74 replies · 1,534 views
The US music scene is shite, always has been, always will be, apart from a dozen bands what have they really given us?
The UK on the other hand has given the world more great music than anyone else. Any of our american friends wish to prove me wrong? 
You name an american artist, i'll trump it with a better one from the uk...
Steve One wrote: The US music scene is shite, always has been, always will be, apart from a dozen bands what have they really given us?
The UK on the other hand has given the world more great music than anyone else. Any of our american friends wish to prove me wrong?
You name an american artist, i'll trump it with a better one from the uk...
Hendrix Beach Boys Plastikman Michael Jackson Public Enemy
Gazfella wrote:
King John Honest John wrote: Vanilla Ice.
this bozo is in Manny TONIGHT.
Are ye excited yet
I will be IF he sings, sorry RAPS, THAT song.
you remember THAT song.
DIGI MIKE don't yer know wrote: Talking Heads
Just how successful were Talking Heads in their homeland though?
Minority group, shirley?
Public Enemy American Music Club Low Galaxie 500 The Pixies Throwing Muses Mazzy Star The Velvet fucking Underground Motherfucking BEACH BOYS
Doctor Clayhead wrote: Motherfucking BEACH BOYS
Is that the legal name they've been forced to use now?
Bands and the courts: always ends in tears
El Jarvo wrote:
Doctor Clayhead wrote: The Pixies
Where's Liam when you need him?
crouching down with the bedroom door locked.
Many great jazz musicians and vocalists in the past came from the US: Stan Getz Dave Brubeck Paul Desmond Miles Davis John Coltrane Glenn Miller Benny Goodman Chet Baker
etc etc etc etc.....
leather_girl wrote: Many great jazz musicians and vocalists in the past came from the US: Stan Getz Dave Brubeck Paul Desmond Miles Davis John Coltrane Glenn Miller Benny Goodman Chet Baker
etc etc etc etc.....
England doesn't like Jazz dear. post some other names please.
El Jarvo wrote:
Doctor Clayhead wrote: The Pixies
Where's Liam when you need him?
Na na na-na-na, indeed!
oldmonkey wrote:
King John Honest John wrote: olivia newton john
aussie...
She was born in Wales, apparently her father was in the Secret Service during the war and arrested Rudolph Hess when he flew to Scotland. Emmigrated when she was 5.
Everyone seems to be saying im wrong and the yanks have given us all the best music, i give up! 
Steve One wrote: Everyone seems to be saying im wrong and the yanks have given us all the best music, i give up!
Don't! 
I'm working on it...! 
Steve One wrote: Everyone seems to be saying im wrong and the yanks have given us all the best music, i give up!
Damn right! Who else could give you:
Boston Journey White Snake Jefferson Aeroplane Survivor New Kids on the Block Styx
How can you Brits possibly compare to these awesome musical geniuses?
PAH!
Ryan Adams Bright Eyes The Rapture The Strokes Yeah Yeah Yeah's Aimee Mann Beastie Boys REM DJ Shadow Beck Bob Dylan Bruce Springsteen Prince Nirvana Scissor Sisters Polyphonic Spree Smashing Pumpkins
Steve One wrote: Everyone seems to be saying im wrong and the yanks have given us all the best music, i give up!
come on ste, the deal was , we present an argument and you shoot us down, i see no responses apart from agreeing about talking heads, more, more, more, dont give up on us now!!!
Metallica Alice In Chains Nine Inch Nails Red Hot Chili Peppers Stone Temple Pilots The Offspring Ramones Ministry Suicidal Tendencies
Jennifer-Sunshine Express & Cozzie
Indeed*!*
|| | ||| 6217|| 8 || 3 wrote: America invents music, while Britain picks it up and makes it better.
ask the rolling stones and beatles
King John Honest John wrote:
leather_girl wrote: Many great jazz musicians and vocalists in the past came from the US: Stan Getz Dave Brubeck Paul Desmond Miles Davis John Coltrane Glenn Miller Benny Goodman Chet Baker
etc etc etc etc.....
England doesn't like Jazz dear. post some other names please.
Jimi Hendrix. 'Sweet as Sugar. Smooth as Silk. Acid Blues, Chicago House..
