General consensus around here seems to be that most music papers are pretty much worthless these days. One habit I've not yet overcome is checking out The Village Voice's year end music poll Pazz and Jop, where a bunch of writers send in their top 10 lists and Robert Christgau compiles them.
NO comes in at a decent enough #22, and tied for #15 on the singles list with Crystal. Of course, people are gonna quibble with the listing etc. (I don't really think Dylan's latest album is the best of the year) but that goes with the territory when dealing with such things. http://www.villagevoice.com/specials/pazznjop/01/