Skip to content

PETER HOOK BASS INTERVIEW

Archived

48 replies · 2,806 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Found this as I was noodling around today. Apologies if this has been posted before but should be good for all the aspiring bassists out there...

New Order Restored

The Revolutionary Style of Peter Hook Leads a New Generation By Brian Fox | May 2005

There are watershed moments in rock & roll—like Woodstock or the Beatles’ Ed Sullivan Show appearance—that affect musicians so profoundly that they, in turn, go on to change the face of pop music. For punk and indie rock, one crucial event was the Sex Pistols’ June 4, 1976 show at Lesser Free Trade Hall in Manchester, England. In the opening slot, punk-pop’s pioneering Buzzcocks played its first gig. In the audience—which numbered only a few dozen—future members of Joy Division, New Order, the Smiths, and Simply Red stood shell-shocked as the Sex Pistols took the stage and unleashed their fury. Peter Hook, then a 21-year-old dockworker, was among them.

“It was incredible,” recals Hook, who attended the show with his childhood friend Bernard Sumner. “What I saw was so intense and wonderful that I decided to just go for it. I had never played a musical instrument before that, but the next day I went out and got a bass.”

Within a year, the two self-taught musicians formed Joy Division with singer Ian Curtis and drummer Stephen Morris, taking the name from the concentration-camp brothels set up by Nazi officers. Joy Division became the seminal post-punk band, harnessing the energy of punk and directing it inward. The dark, atmospheric soundscapes of anthems like “Love Will Tear Us Apart” and “She’s Lost Control” showcased Hook’s chorused tone and raw upper-register melodic bass lines, which snaked between Curtis’s melancholic vocals, Sumner’s angular guitar, and Morris’s mechanical beats.

In May 1980, just as the band’s star was beginning to rise in America, Curtis hanged himself. The remaining three re-formed as New Order later that year, adding Gillian Gilbert on keyboards and guitar. As in Joy Division, Hook’s high lead bass lines formed the core of the band’s songs, but New Order began integrating sequencers and synthesizers into its sound. New Order soon found itself at the center of a dance music craze as the Manchester club scene took off in the ’80s. The group’s 1983 song “Blue Monday” became the top-selling 12" single of all time, and the band continued to release hit dance tracks throughout the decade. New Order took a break in the ’90s, and Hook pursued two solo projects, Revenge and Monaco.

The last few months have been huge for “Hooky” and New Order. NME, the U.K.’s biggist music magazine, bestowed its Godlike Genius award to the band, and Germany’s Dance Music Awards presented it with a Lifetime Award. The BRIT Awards placed Joy Division’s “Love Will Tear Us Apart” in the top five of its 25 Best Songs Ever Written, and two Joy Division/New Order songs made the top 200 of Rolling Stone’s 500 Greatest Songs of All Time. Echoes of Joy Division’s spooky gloom and New Order’s danceable pop reverberate across modern-rock radio, with new groups like Interpol, the Killers, the Bravery, and Kasabian evoking the sounds of both bands [see sidebar, page 102].

But for Peter Hook, there is no time for nostalgic revelry. He and his bandmates continue to push boundaries on Waiting for the Sirens’ Call, a new release that combines classic New Order danceability with fresh-sounding pop. It’s a mixed bag that blends straightahead guitar rock, lo-fi garage rock, and even dancehall.

In the spring and summer, New Order will be on the road, playing the Coachella, Glastonbury, Oxegen, and T in the Park festivals in America and the U.K. The band will play close to a dozen other U.S. dates. “We’ll tour, but we’re too set in our ways to market ourselves heavily,” Hook says. “We’re not out to dominate the world again. After a while, you realize that you have a life outside the group and you have to look after it, so we are.” With Gillian Gilbert on sabbatical from the band since 2001, New Order’s current lineup is Hooky, Sumner, Morris, and guitarist Phil Cunningham, who became a full-time bandmember in 2004.

How would you describe your bass style, and how did it evolve? It’s melodic lead bass, I suppose. It was Ian who spotted that the relationship between high bass and low, chunky guitar was really interesting and unusual. My style of writing and playing came from that. Also, when I started playing bass I had an old Sunn bass cab with an 18" speaker. It was just dreadful—you couldn’t hear a bleedin’ thing. That was another reason I started playing so high, because the bottom end was just awful.

How has your style changed over the years? It hasn’t changed at all. I’m amazed I’ve gotten away with it for so long! I’ve definitely gotten better live—I don’t play half as many bum notes. But I still hit them. It’s part of the punk rock ethic. I’m perfectly happy with what I do, and I’ve never felt that it’s run its course. But it’s very difficult to come up with signature riffs like “She’s Lost Control,” “Twenty-Four Hours,” or “Krafty” [see music lesson, page 56]. I always pray to John Entwistle.

