Another New Order rehearsals leaked? — Forum Archive

4 Apr 2004, 14:31

Can anyone confirm if this is legit or not?

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=43633&item=4004221935

-Paul

4 Apr 2004, 14:48

It's a soundcheck. Nothing much to get excited about.

4 Apr 2004, 14:49

Well no it isn't legit, it's a bootleg ! It is probably from a soundcheck. Don't think they've ever been playing Isolation and Age of Consent at the same time (well I know they haven't).

Straight onto DAT from the mixer ?????

4 Apr 2004, 16:14

hmmmmm..... :confused2:

4 Apr 2004, 16:24

some poor sod has paid 21 quid for this :jawdrop:

4 Apr 2004, 17:08

Would be nice to get to the truth of this. Why do I suspect that Isolation was taken from the '98 BBC recording? Interesting the blurb for AoC refers to Hooky as "Pete"...not a real fan? Of course not, given this stinks of ripoff...who knows where the other two tracks were taken from, they don't ring any bells.

Isolation live seems to have been played at all the '98 gigs, and at Olympia and Fuji 2001, and Horden Pavilion Sydney and Metro Melborune 2002.

However...the last soundcheck recording I see listed at Waterrat is for Santa Barbara 07 Nov 86...I guess after that time the band stopped doing the soundchecks themselves so there wasn't anything worth taping?

--Sam

5 Apr 2004, 03:10

Sounds dodgy,if the buyer is a NOOLer let us know.

5 Apr 2004, 08:22

they even managed to misspell blue monday! :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

:nonono:

5 Apr 2004, 10:08

So if they are a Nooler and its legit,they will be making 2000 copies or if its jarg they paid a lot of money for fac all. lose/lose situation me thinks.

5 Apr 2004, 10:12

Originally posted by The Happy One However...the last soundcheck recording I see listed at Waterrat is for Santa Barbara 07 Nov 86...I guess after that time the band stopped doing the soundchecks themselves so there wasn't anything worth taping?

Where do you get your assumed info from ? Just because Water Rat doesn't list any soundchecks after Santa Barbara doesn't mean they stopped doing them ! They still do them themselves, always have. They probably don't have all the band on stage at any one time in the soundchecks as often as they used to these days, but they still have them. The reason for the lack of soundcheck listings on Water Rat's site is probably to do with a change in the type of venues they played after 1987 - venues that wouldn't be quite so amenable to people sneaking in and watching/taping the soundcheck.

5 Apr 2004, 10:46

Originally posted by Mr Hibster they even managed to misspell blue monday!

FCUK ME this wouldn't get past QUALITY CONTROL at PLANET ROCKET. 1.SPELLING MISTAKE 2.CROSSING OUT Get Real people. MINTY MINT or FCUK OFF. :laugh:

5 Apr 2004, 10:52

Yeah but what if it is real & as the description claims,theres only one out there Mick?

5 Apr 2004, 11:01

Originally posted by steve52 Yeah but what if it is real & as the description claims,theres only one out there Mick?

There was only one turd in the bog at our office this morning. Didn't make it worth spending twenty quid on.

5 Apr 2004, 12:34

Originally posted by steve52 Yeah but what if it is real & as the description claims,theres only one out there Mick?

Do you believe in Father Christmas as well? There have been two this week that I know of, the one above and another that went for £14. It's crap, end of. But people really will buy anything, as the £35 quid in this blokes back pocket proves.

5 Apr 2004, 13:01

I didnt know there was another one knocking about.

5 Apr 2004, 13:22

Originally posted by steve52 I didnt know there was another one knocking about.

are you saying you bought this one? :skeptic:

5 Apr 2004, 15:28

this seller is a bit of a chancer, he's selling water now! http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=324&item=2997319267

5 Apr 2004, 15:30

and here are the other 'unique' rehearsal discs..... http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=43633&item=4004887160 http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=43633&item=4005221948

5 Apr 2004, 16:04

Originally posted by Mr Hibster > Originally posted by steve52> I didnt know there was another one knocking about.

are you saying you bought this one? :skeptic:

No. i cant stand these people on ebay tryin to rip people off,i`ve been outbid by that kind before-only for them to relist it for twice as much.

5 Apr 2004, 16:06

Originally posted by johnny james and here are the other 'unique' rehearsal discs.....http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=43633&item=4004887160http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=43633&item=4005221948

just had a look at your link. would it be wrong to inform the buyer he`s being conned?

5 Apr 2004, 17:24

Originally posted by steve52 Yeah but what if it is real & as the description claims,theres only one out there Mick?

But i KNOW it is FAKE and even if it was REAL i only collect items NOW that are very pleasing to the eye.No cover....no novelty value and most importantly i have to buy the items after i have searched them down in a shop or market.All part of the fun.But WHY people are conned like this is beyond me.A little research or indeed a question or two on this forum would enlighten most people. Cheers ROCKET MICK

5 Apr 2004, 17:41

Originally posted by Detweiler 3.63

Where do you get your assumed info from ?

Just because Water Rat doesn't list any soundchecks after Santa Barbara doesn't mean they stopped doing them ! They still do them themselves, always have. They probably don't have all the band on stage at any one time in the soundchecks as often as they used to these days, but they still have them.

The supposition was *purely* based on the lack of recordings listed on Waterrat, that's all. Maybe "I guess" wasn't clear enough, sorry. :(

The reason for the lack of soundcheck listings on Water Rat's site is probably to do with a change in the type of venues they played after 1987 - venues that wouldn't be quite so amenable to people sneaking in and watching/taping the soundcheck

Right, this explanation makes sense. But what in general, no need to name names, are the sources for *your* information to the contrary?

I'd thought that as they got more popular and the venues got larger, they'd just have the road crew handle it...natural ass-umption to make. It's good to see they're still involved with soundchecks!

6 Apr 2004, 03:37

My evidence to the contrary is personal attendance at soundchecks, for a start !

6 Apr 2004, 04:03

One of Hookys longest soundchecks ever ,Avalon, NYC, just before Christmas ... Later at the gig itself, it sounded like everything had been turned up to a Tap friendly 11.

Laziest soundchecker, Mick Jones B.A.D. tours, Flea did them all ( London Flea, not t'other one ) I digress... Carry on Fawlty

6 Apr 2004, 04:08

I cant belive you managed to get Big Audio Dynamite into a thread about a New Order s/c. One last blast before you go away mate?

6 Apr 2004, 04:18

Originally posted by steve52 I cant belive you managed to get Big Audio Dynamite into a thread about a New Order s/c. One last blast before you go away mate?

Yeah, go later today, maybe someone should do a ' who is the best one fingered keyboard maestro, Gillian or Don Letts ? There you go another B.A.D insurgence :D

6 Apr 2004, 04:21

And Don didn't have a floppy disc roadie either :evil4: :evil4:

And another B.A.D foray into a NO thread :D