BB King. Son Seals. Stevie Ray Vaughan. Eric Clapton.
Ministry. NIN. Pearl Jam!
|| | ||| 6217|| 8 || 3 wrote: America invents music, while Britain picks it up and makes it better.
Absolutly agree. Uk music wouldn´t be nothing without the roots of American music
Velvet Underground Doors Ramones Devo Nine Inch Nails Smashing Pumpkins
and all New York indie rock scene 
JPS wrote:
|| | ||| 6217|| 8 || 3 wrote: America invents music, while Britain picks it up and makes it better.
ask the rolling stones and beatles
Better still, ask the black folks who really invented it...oh you can't, no one knows who they are cos no one would release their records, oh well.
B.B king The Ramones Jackson Browne Blondie The Doors Iggy Pop Beat Happening Bob Dylan
We have at the very least this to be gratefull for.
Take things back far enough and surely the 'godfather' of modern rock music was Mozart. He was the rebellious 'bad boy' of his time, broke with convention and played with the rules of scale, rhythm and harmony.
American bands that Steve can try to trump (love that word - fnarr) are:
Patti Smith New York Dolls Dead Kennedys EDIT: add The Smithereens to that!
Although I still agree that there are three or four British (not necessarily English) bands that wipe the floor with most American groups.
And what about the Australians? They've produced a fair bit of talent...
Being in Australia is interesting, watching the music scenes in both the US and UK. I have to say *most* US music is absolutely crap - in the commercial field. If you look at what is commercially viable, there's some great stuff from the US: Sufjan Stevens, 77's, Vigilantes of Love, etc.
Overall though, British music is far, far better (even though they've given us the Spice Girls, and James Blunt :barf: )
Chris Nash wrote: Take things back far enough and surely the 'godfather' of modern rock music was Mozart. He was the rebellious 'bad boy' of his time, broke with convention and played with the rules of scale, rhythm and harmony.
American bands that Steve can try to trump (love that word - fnarr) are:
Patti Smith New York Dolls Dead Kennedys EDIT: add The Smithereens to that!
Although I still agree that there are three or four British (not necessarily English) bands that wipe the floor with most American groups.
And what about the Australians? They've produced a fair bit of talent...
All hail The Smithereens!!! The Replacements Marvin Gaye Otis Redding Aretha Franklin Al Green James Brown Stevie Wonder Stevie Ray Vaughan Ella Fitzgerald
Doctor? wrote:
JPS wrote:
|| | ||| 6217|| 8 || 3 wrote: America invents music, while Britain picks it up and makes it better.
ask the rolling stones and beatles
Better still, ask the black folks who really invented it...oh you can't, no one knows who they are cos no one would release their records, oh well.
they may have been treated as second-class (or 5th-class) citizens, but were still Americans
Chris Nash wrote: And what about the Australians? They've produced a fair bit of talent...
Yer right, Air Supply is TOPS!
Chris Nash wrote: Take things back far enough and surely the 'godfather' of modern rock music was Mozart. He was the rebellious 'bad boy' of his time, broke with convention and played with the rules of scale, rhythm and harmony.
Yes, but modern pop and or rock doesn't does it, and the further back you go in the history of popular music, which is probably the 30's (ish), the less mould-breaking it becomes. Most of it is basic cycle of fifths, dominant resolution, and pentatonic, melodic minor, and mixoliydian melodies. Rocket science it aint.
However I suppose you could equate what Mozart did with melody, rhythm and harmony, to what modern music does with sounds. Mozart shocked by using notes in a different way, modern music uses distortion pedals and redlined amps, synths and effects to inflict the same stunning blow to the senses.
Fuckin hate 90% of his tunes too, most of em are like supermarket musak. Give me Gustav Holst any day. Went to a gig in the symphony hall on the lakefront in Chicago...the program....Mozart chamber music, Schnitka, Messien, stockhausen, Mozart orchestral stuff. OMG it was torture sitting through that. We were out the front smoking after the first Mozart and the first "wrong" compositions, talking to this ancient American lady who said "it's like a sandwich, they've stuck the most exquisite filling in between bread that I really don't like, in fact it's like they made the bread from crap". What a nice lady. Chicago symphony orchestra BTW...quite a band lemme tell you especially with about 90 of them on stage to accomodate all the weird instruments used in The Planets.
i realize this is not music related... so don't give me the 3rd degree... just a little humour if you will!
blair vs bush? is one better than the other! 
you make the call! 