How did you write this new batch of material? Steve has a barn on his farm that he’s converted into a studio, and we always record there. Mostly we just jam together. We all play live, and we each go off on our own tangents. Then we get the ideas together, carve them up, and develop them. We work on it in sections—it’s a proper jigsaw puzzle. The task of putting an album together is amazingly daunting. We basically worked 40-hour weeks for a year and a half to write it, and another nine months to record and mix it. It was quite intense work—it certainly does not get easier over time. But I always felt like I was making progress. The upshot of it was that it was very prolific, enthusiastic, and totally natural.

Does the new album sound different from 2001’s Get Ready? For Get Ready, we were able to write the way we did with Joy Division—minimizing the use of sequences. It sounded very fresh and very angry, but it lacked the subtlety and mellowness that New Order had. When we started playing those songs live, we found that a lot of the fun was missing.

How did you come up with your bass lines? I’m quite methodical in how I work them out. If a track is prepared, I do six or nine tracks of jamming, trying different ideas with different basses. When I’ve got all the riffs on tape, I sift through them to get the best ones. In a typical New Order song there’s an intro, a verse, a chorus, a bridge, and a break, so if I’ve got a riff for each, I’m rocking. One of my general rules of thumb is that I don’t really play over the verses, because of how I play lead bass. I take the breaks, Bernard’s vocals take over in the verses, and we compromise on the choruses.

How did you first go about learning? I was lucky because Bernard and I started learning together. Playing with someone else is a much faster way of learning than when you sit in your bedroom with a book. Plus, the punk scene at the time made everything totally accelerated. If you formed a band, you didn’t need to have any real material to play out.

When a teacher shows you what to do, then you’re off in a certain way immediately, and that’s the opposite way of how I did it. I’m almost anti-teaching. My son Jack just got into trouble at school because his music teacher was saying to him that all musicians read music. He told her, “My dad’s a musician, and he doesn’t read music.” And she gave him a detention. Ridiculous! So that’s the sort of thing I fight against. One of the beauties of New Order is that we don’t take ourselves very seriously. People have a very serious image of us because how our music has been presented, but we as people aren’t that serious.

What has been your typical live setup? My Alembic F2-B valve [tube] preamp goes to an Electro-Harmonix Clone Theory chorus pedal, then to a Crown DC-300A, a fantastic old valve power amp. I’ve used that setup for about 25 years. The Crown’s bottom end is amazing. At one point I had six of those old Crowns, but they kept going down all the time. I used to use a Roland SIP-301 preamp as well. I use two 15" Gauss 5460 speakers; they’re 20 years old, so they’re nice and soft, and they add distortion.

With Revenge and Monaco, I updated my setup to an Ampeg SVT. I would crank it up all the way when I played live. But in New Order, I have to keep my stage volume down. So now I’m trying to work out my sound with Ashdown. Ashdowns sound fantastic on the bottom end, but since I don’t actually play that many low notes, I’m checking out their guitar amps. I’ve been using an Ashdown guitar amp live in the studio, and it’s been absolutely amazing—it’s a wicked sound. But there’s something psychological about playing through a guitar amp.

What is it that you want out of an amp? Crunch, presence, and warmth—a crunchy softness. Being lead bass, it needs to have sustain. But mainly, I just need to know that if I switch an amp on, it’ll work. I’m paranoid—I’ve got five spare setups.

How do you get your tone? On the instrument, I leave the bass and treble knobs all the way up, but not the mids. I suppose I’m very lucky—my settings haven’t changed for 20 years. Bernard and Philly spend days and weeks searching for guitar tones. I sometimes get paranoid about not changing my sound, though. It’s a weird predicament that you feel when everyone around you is changing, but you’re not. But they all say, “What are you worried about? It sounds great!”

What basses do you play the most? The Eccleshall is perfect for playing live because of how it sings; the sustain is great. But it just doesn’t work well in the studio. For that, I always use the Yamaha BB1200s.

You don’t have onstage feedback problems with the hollowbody? Oh, I love the feedback!

Have you always played with a pick? Yes, because I like the attack and the physicality of banging away with a pick.

What strings do you use? Elite Bass Sensors. They’re fantastic. I use really heavy strings: .060, .065, .080, .105. They’re like tree trunks, and very hard on the fingers. Since I play high all the time, that’s how I get the strong-sounding bottom end. I also strung my 6-string with heavy strings, .050, .050, .060, .065, .085, .105. So it sounds nice and tight, but it kills your fingers after a couple of weeks off.

Do you play keyboards as well? I’ve written on keyboard for New Order, but I just love playing the bass, and all I want to do is play the bass.

What music do you like to listen to? I get into a lot of new music these days. I love Snow Patrol, Bloc Party, and Secret Machines, and I’m a great fan of the Zutons. The Kaiser Chiefs, Razorlite, and Kasabian are all brilliant. My son Jack is at the age where he’s digging it all. He’s good at spotting the stuff that sounds like Joy Division and New Order. He’ll bring it to me and say, “This sounds like you, Dad. Listen!” He gets more upset about it than I do. He’s just started playing bass himself. I’m delighted, because if he gets half as much out of it as I do, he’s going to be a very happy boy. It’s strange to be sitting around talking about bassists with your son. It’s quite sweet and touching, really.

