Skip to content

Sponsored by Taboo #7 - most under-rated New Order song

Archived

30 replies · 596 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Which song do you think is not given the credit it deserves ?

Closed
  • Everything's Gone Green 12 (22%)
  • Confusion 6 (11%)
  • We All Stand (Alex Staszko gig request mix) 0 (0%)
  • Sooner Than You Think 9 (17%)
  • Way Of Life 7 (13%)
  • Guilty Partner 1 (2%)
  • Everyone Everywhere 5 (9%)
  • Close Range 7 (13%)
  • Skullcrusher 1 (2%)
  • ICB 6 (11%)

54 votes · voting closed

Again my choices, not Tabsy's. Probably all wrong, but hey who cares. It's not like it's important or anything.

0 likes

i really love sooner than you think! it's one of my faves on low-life

0 likes

Kind of a hard pick between Everyone Everywhere and the recently re-discovered Sooner Than You Think...

I went for Everyone Everywhere though... kind of tune you listen to alone in the dark ;)

0 likes

hmmm...since Rock the Shack isn't here...I guess I'll go with way of life...I always forget about it...until I hear it...

0 likes

They're all crackers, but ICB for me. Turn the lights out, pour yourself a double vodka, slam the Peel Sessions (vinyl) version on and admire. This is an audiophile masterpiece.

0 likes

went the way of Sooner Than You Think, but just wish one of the recorded versions of Confusion could have captured the power of the early live versions, & it owuld have been there!!

0 likes

ICB... Dead Souls Pt. 2!

0 likes

i felt ICB or Everythings gone green where less credited so.. i dunno i have to think on it:scratch:

0 likes

sooner than you think. close range a close second.

0 likes

EGG for me.

0 likes

EGG is clearly underrated, but I had to vote for ICB because the whole Movement album is underrated! (It's a better song than The Him, for example.) Close Range is also one of the 4 best songs on Get Ready, so that came "close" too.

0 likes

I voted for ICB also. I guess I'm one of the few who really enjoys Movement. ICB is my second favorite track off the album next to DNE.

0 likes

EGG: it has the unfortunate distinction of coming in between two masterpieces (Ceremony and Temptation) and thus often gets ignored by even the devoted, nutcase fans (not to mention the fair-weather ones) :thumb:

0 likes

Oh, I don't know about that Tabsy, at least from what I've noticed, but then I've always played the 12" quite frequently, so I may be a bit biased on that view.

My vote went for Close Range.

0 likes

Confusion. I always thought it was a better dance track than Blue Monday. And the '87 version is seriously overlooked.

0 likes

EGG for me. Bring it back live Mr Sumner.

0 likes

Dunno how "underrated" STYT is: I recall the Melody Maker that came out the week of Reading '93 had a big feature on the band, and they reckoned it was their finest moment ever. Got a feeling it was written by well-known Order devotee Paul Lester (currently, I think, co-editor at "Uncut").

0 likes

EGG

0 likes

EGG (Taras version) :nod:

0 likes

In case anyone's wondered what the "Alex Staszko gig request mix" is all about, most UK bootlegs between 1983 and 1987 have a lone voice shouting "We All Stand" in between songs. That was Alex (or his inflatable skeleton Ian). It never mattered if they'd already played it in the set, he still shouted it anyway !

0 likes

EGG. So much better than Blue Monday :D.

0 likes

I reckon EGG gets plenty of credit (1st attempt at learning how to produce/last production with Hannett/1st time the 7" was edited down from the full version/etc, etc) so I'll go with Guilty Partner which tends to get lost amongst brighter stars on Technique.

0 likes

Is EGG really 'under-rated'? I thought most people here loved it. I've gone with that anyways. It's the one with the biggest bollocks.

As for the rest, I can take 'em or leave 'em. In fact, a couple I'd rather just leave - WAS, STYT, GP.

0 likes

My vote goes to Confusion (the Substance version - way better than the original IMO).

0 likes

i picked skullcrusher because i thought the live verions with the vocals were pretty good, they had some interesting guitar parts i especially like the version they opened up a show in amsterdam in 1984

0 likes

Everyone Everywhere at Montreaux. What a graceful performance.

0 likes

Confusion. The original version,pre-substance is up there with Temptation. Its a real shame the live version is based around the 87 mix.:nod:

0 likes

icb for me i agree the john peel version was definitely the best:thumb:

0 likes

M E S H not only it didn't appear even on Retro, but neither on this poll! And it's one of thier Top 5 for me! It's even been the name of A New Order Fan for a month...

0 likes

Originally posted by Spotnick Kind of a hard pick between Everyone Everywhere and the recently re-discovered Sooner Than You Think...I went for Everyone Everywhere though... kind of tune you listen to alone in the dark ;)

I'll go w/Sooner, though it's not the most interesting song lyrically, it is beautiful to listen too and deeply unusual.

I was a big fan of everyone everywhere, but the live version of that has always left a bad taste in my mouth, it's absolutely horrible. One of the worst New Order tunes when it comes to "great" New Order songs that were performed live.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