Blair. He's a lying devious slimy spineless cunt. But he can read and write and find his arse with both hands.
|| | ||| 6217|| 8 || 3 wrote: Give me Paul Hindemith, Bela Bartok or Giorgy Ligeti
Ooooh ligeti.......mmmmmmmm 2001 a space odessy is like a pop video for him.
BillONdollar wrote: i realize this is not music related... so don't give me the 3rd degree... just a little humour if you will!
blair vs bush? is one better than the other!
you make the call!
0-0 AET. Far too much ET.
Hank Wiseass© wrote:
Steve One wrote: The US music scene is shite, always has been, always will be, apart from a dozen bands what have they really given us?
The UK on the other hand has given the world more great music than anyone else. Any of our american friends wish to prove me wrong?
You name an american artist, i'll trump it with a better one from the uk...
Hendrix Beach Boys Plastikman Michael Jackson Public Enemy
Plastikman is Canadian, No?
How about- Geoff Mills Derrick May Kevin Saunderson Arthur Baker Joey Beltram
RichShan wrote:
Plastikman is Canadian, No?
How about- Geoff Mills Derrick May Kevin Saunderson Arthur Baker Joey Beltram
Here's some of mine from the USA
Juan AtkinsCarl CraigKenny LarkinStacey PullenDJ PierreLarry HeardMobyLCD SoundsystemAfrika BambaataaMantronixEddie 'Flashin' FowlkesMarshall JeffersonTodd TerryJohn AcquavivaRon TrentArmand Van HeldenFischerspoonerFrankie KnucklesErick MorilloDavid MoralesMasters At WorkGrandmaster FlashDJ SneakRun DMCEric B And RakimLoleta HollowayJames Brown
Alan Paul Kitching wrote: Here's some of mine from the USA
Juan AtkinsCarl CraigKenny LarkinStacey PullenDJ PierreLarry HeardMobyLCD SoundsystemAfrika BambaataaMantronixEddie 'Flashin' FowlkesMarshall JeffersonTodd TerryJohn AcquavivaRon TrentArmand Van HeldenFischerspoonerFrankie KnucklesErick MorilloDavid MoralesMasters At WorkGrandmaster FlashDJ SneakRun DMCEric B And RakimLoleta HollowayJames Brown
As above plus Leadbelly, Woody Guthrie, Jimi Hendrix, Arthur Baker, A Tribe Called Quest, De La Soul, Jungle Brothers, Ice-T, Ice Cube, NWA, Public Enemy...
And the list could go on...
oldmonkey wrote:
14 K wrote: Eric Clapton.
You learn something new every day!
Indeed! Suppose the attraction is to the near untouchable Led Zeppelin John Bonham era..
Fascinating how Liz Phair, Saint Etienne- Sarah Cracknell crossed the Distance and appealed to so many.
El Jarvo wrote:
DIGI MIKE don't yer know wrote: Talking Heads
Just how successful were Talking Heads in their homeland though?
Minority group, shirley?
most americans would recognize 'burning down the house' or 'road to nowhere' but, yes, they were never a top 40 band (although little creatures did quite well).
EdelBrock wrote:
Chris Nash wrote: And what about the Australians? They've produced a fair bit of talent...
Yer right, Air Supply is TOPS!
you may say that in jest, but air supply really do rock.
Buffy wrote:
El Jarvo wrote:
DIGI MIKE don't yer know wrote: Talking Heads
Just how successful were Talking Heads in their homeland though?
Minority group, shirley?
most americans would recognize 'burning down the house' or 'road to nowhere' but, yes, they were never a top 40 band (although little creatures did quite well).
it's funny, but I hear more Talking Heads tracks on the "classic" rock station out here than I do from people such as Steve Miller, Boston, etc. and not just the big hits either. YMMV where one lives, it seems.