Who are some of the bassists you admire? One hero of mine was John Jack Brunell of the Stranglers, because of how he’d play loud riffs. And I always liked the way Paul Simonon wore his bass with the Clash.

Live, you wear your bass down by your knees. Do you record sitting down? Recording is serious work, so when I’m doing it, I have to stand up and go for it.

When you play live, do you improvise much? No, it tends to all be written out beforehand. The problem I have is that when we play, I get really excited and run around like a fucking maniac, which leads to me playing some fantastically wrong notes! It’s all very strange, because I remember a time when I was very shy. But we turned from kids who played with our backs to the audience into leather-trousered, motorcycle boot-wearing, groin-thrusting lunatics. I don’t know how it happened.

In your two side projects, Revenge and Monaco, you used another bass player. Yeah—I’d play the high lead parts, and the other bassist would go low. That’s because I can’t really sing and play at the same time. We went through about five different bassists, because nobody could play like me. I think the way I play is very simple, but I couldn’t find people who could do it. They were all very accomplished bass players, but they just had different instincts, and your instinct is what makes up your style.

You’ve also worked as a producer. I went through a period of having my own studio, but I realized what a pain in the ass that is. I actually got to the point in my production that I was doing pretty well. I did the Stone Roses, the Go-Betweens, and a few others. I like producing. It’s rewarding, but it’s very hard work.

As a producer, what do you bring to a session? Instinct. I’m good with people, so I can get them to do things. Most of the people I work with are friends, and it still stays like that. The way I produce is that I will not do anything the band doesn’t like. When I was young, a producer came and did something I didn’t like with our music, and I have to live with that every day.

What drives you? I get terrified at not being able to put a bass riff on a song. It breaks my heart if I don’t put a top bass riff on every one of our songs. I’m devastated. So that’s what drives me, because that’s all I want to do. I want to be the bass player in New Order, and I want people to hear it and go, “Fuckin’ hell—he’s done it again!”

Toy Division Hooky sounds off on some of the basses he’s played over the years:

Yamaha BB1200s “It’s a 22-year-old bass that’s been on every single New Order album. I’ve tried to find a backup to it, but I’ve never found one that sounds better. The top end you can get out of it is amazing. It took me eight years to find another one; now I’ve finally got a spare.”

Eccleshall “It’s made by Chris Eccleshall in Cornwall. I wanted a hollowbody with Yamaha electronics, so he took the active electronics from a BB1200s and built a full-scale neck-through bass with 24 frets.”

Shergold Marathon 6-string “I used to play it a lot, but I haven’t used it on the last two albums.”

Overwater C Bass & Guild Starfire “When John Entwistle died, I went to the auction for his guitars, because I wanted to buy his Gibson Thunderbird. It went for 57,000 pounds! I bid three times, but I realized my wife was going to kill me if I went through with it. I was really glad to get these two, though.”

Gibson EB-2 “I loved the shape of it, but it just wouldn’t stay in tune. I must have spent about 200 quid on a new bridge, new pickups.”

Hondo II Rickenbacker copy “It was absolute shite.”

Gibson EB-0 copy “It went out of tune between F and G on the E string.”

0 likes

Well you live and learn...Hooky was a cheap bastard with a Hondo at one point as well....fucking fabulous.

:) I always thought it was a real Rick....oh shame on me. Still not seen an explanation of where the funding for the Shergolds came from...they MUST have cost a few bob like (his and bernards)

0 likes

I was most amazed about the fact that it took six years to track down what I thought was a pretty common Yamaha bass...

The Rickenbacker is a def. a fake as the nameplate on the neck is just blank...

As well, I'd always heard that he played through two Electo Harmonix Clone Theory pedals in series but I guess it's just one...

Now off to find one of those Yamaha's...

0 likes

i have one of those yamahas. it sounds decent, but it's not my main bass b/c i don't want to emulate hooky's sound everytime i pick up a bass.

however, i think that no matter the bass you use, it's really all in the amp and FX setup though. get a proper chorus pedal and you'll be in hookyland in no time.

0 likes

The Rickenbacker would explain his present-day crooked back stature, at least while playing :D.

0 likes

good read :clap:

0 likes

"When a teacher shows you what to do, then you’re off in a certain way immediately, and that’s the opposite way of how I did it. I’m almost anti-teaching. My son Jack just got into trouble at school because his music teacher was saying to him that all musicians read music. He told her, “My dad’s a musician, and he doesn’t read music.” And she gave him a detention. Ridiculous! So that’s the sort of thing I fight against."

