Skip to content

JD vs. the Doors

Archived

5 replies · 323 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

We've all heard the comparisons between Joy Division and the Doors, but it's never made much sense to me. What JD song do you think sounds most like the Doors?

My nomination is Decades, easily. I thought of the Doors the first time I heard it, and I don't even really like the Doors!

0 likes

We All Stand... looks a lot like "The End" isn't it? :scratch:

At least the lyrics...

0 likes

Both singers have that baritone voice. Both a bit moody. I can see the comparison.

I've been listening to Revenge, amazed at how much Hooky's voice can sound like Ian Curtis.

Perhaps he should have a stab at singing a bit more. He needs to practice so he's ready for when Barney completely forgets how to do it.

0 likes

to me they sound completely different, nothing like each other at all. this would never come up if they both hadn't lost a lead singer

0 likes

Actually, it would have...

Ian Curtis was a huge Doors fan, and Jim Morrisons singing was obviously a huge influence on Ian.

Listen to Morrison sing "Riders on the Storm", and you can easily picture Ian singing it, its si similar in style (the vocals).

I can hear a lot of the Doors in JD's music as well, the general moodiness of it all.

Ill say without shame, I like the Doors. Morrison is overrated as a lyricist (Ian was miles better) but the music is really good.

0 likes

Zachery Starkey wrote: Actually, it would have...

Ian Curtis was a huge Doors fan, and Jim Morrisons singing was obviously a huge influence on Ian.

Listen to Morrison sing "Riders on the Storm", and you can easily picture Ian singing it, its si similar in style (the vocals).

I can hear a lot of the Doors in JD's music as well, the general moodiness of it all.

Ill say without shame, I like the Doors. Morrison is overrated as a lyricist (Ian was miles better) but the music is really good.

Actually, if we're to believe Hooky, Riders on the Storm was a song that JD covered live.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