Skip to content

WFTSC - 4/5 stars from Rolling Stone (Issue 973)

Archived

13 replies · 556 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Orderly Return Ranking New Wave influences make smashing comeback

New Order have nothing to regret. If they'd broken up when Ian Curtis died, they'd still be remembered as Joy Division. If they'd broken up after the 1982 single "Temptation", they'd be remembered for the most achingly emotional seven-and-a-half minute New Wave disco twelve-inch of all time. If they'd broken up after Low-life, in 1985, they'd be remembered for the most influential electro-vampire post-punk limp-wristed goth-twit album of the Eighties. But they didn't break up. They just keep making brilliant new records and inspiring brilliant new bands, such as the Killers, Bloc Party and Interpol.

They took a break in the 1990s, cleansing their systems of toxic chemicals and even fuglier side projects. (Revenge? Electronic? Monaco? Jesus!) If their 2001 Get Ready was a toe-dip return, Waiting for the Sirens' Call is their best since Technique, taking the "Blue Monday" beat into new wakced-out realms.

Bernard Sumner still sings and strums with his boyish air of distractable pique, and he writes some of the most genius crap lyrics around ("The world is a beautiful place/With mountains, lakes and the human race"). His secret is his sincerity, the way he whoops and yelps through blood-curdling poetry that a more clever singer would shame himself trying to play straight. But he'd be nowhere without Peter Hook, the Keith Richards of the bass, and drummer/pinup boy Stephen Morris. They outdo themselves with the sleek pop uplift of "Krafty", the robot clank of "I Told You So", the moody shimmer of "Turn" and the towering title track. Every song is great, except the one called "Dracula's Castle". What more could a fan ask?

/s/ Rob Sheffield

Key Tracks: "I Told You So", "Krafty", "Turn".

0 likes

Still don't get it why everyone hates Dracula so much. :shrug:

0 likes

I would expect there would be a lot of newspaper reviews tomorrow.

0 likes

I thought maybe USA Today would have a review last Friday for their weekend edition, but I haven't heard anything.

A cool thing about the RS review is that NO got their own headline and "boxed in" review to separate them from four other reviews on the same page. Quite cool, indeed.

0 likes

LE Roberts wrote: ...remembered for the most influential electro-vampire post-punk limp-wristed goth-twit album of the Eighties.

I love that part... I never listened to the album that way... :wink:

0 likes

Apologies for the repeat of Who's Joe post on 4/20 with this review. I just got the magazine today and I didn't see the post buried on the fourth page of that thread.

0 likes

No offense taken, just happy to see that this review was so kind, considering the snide review available on allmusic.com.

Cheers!!

Who's Joe?

0 likes

Very kind indeed. People have their own opinions about reviews, but to have such a positive one in a magazine of that caliber is great to see. Happy for NO. Just wish it was more of a "tour" this go-around. Perhaps in '06-'07 [insert holding breath]...

Cheers to you, Joe.

0 likes

Beatrix Kiddo wrote: Still don't get it why everyone hates Dracula so much. :shrug:

I guess you don't get why so many people love Guilt so much too... :wink:

0 likes

LE Roberts wrote: If they'd broken up after Low-life, in 1985, they'd be remembered for the most influential electro-vampire post-punk limp-wristed goth-twit album of the Eighties.

What the fcuk is limp-wristed about Low-Life?! :confused2:

0 likes

Beatrix Kiddo wrote: Still don't get it why everyone hates Dracula so much. :shrug:

I hate the title but the rest reminds me so much of technique era NO.

0 likes

mike watson wrote:

Beatrix Kiddo wrote: Still don't get it why everyone hates Dracula so much. :shrug:

I hate the title but the rest reminds me so much of technique era NO.

yes, sounds like an uninspired rehashed leftover from the Technuique era

0 likes

pumped full of drugs wrote:

mike watson wrote:

Beatrix Kiddo wrote: Still don't get it why everyone hates Dracula so much. :shrug:

I hate the title but the rest reminds me so much of technique era NO.

yes, sounds like an uninspired rehashed leftover from the Technuique era

Funny how the REAL leftovers from the Technique era (e.g., Don't Do It, MTO, Best and Marsh) are so damn good.

0 likes

The Technique leftovers are great, but Dracula is probably my least favorite track on the new album. It sounds more of a re-hash than a re-invigorated Technique song.

I wouldn't go so far to say Bernard's lyrics are crap, but they can be genius at times. Genius Crap is an interesting phrase.

I never thought of Stephen as a pinup boy - I'll leave that for the female New Order fans to debate.

The best thing about the review was that I finally know why I love Low-life so much. Thanks Rolling Stone. ;)

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