That's true as well! that music teacher is a right bitch though!!

who needs to know about crotchets and quavers when i just pick up my bass and have a little jam around with andy my drummer?? i love just jamming with andy its great and its the best way i think, well its how i came up with all my best bass work in my short bass career anyway :thumb:

0 likes

"I get into a lot of new music these days. I love Snow Patrol, Bloc Party, and Secret Machines, and I’m a great fan of the Zutons. The Kaiser Chiefs, Razorlite, and Kasabian are all brilliant. My son Jack is at the age where he’s digging it all. He’s good at spotting the stuff that sounds like Joy Division and New Order. He’ll bring it to me and say, “This sounds like you, Dad. Listen!” He gets more upset about it than I do. He’s just started playing bass himself. I’m delighted, because if he gets half as much out of it as I do, he’s going to be a very happy boy. It’s strange to be sitting around talking about bassists with your son. It’s quite sweet and touching, really."

Hehe thats funny n true as well! like the time i first heard vertigo by U2, i was like :angry: :banghead: cos it was such a blatent rip-off of isolation, so i had to go grab him and share the angry moment with him. its fun, we talk bass a lot its well good :thumb:

0 likes

Jack_H wrote: "When a teacher shows you what to do, then you’re off in a certain way immediately, and that’s the opposite way of how I did it. I’m almost anti-teaching. My son Jack just got into trouble at school because his music teacher was saying to him that all musicians read music. He told her, “My dad’s a musician, and he doesn’t read music.” And she gave him a detention. Ridiculous! So that’s the sort of thing I fight against."

That's true as well! that music teacher is a right bitch though!!

who needs to know about crotchets and quavers when i just pick up my bass and have a little jam around with andy my drummer?? i love just jamming with andy its great and its the best way i think, well its how i came up with all my best bass work in my short bass career anyway :thumb:

Jack, I totally agree with you and your Dad. The thing that puts young 'uns off learning an instrument is that they have it drilled into their heads at school that that HAVE to read music to play music, whih is a load of tosh. They should be just given an instrument and told, 'right, lets see what noise you can get out of that!'

And they wonder why less kids are taking up music at school...

Great article :clap:

0 likes

Jack_H wrote: like the time i first heard vertigo by U2, i was like :angry: :banghead: cos it was such a blatent rip-off of isolation, so i had to go grab him and share the angry moment with him. its fun, we talk bass a lot its well good :thumb:

^ That's fantastic you guys get on so well. :) The whole bit about "My dad's a musician, etc" sounds like something I would have fired off at my music teacher.:lol: My dad wasn't, but I could have given her a long list of musicians who say they've never read music at all in their careers and still turn out quite sucessful.

:evil4: What a good interview.

0 likes

Jack_H wrote: "When a teacher shows you what to do, then you’re off in a certain way immediately, and that’s the opposite way of how I did it. I’m almost anti-teaching. My son Jack just got into trouble at school because his music teacher was saying to him that all musicians read music. He told her, “My dad’s a musician, and he doesn’t read music.” And she gave him a detention. Ridiculous! So that’s the sort of thing I fight against."

That's true as well! that music teacher is a right bitch though!!

who needs to know about crotchets and quavers when i just pick up my bass and have a little jam around with andy my drummer?? i love just jamming with andy its great and its the best way i think, well its how i came up with all my best bass work in my short bass career anyway :thumb:

FUNNY!

At the end of third form I went to my music teacher and said I wanted to go on to O'level (that's what they called GCSE's when I were a lad). She said "well, you need to sing or play an instrument" I said "I play electric bass" and she said "no, an instrument" bitch.

The previous 3 years had been spent drawing page after page of clefs....doing maybe one day on transposition...and listening to the same 2 albums over and over again.

Of course the year I left they got some sequencers and stuff.

Anyway, I'm glad I didn;t get to do the O'level. It gave me a chance to learn to play for myself. Standing around in the bedroom, bass on loud, your old fella tearing outta the hi-fi (other things too obviously, but hey a bit of flattery never hurt). I eventually got an atari and wrote a stack of tunes.

then the local college openned a music department, and off I trundled to do B-tec (it beats working thought i at the time). I learned almost nothing about music technology (ended up teaching classes instead of taking them in my 2nd year FFS).

The important thing tho, is that what I DID learn about music, about harmony, and chord substitution and all that shite....damaged me beyond repair. Honestly. It took away the ability to find the notes inside me in innocence. Never again would I be certain to play the "right note" only the "correct one".

Don't get me wrong, I got so much experience of so much other music, that it did me good, and I worked with some fabulous players too. Even some of the bass tuition I got was worthwhile. My tutor just ignored all the appalling habbits I'd learned both myself and from a Mancunian Bassplayer you may be familliar with :) ("why do you insist on playing melodies on a bass steve?"..."well, cos they suck on a guitar")And he taught me other ways to play.....some of which I've JUST, ten years later started to mess with (and would have anyway I think)

Speaking of top players..... I have a solid bit of advice....for all the bassplayers...a bassplayer who can sight read will make a fortune. Depends on whether you want to be a twit of a session man or not tho.

