished guitarist, but still among my favorites.

0 likes

ok man fair enough but i just really don't like the edge!! or u2!!

:shrug:

0 likes

Jimmy Page Dave Gilmour Neil YOUNG SLASH Keith Richards and then MARR/BARNEY/SQUIRE

0 likes

CTB wrote:

DiscoShed wrote: The Edge? If remember right-on "The Joshua Tree" he used something called an "Infinite Guitar" It is the size of a pick up and vibrates the strings. This creates infinte sustain. He can hold that note for a long time!!

A good example is "with or Without You" that long "whine" note? Infinite Guitar same with the repeated notes on the outro. beautiful playing but not much technical skill.

It's called an E-bow, it's basically a hand-held elctromagnet that creates a localised feedback sustaining string vibration. I've always wanted to get one, but they aren't cheap. They're used loads - you can hear it being used on stuff by Pearl Jam, Radiohead, Cocteaus, REM, RHCP etc etc. CTB :bear:

Yep, the late great Stuart Adamson used to use on on The Storm.

0 likes

I came from the hills with a tear in my eye The winter closed in and the crows filled the sky The houses were burning the flames gold and red The people were running with eyes filled with dread Ah my James They didn't have to do this We chased them for miles I had hate in my eyes Through forest and moors as the clouds filled the skies The storm broke upon us with fury and flame Both hunters and hunted washed out in the rain I know I can never return To the time of hope when I was born Let the strength of peace run through my hand When we walk away from the ?stormy shore? Then I will be afraid no more And now I'm sure of where I stand Let the strength of peace run through this land And nobody smiled as we took back our own While rain beat upon us the thunder did moan And nobody smiled when we knew what was lost We knew well enough only time proves the cost

Another BIG COUNTRY fan TIM?:thumb:

0 likes

[orange]State of Love and Trust [/orange] wrote: ok man fair enough but i just really don't like the edge!! or u2!!

:shrug:

Fair enough, I guess our dislikes are also subjective and valid.

Now would you like to know what I think James Hetfield? :evil4:

0 likes

My top 5 guitarists would be:

  1. Pete Townshend
  2. Paul Weller
  3. The Edge
  4. Dave Gilmour
  5. Slash
0 likes

Comrade Shampanyov wrote:

[orange]State of Love and Trust [/orange] wrote: ok man fair enough but i just really don't like the edge!! or u2!!

:shrug:

Now would you like to know what I think James Hetfield? :evil4:

not really :shrug: :evil4:

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