BARNEY REPLACEMENT

SCENARIO..Barney has left the band so who sings then? or do they draft in a new singer like they did with the bass player....Mr Peter Hook?

oh bollocks to that.

Time to get another life if that happened.

Never mind that, when Gillian left she should've been replaced by Johnny Marr. Would've spared him the Cribs too.

If Barney left - there is no future. My view is this - Barney wrote the majority of the songs, Barney sings the majority of songs, therefore it doesn't matter who the musicians are, you are seeing the material performed by the singer and songwriter! I often wonder why he didn't go with Bernard Sumner rather than Bad L?

'WELSHCAKE' wrote: SCENARIO..Barney has left the band so who sings then? or do they draft in a new singer like they did with the bass player....Mr Peter Hook?

I would vote for the the teleprompter that he uses. It might not sing as out of note but at least it would be on cue all the time.

I thought you would have gone for the Madonna Boys

Surface wrote: If Barney left - there is no future. My view is this - Barney wrote the majority of the songs, Barney sings the majority of songs, therefore it doesn't matter who the musicians are, you are seeing the material performed by the singer and songwriter! I often wonder why he didn't go with Bernard Sumner rather than Bad L?

'WELSHCAKE' wrote: SCENARIO..Barney has left the band so who sings then? or do they draft in a new singer like they did with the bass player....Mr Peter Hook?

I tend to agree with you here, but it HAS happened with other bands. Look at UB40 and yes, Section 25, albeit under inevitable circumstances!

Bring back Steve to the front as he was in 1980