I was gonna say this before then thought better in case you yelled. But I thought..."couldn;t find anyone to play like him????? WHAT???"...then it clicked, that it's what we're discussing here....if you;ve learned to play bass the right way...you'll never play like Hooky, and that's just yer own bad luck :)

I always wonder tho....right jack spill the beans....when no one's listening...does he start slapping and tapping and doing mad jazz walks...then quickly revert to hammering out ner ner ner der der der with a pick before anyone twigs on :)

the point....no one can tell you you're wrong about your music, it's yours. I hope your da tore her a new one on parent's evenig....shoulda brought down a gold disc (They get those now i assume).."can't read a fookin note luv" and set in front of her. Detention indeed. If that's really all you said to her, you must go to stallag luft 5 high.

Incidentally....at the risk of seeming like a total stalker, did you in fact get me mail about NOOL day, or has snotmail joined the ranks of those services that fear the slightlynarrow domain name and send it to the spam box? (I mean you can not tell me anything if you like, but you'll sound pretty quiet come april ....besides...ask yer da...it pays to have the techies on side :D )

0 likes

BTW jack...you already know everything there is to know mate....everything that's important.....your function in the universe is to jam with a drummer. :D

0 likes

Yeah, i have just started reading it now, i had 43 emails wow!!!:eek: but i will reply to it tomorrow cos im going to bed now, im not well today, got a cold, but i will reply to it all tomorrow i promise.

and my drummers good too :thumb:

0 likes

Yeah, well if he stank, I'm sure you could suggest a reasonable coach :)

No hurries or worries mate BTW....it's just LOTS of people don't get my mails because their dumb security systems freak out at the mailserver being on a domestic Ip address or something retarded.

and Get well soon and all that shite...plague suck ass.

0 likes

I took a Music Theory course this semester and regretted it. I wanted to take some classes unrelated to my major, but the amount of time demanded of you to learn music in a classroom setting is damn ridiculous, especially when you've got five other courses to worry about and here's a snotty music prof demanding umpteen hours of practice every night come hell or highwater. Consequently, I blew the technique portion of the final and the written half is on for this Friday. At this point i'm more focused on getting the damned class over with rather than anything else.

That being said, learning piano can verily help one in playing any other instruments, if only the basics in terms of scales and such. Whole step-Whole step-Half step-Whole step-Whole step-Whole step-Half step and whatnot :crazy:.

0 likes

Grrrrr practicing the most inane pointless crap for years and beating any sign of inspiration out of you.

That's where classical players come from.

Lifeless snotbags who are at best cover version artists, and at worst little better than a monophonic sequencer track.

Artist moment here: When in Chicago with the college Jazz band it was my birthday, and i got utterly UTTERLY shitfaced, which took an inordinate amount of doing until I gave up on what passes for beer in that place, and got tucked into spirits, something they are MUCH better at. Anyway, back in the Hotel I had a crisis, I started totally freaking out...why was I here...other people on the tour had been brought in from other classes, how come another better bassplayer wasn't...I stank and they could all play like FUCK.

the drummer and one of the guitarists (the other 2 members of the engine (or groove section as we preferred), the rest of the band being deemed "the remedials" for their utter lack of any kind of groove)...sat me down and said... "how often does $DUDE or $DUDE play their bass....what 5 hours a day every day playing the same excercises over and over" "you on the other hand walk off stage and put it down, 2 days later you pick it up and walk back on stage and you STILL lay it down" And I argued that those guys could do all sorts of amazing things, and they said... "yes, but they are not one bit more groovey or soulful that you, in fact $DUDE's a fucking spastic without a drummer and you can hold the time all night, I've timed you"

And I felt warm and loved, and when I sobered up a few days later I realised it was true. I'd learned enough to get the bass to do my thing for me, be it soloing my balls off ina Hookyesque manner, or going into sub-bass meglomaia mode (my early mornings in rehearsal rooms are legends to people who don;t even know me as anything other than "that guy who broke all the stuff with his bass while the band were still having coffee".

The rest of this is just babble mainly, but hey if yer bored. Oddly, I seen both those bassplayers a year or so ago. one was leading an excellent wrong jazz band...they'd learned everything about music and turned to the darkside, it's always a nice thing to see people making a disgusting racket, as long as it's a groovy one, and when cunts yap about it being noise....they can fire music nonsense at them til they go away....we're talking John (Jon) Zorn territory, but less wanky. The other guy, had continued to work with the same drummer he'd been with at college for like 10 years....the two of them are big scarey session guys on the mainland somewhere. Their band scraped the asshole of a dead rat and sucked the harvest. Just bollox, total technique, every note perfect, every fret hit like a (non US made) smart weapon, each note chosen in perfect key with whichever of 1700 chords was passing on that beat, it was pure art. it ws pure BALLIX! Drummer and Bassplayer are good mates of mine and ai still bailed like the PA had caught fire. FUCKING AWFUL.

"Jazz, it's like theatre, it's what you do when you can't get a gig" so true.

