Ultimate Survivor suggestion... — Forum Archive

18 Apr 2005, 05:55

With 8 albums in the bag shouldnt we have a survivor for all the winners of all the albums?

Obviously wait until the WFTSC debacle has been resolved but then stick the winners of each album head to head.. :evil4:

18 Apr 2005, 06:53

DoN wrote: With 8 albums in the bag shouldnt we have a survivor for all the winners of all the albums?

Obviously wait until the WFTSC debacle has been resolved but then stick the winners of each album head to head..

I think Movement has never been done either, and then we have tunes like Here To Stay...

I might push it to include Closer and Unknown Pleasures in the lot :evil4:

18 Apr 2005, 07:02

Spotnick wrote: I think Movement has never been done either, and then we have tunes like Here To Stay...

Hmmm. I wonder what on earth might possibly win Movement?! :skeptic: :laugh:

18 Apr 2005, 07:08

Monster wrote:

Spotnick wrote: I think Movement has never been done either, and then we have tunes like Here To Stay...

Hmmm. I wonder what on earth might possibly win Movement?!

It's not like it's going to be a surprise for anyone, is it? :D

18 Apr 2005, 07:09

Prior Survivors:

[innerurl=MessageList.aspx?ThreadID=7509]Get Ready Survivor[/innerurl]

[innerurl=MessageList.aspx?ThreadID=8370]Substance Survivor[/innerurl]

[innerurl=MessageList.aspx?ThreadID=8613]Technique Survivor[/innerurl]

[innerurl=MessageList.aspx?ThreadID=8749]Power, Corruption and Lies Survivor[/innerurl]

[innerurl=MessageList.aspx?ThreadID=9028]Republic Survivor[/innerurl]

18 Apr 2005, 07:10

Are you sure we didn't do Movement? There were all these protests from the Doubts Even Here fan that his song had been eliminated!

18 Apr 2005, 07:11

Spotnick wrote:

I might push it to include Closer and Unknown Pleasures in the lot

Not such a bad call - the JD ones would at least be a bit more closely contested.

18 Apr 2005, 07:14

Hey, we never did Low-Life?

Why do I doubt that? :skeptic:

18 Apr 2005, 07:20

oldmonkey wrote: Are you sure we didn't do Movement? There were all these protests from the Doubts Even Here fan that his song had been eliminated!

I had the same thoughts, but I can't find it if it was done.

I believe we only did a "best of" poll, but I doubt the outcome would change.

18 Apr 2005, 07:27

oldmonkey wrote: Are you sure we didn't do Movement? There were all these protests from the Doubts Even Here fan that his song had been eliminated!

Didn't we have a best of instead (a format I actually prefer, although it would be nice - but complicated - to have, say, your top 3, each weighted accordingly).

I think DNE got about 50% of the vote though, didn't it?!

18 Apr 2005, 08:27

Spotnick wrote: Hey, we never did Low-Life?

Why do I doubt that?

Low Life was missed out?!! thats a travesty!!!

18 Apr 2005, 08:34

There are at least four tracks off Low-life that should be put in a "best off" poll without even having to "qaulify".

Word up.

18 Apr 2005, 09:03

Low-Life will be complicated because TPK is the edited version... that will cause problems to the people voting...

Otherwise, it would be a sure win.

18 Apr 2005, 09:37

Spotnick wrote: Low-Life will be complicated because TPK is the edited version... that will cause problems to the people voting...

Otherwise, it would be a sure win.

I'll nail my colours to the mast already - I'll be supporting Sunrise & PFD . . . & thats all :skeptic:

18 Apr 2005, 10:20

BERNE pool of broadcasting corporations wrote:

Spotnick wrote: Low-Life will be complicated because TPK is the edited version... that will cause problems to the people voting...

Otherwise, it would be a sure win.

I'll nail my colours to the mast already - I'll be supporting Sunrise & PFD . . . & thats all

in the overall one or in the low life one?

you could do non album singles & then b sides too.

18 Apr 2005, 10:26

hibster wrote:

BERNE pool of broadcasting corporations wrote:

Spotnick wrote: Low-Life will be complicated because TPK is the edited version... that will cause problems to the people voting...

Otherwise, it would be a sure win.

I'll nail my colours to the mast already - I'll be supporting Sunrise & PFD . . . & thats all

in the overall one or in the low life one?

you could do non album singles & then b sides too.

Great suggestion. My vote also is for a separate non-album singles Survivor, and a separate B-sides Survivor. And finish off any albums that haven't gone (Movement, Low-Life?). Then face all the songs against each other. I'll hazard a guess - Temptation is the ultimate victor.

18 Apr 2005, 18:27

Maybe State of the Nation will come back and win it all.

18 Apr 2005, 22:29

If it did, I'd question the State of the Forum _"Yes it's the State of the Forum, that's lacking in Decorum" :D