Odd One Out ?
Archived27 replies · 512 views
Which is the odd one out of these tracks, and why ?
Closed-
New Dawn Fades 4 (27%)
-
Atmosphere 7 (47%)
-
Heart And Soul 1 (7%)
-
She's Lost Control 3 (20%)
15 votes · voting closed
She's lost control , it's the only song title Gary Whelan wrote on his tom-tom's when he was with the Happy Mondays![]()
New Dawn Fades , it's the only one that is a veiled tribute to Martin Hannet and his studio habits .
Originally posted by Garymac New Dawn Fades , it's the only one that is a veiled tribute to Martin Hannet and his studio habits .
![]()
New Dawns Fades.
Its the only one that:
- Wasn`t a single.
- New Order didnt perform regularly in recent years.
- er,...it just is.
Originally posted by SPtwo New Dawns Fades.Its the only one that:1. Wasn`t a single.2. New Order didnt perform regularly in recent years.3. er,...it just is.
Heart And Soul was a single?
Must've missed out on that one then.
My vote is Atmosphere, the only track that, at the time of its release, wasn't included on the album proper.
I chose Atmosphere. It is the least "punk" sounding of the three I think, much slower and sad doesnt exactly get the crowd moving like the others. Good song still, just different.
Originally posted by Green > Originally posted by SPtwo New Dawns Fades.Its the only one that:1. Wasn`t a single.2. New Order didnt perform regularly in recent years.3. er,...it just is.
Heart And Soul was a single?
Must've missed out on that one then.
My vote is Atmosphere, the only track that, at the time of its release, wasn't included on the album proper. Heart And Soul was never a single, Atmosphere was the b-side of Dead Souls (that Sordide Sentimetale thing) and was never intended for inclusion on any album.
I will stand by the original answer, which will be revealed tomorrow (though nobody has given the correct reason yet !), even though the answer may actually change between now and tomorrow.....
The correct reason has a link to tonights gig , featuring Digital and Re-Order , I also stand by your original answer and expect to recieve a goody bag sooner than a Brazilian postman can offer an excuse ![]()
You won't be playing 'Atmosphere' tonight, as it's too hard to replicate Ian Curtis' off-key singing on the opening line.
Originally posted by Slippy Atmosphere isn't on a standard album?
It's on "Substance 1977-1980", "Permanent" and the "Heart And Soul" boxset (which includes the early version when it was called "Chances"), go forth Slippy mate.
Originally posted by Spotnick Atmosphere is the only song name with 1 word, all others have 3 :p
you wanna count that again
"she's" is two words surely :D
Originally posted by Geri > Originally posted by Spotnick> Atmosphere is the only song name with 1 word, all others have 3 :p
you wanna count that again
"she's" is two words surely :D
Whatever, I wasn't sure if they really count contractions as 2 words :p
The correct answer was.........
Heart and Soul, because we weren't playing it at the gig last night. As soon as I get hold of the video footage from last night, I shall make a copy available. Unfortunately the tape recording didn't happen, as the mic wasn't switched on (BBC eh !!). We'll get a recording next time.
Originally posted by Spotnick Atmosphere is the only song name with 1 word, all others have 3 :p
What? ![]()
Originally posted by Spotnick > Originally posted by Geri> > > > Originally posted by Spotnick> > Atmosphere is the only song name with 1 word, all others have 3 :p>
you wanna count that again
"she's" is two words surely :D
Whatever, I wasn't sure if they really count contractions as 2 words :p Nope, contractions count as one word.