I will,have and do dabble, but only so I can butcher jazz standards. The one useful reading skill I learned in college was how to bluff your life on any jazz tune with a chord chart, and when all else fails, playing totally random notes with absolute conviction :)

Our bigband, and one or two litle amusements since have had dancefloors filled with rioting drunks by doing things to jazz tracks that jazz heads consider rape. And all by UNlearning and gettin down :)

0 likes

Great article! I play (or attempt to play) bass myself.. Hooky is a great inspiration. :)

Funny quip added to sig...

0 likes

Good on Jack for sticking it to his teacher.

And what happened to the Rickenbacker?

0 likes

I know where Steve's coming from, although I've never taken music courses (and I dont think I will after reading Steve's posts!) but one of my friends who I force to listen to JD/NO doesnt think Hooky is anything spesh. And I know if my bass teacher were to hear some Hooky bass lines he wouldnt be very impressed. But I love just messing around on the high end of the bass, playing melodic riffs, because I think music is about enjoyment, not impressing people with fancy playing. Although being your own person is important, i'd be a liar if I said Hooky is not a huge influence.

Jack H, do you have a favourite Hooky bassline?

0 likes

Actually, my bass tutorm knew BM and that was that..."that's the boy with the 6 string".

Played him some other tunes and his general attitude was.. "he knows dick, but he plays really well" and he had the glazed look of one who has understood the legend (OK, one of the tracks I played him was AoC live, that wuold scare anyone).

there are a frightening number of well regarded bassplayers who think the sun rises and sets on Hooky and spends much of the intervening time shining out his arse. Flea's MAD for it, as one who comes to mind instantly. And they like him cos even the les claypools and victor wootens of this world know in their hearts they could never have written the bass part to TLU or Chosen time, or...why bother listing, there are two many, that only Hooky could have come up with.

Bernard is exactly the same, he learned to make the guitar make the noise he wanted it to make. i think he has since learned more and that may be part of the idiot comping thing he keeps insisting on.....someone should remind him one of the reasons he got the gig up front was that he worked the guitar rund the vocals in JD anyway...worked a treat with NO for ages too. I can't help thinking he just looks all flustered nad frsutrated on stage a lot of tims these days, and I think he's tryin to do more than he was built to do happily :) Bless him.

0 likes

Christopher Owens wrote: Good on Jack for sticking it to his teacher.

And what happened to the Rickenbacker?

A copy apparently, unless I skipped a bit :)

Fuckin horrible things. Someone else beat me to it on the "that's why he plays in the shape he does" comment. Rick guitars weigh 2X my bass (Yes my bass is the lightest bass you'll ever play, I bet it's lighter than those eccleshalls), I think I picked a rick bass up once but never actually played it, possibly cos the boss came back in to "my mate's" music store :)

0 likes

Very insightful. Thanx for the interview post.:read:

0 likes

Hookys the man !!!! Interviewer spelt his name wrong tho

Who are some of the bassists you admire?One hero of mine was John Jack Brunell of the Stranglers, because of how he’d play loud riffs. And I always liked the way Paul Simonon wore his bass with the Clash.

John Jack Brunell.....he built bridges did'nt he

Should have been Jean Jacques Burnel of course :bow:

0 likes

No surprise really that Hooky's a fan of JJB. A ruthless bassbastard if ever there was one.

BTW...I wish a complaint to be passed on to that bugger Hook!

I've learned 2 (at least 2 anyway) VERY bad habits from him.

  1. WHich he's stopped, and I haven't is constantly clanging the G-string to check everything's working right in between tunes and check the next sound is working. I do it all the time for no reason other than it makes me float off to PFD land...drrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrRRRRRRRRRRRNNNNNNN Rest of people on stage just glare at me.

  2. It's now programmed into me, that as a bassplayer it is my $DEITY-bestowed right to make the last noise of any tune/gig/album/career

FWIW, Mrs Morris has one to answer for.....battering patch test keys on open channels (in our case sometimes it just means twattin a keyboard) to check if the programming all worked out at the top of the track.

0 likes

Beats guitar noodling anyway! I have sadly got into the habit of pre-announcing Ceremony with a little soft pick at the guitar riff, as we always seem to play it at a time of pedal change, and I always want that reassurance that the next one isn't gonna be a turbo-charged overdrive special!

0 likes

oldmonkey wrote: Beats guitar noodling anyway! I have sadly got into the habit of pre-announcing Ceremony with a little soft pick at the guitar riff, as we always seem to play it at a time of pedal change, and I always want that reassurance that the next one isn't gonna be a turbo-charged overdrive special!

Buggers have a LOT to answer for don't they :)

Not so bad for you, in a tribute band as for me doing Hooky things at a fookin posh Jazz do MUUUUHAHAHAHAHA (a bar of Aoc or a very deliberate strumming of all 4 strings a la no love lost is my usual method of checkin tuning to :) )

Still at least you don't do the full "this is my errrrr ceremony guitar" ramble from Kilkenny 83. Hooky suddenly blasting into the tune to shut him up is truly wonderful....pure disater area/spinal tap/bad news, bass sounded on fucking evil form that night too :D

0 likes

Steve Campbell wrote:

Still at least you don't do the full "this is my errrrr ceremony guitar" ramble from Kilkenny 83. Hooky suddenly blasting into the tune to shut him up is truly wonderful....pure disater area/spinal tap/bad news, bass sounded on fucking evil form that night too :D

I did at Homage! I wasn't even playing Ceremony (Day of the Lords), and it was neither a Gibson 330 nor even my guitar!

