Skip to content

In response to Spin's crappy list

Archived

17 replies · 608 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Here's mine (of top 20 most influential, imho)

  1. The Beatles
  2. Led Zepplin
  3. Sex Pistols
  4. Bob Dylan
  5. The Who
  6. The Clash
  7. Joy Division/New Order
  8. Public Enemy
  9. Ramones
  10. Pink Floyd
  11. Velvet Underground
  12. U2
  13. John Lennon (solo)
  14. Kraftwerk
  15. Lou Reed (solo)
  16. Radiohead
  17. Oasis
  18. NWA
  19. Nirvana
  20. The Doors

Sorry couldn't think of 50.....anyway I tried to refelct reality, but I had to stick JD/NO in the top ten at least.

0 likes

Keep in mind, I don't care for Ozzy or NWA, but you can't deny their influence on the crap of today

0 likes

No Dylan Tabsy? :nonono: Surely the best lyricist of all-time (his voice isn't upto much though;) ) And surely a very big influence on numerous bands of today:nod:

0 likes

Okay, rectified that situation (see my revised list)

0 likes

Not a definitive list, more some notable omitions

Hendrix Beach Boys Marvin Gaye Stevie Wonder larry Levant Prince Michael Jackson D.J. Pierre Stone Roses Alfredo Weatherall

0 likes

how come ABBA nor the Village People ever make any list of most influential/best etcetera????

of course, I probably already know the answer to this one!!!!

0 likes

It's horrifying to see Richard Marx and Whitney Houston name-checked as influences by the boy-band/sexy jailbait contengiant.....:headoff:

0 likes

Surely the top of the list should be Mike Flowers Pop's ?

0 likes

Dylan, The Beatles, The Pistols, Led Zep, The Stones, JD/NO, Radiohead, Clash, Doors, The Band, Velvet Underground, Hendrix, Kraftwerk, Michael Jackson, Ramones, Nirvana, Stone Roses.

0 likes

Oh yeah, Michael Jackson....pre-child molesting years, I have to admit I was a fan (thought to be fair you coudln't escape him in the 80's. President Reagan made it a national law to buy whatever products MJ endorsed)

0 likes

Tabsy - I've gotta be honest mate, I've never liked Wacko meself, but there's no taking away the fact, he was pretty influential to a lot of music thereafter;)

0 likes

Yeah, he owned the Eighties, he was the first black artist to break the rascist early MTV airwaves, and popularized urban music to such an extent that it made it easier for Rap to gain a foothold in its most important audience: middle-class white suburban youth. Whatever else he's done, you do gotta give MJ credit. That doesn't mean you have to like any of his songs, though...

0 likes

Originally posted by Taboo # 7 Yeah, he owned the Eighties, he was the first black artist to break the rascist early MTV airwaves, and popularized urban music to such an extent that it made it easier for Rap to gain a foothold in its most important audience: middle-class white suburban youth. Whatever else he's done, you do gotta give MJ credit. That doesn't mean you have to like any of his songs, though...

:nod: Yeah - agree with that mate.

0 likes

Unfrotuantely, though, he also made it easier for rap to become mainstream, and whenever that happens to any form of rock music (and yes, rap is an offshoot of punk rock. If you don't believe me ask Jon Savage), it loses that essential element that made it interesting in the first place. There's still some good stuff coming out, and i don't mean to negate the advancements made in the rap world from ten years ago, but a lot of rap today seems watered down compared to the original gangstas.

0 likes

Tabsy...

do you really think it was Jacko that made rap accessible to middle class white teens??? I'm going to have to disagree with you on that one and give that particular honor to the Beastie Boys...or maybe even Run DMC...

JUst remember my first experiences with the rap type thing...and I can't say that Michael influenced my decision to listen to these guys at all...

0 likes

and no-one's mentioned The Smiths?????

0 likes

Hmmmm, strange but true.

0 likes

I am very amazed not to have seen Mr David Bowies' name listed there, what else could be said about this man but definately top 20 material, he is a god!!!!!!

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