0 likes

Steve Campbell wrote: Grrrrr practicing the most inane pointless crap for years and beating any sign of inspiration out of you.

That's where classical players come from.

Lifeless snotbags who are at best cover version artists, and at worst little better than a monophonic sequencer track.

That'll be me then:(

Grade 8 piano and don't regret it at all and have always found my theory training very helpful in making my own music.

I think guitar teachers are far worse than classical teachers. They seem obsessed with chords and scales and the like and not so on feel.

The first thing I was really taught on piano was melody...which is new order. Whereas on guitar you are taught chords.

Plus speed seems to count a lot for the speed merchant guitar players whereas the most important thing in piano is feel. You could play a technically perfect piece in piano and still fail a grade if you played it like a robot.

That being said, I'm speaking from observation as I have never had and never will have a guitar or bass lesson. been playing both for a long time, still don't use chords and still feel like an idiot when I have to explain to band members about what I've played/written as I don't know all the technical lingo.

0 likes

you're not monophonic ;) you can use the internet you like New Order you SO don;t fit the profile :)

EDIT: actually on re-reading that you seem to have deftly ignored loads of the mor annoying things. And you have no fucking idea just how right you are about FUCKING guitarists and their chordal obsessions....Jazzers are insane. They set me a lead sheet down, and I got "uhuh, bit of A for that long then itt's C minor for a bit then an E...fair play", start playing root notes and once I get a groove going start throwing in the notes that belong to the chord/key/mode whatever......meanwhile, all around me..... "see over that first C, what are you playing, is a an add 13 flat 9, or is it the F dominant flat 5 flat 11" (ching screech) "I dunno man $DUDE shoed me how to play a G noddlarian modal pentatonic frugghatch inversion over a c major" and so it goes on. and if at any point I mention anything like...."that sounds not a great deal like the tune we're meant to be playing anymore" or "that's a pile of cock, sort yourselves out"...I get a fucking lecture on being a retard. They'd have grounds for it were it not for the fact I leared most of the same shit as them (tho not in guitar class obviously, I'd rather have had my hands chopped off), yet somehow the most it meant to me was something to reach for when stuck...and as for all that sustitution shit, they keep wanking over it, and giving me loads of "you should be able to fire all this off campbell"....and none of them ever stops to think that 1. all that crap basically means, on the bass, not hitting the rot note but some other, really, that's all it comes down to. or 2. if I start playing like a cunt it really will be jazz, 3 guys (we're up to date on this post soryy, this is my little tuesday night distraction project a jazzy 3 piece) playing 3 fookin tunes.

AND I can't ven hooky-out when I want cos there's so many Fucking Chords that you would actuallu HAVE to know all the bollox not to lpay bummers ARGGGGH. Still the whole excercise amuses me when I just play any note that's under my finger, with perfect time and posistioning (you have to put at least half your brain out of gear to do it)...just hitting notes here there and everywhere in a steady walking groove......and they say " fuckin right man thought you said you couldn't do walkin basslines" :banghead:

HEHE this thread has deviated from Hooky's bass playing to"639 reasons why Jack's music teacher is full of mad dog's shite"

Spark the printer up Jack :)

0 likes

*heartily agrees with Steve's rant*

I spent a decade in Orchestra classes because it was the only way I could get the parents to pay for a violin for me. I already had this Yamaha synth they had thought was a keyboard (which was my luck, I do admit), and in exchange for a violin, I was told there had to be lessons that followed.

I didn't want lessons because I wasn't obsessed with key signatures or the circle of fifths. I just wanted a violin so I could play stuff like New Order as viciously as possible on a classical device.

I rarely use the instrument as intended. More often than not it has found its way into more rock arrangements between groups I've played with, and gets tuned out of key and modified to produce more interesting sounds. I refuse to read notes off a page, because it's far more creative to just bang around with the notes and find melodies and bridges I've had sitting around in my head for ages. With all luck, I've only worked with people so far who operate on that same code of conduct. :P

My director always said I'd never do anything with "that pop music" I kept noddling with in the practice rooms. I admit to not being famous, but there's nothing like seeing someone's face light up during an otherwise boring school concert when they hear the opening strains of BLT grinding away.

I'm all for Jack printing this out and showing it to his teacher, but really I don't want the lad to get a week's worth of detention for being a smart one. ;)

0 likes

hey I'm partly devil's advocating here guys :)

I'm lucky in that despite a pretty strict classical training I can ignore it all when it comes to playing guitar and bass. I just play the notes...whatever they may be and that be that.

And sadly, the majority of classical sods are very snobby to pop music and vice versa. Which I think is a bit :nuts: as there is good and bad in both...just got to get past the evangalists in all fields of music to make your own mind up.

Personally, I think though the reason I have my new order obsession, and I know I don't post here but those who know me know I have that obsession, is, because I see new order's music as very clsoe to classical music.

Bizarre I know, but the best classical music has simple melodies that intertwine, and so do new order

0 likes

I read a description of True Faith once as being "just like blue Monday, the perfect New Order song, a symphony you can dance to" Perfect.

Don;t think anyone objects to classical music, it rocks (tho much of it is so fookin nice it kills me), it's the learning of the instruments that can damage the music that;s already inside the player. That's bout it aint it people?

And yes I suspect Jack would get expelled these days just for being right. Stab a teacher, get lines...proves she's a moron, you're a subversive and yer on yer arse :D

The day you leave mate, the day you leave :)

"Letter for you Miss" :rofl:

BTW msh...get yer mp3's out for the lads :)

0 likes

Workin' on it as we speak, Steve. ;) Working on getting in shape for Community2, that is. :evil4:

0 likes

Grrrrrrr tease!

There is so much stuff coming up for C2 that if i look forward to it anymore I'll forget to finish my own tracks :)

BTW...the avatar is no monitor-eye friendly, each time my wrecked retinas (retinae?) spot it, the first interpretation they put oh it is...that must quite a black eye under that dressing....then....oooooh how arts....can i suggest you photoshop the rose a sureal shade of blue as a service to idiots.

0 likes

I suppose I can manage that. Looks interesting, now.

0 likes

arrrgh....no the responsibilty....don;t change your online YOU for my sakes argh argh argh.

Dear God what's wrong with "fook off steve, if ya tugged yer tadger less yer fookin eyes would work"

But thanks :)

0 likes

It took all of a minute to color it in, and if it helps someone's eye go less wonky while staring at my avatar, then by all means I'll help out. :evil4:

Actually inspired me a bit, and now I want to run through that shoot and work on making more spacey-colored roses. You've inadvertantly sparked imagination, Steve.

plus my fave color's blue, so it works out well.

0 likes

Proud to have helped there be more art in the world. Tho tbh i think I probably nicked the idea from saville's leaves. Maybe not :)

you gotta love this place.... Hooky talks about playing bass Jack talks about his music teacher WE talk about Jack's music teacher We discuss the good and evil of teaching we list terrible things NO taught us to do and eventually we end up with a squinty, sleep deprived Irishman inspiring an American who (if she is to be believed) can drink more than mosts States, towards a new direction of artistic endeavour.

Who's gonna write.. "NOOL, the book"

0 likes

If there IS a book, I demand a quiz show as well. Someone's got to get a chance to scream "Who said they were all on drugs? LUDICROUS!", only, perhaps substitute "crazy" for "drugs", unless it's also inclusive of "crazy drugs".

An audience full of NOOL members could be dangerously fun, however. Just imagine if there's alcohol served. Might have to be broadcast sometime after the children go off for bed.

This half crocked idea sounds something Wilson'd finance, right? ;)


All said, it's been a perfect transition of a thread.

I dunno if I could still drink like I did 8 years ago. It'd be worth a try, but I'll wait til I'm over there and all of us meet up at a gig or something, so it can be a shared experience. :laugh:

0 likes

msh wrote: If there IS a book, I demand a quiz show as well. Someone's got to get a chance to scream "Who said they were all on drugs? LUDICROUS!", only, perhaps substitute "crazy" for "drugs", unless it's also inclusive of "crazy drugs".

An audience full of NOOL members could be dangerously fun, however. Just imagine if there's alcohol served. Might have to be broadcast sometime after the children go off for bed.

This half crocked idea sounds something Wilson'd finance, right? ;)


All said, it's been a perfect transition of a thread.

I dunno if I could still drink like I did 8 years ago. It'd be worth a try, but I'll wait til I'm over there and all of us meet up at a gig or something, so it can be a shared experience. :laugh:

Get yer passport. NOOLday awaits, I like the quiz idea....but here wll be a room full of smashed NOOLers and great music (tho it may sound rough if you start bringing me drinks). sign yer ass up for Barney's Angels and come join the dementia.

Lot of people round here seem to think this thing's invite only or somthing....it isn't it's LOGING only :D :D :D

Honestly, we don't eat catburgers, and toothbrushes have been on sale for literly years (the say there will be a thing called floss aviable soon). And as long as you don't come wearing a "change the constitution 14 more years" shirt on, you'll be sweet.

Am i turning into to the male whore of this site or WHAT?

I'm still Jem's till told otherwise (cue Jem posting a veritable graphical montage and the words "Fooking otherwise")

Really it's like my reptile brain has suddenly worked out that there are females of my species alive or something, and it's not like any of you bore me. :D (thankfully my higher brain has explained the subtle differences between breeding and E-gobshiting to my reptile brain with a hammer...you're all safe for the times being)

0 likes

Fair enough, I usually turn out to be the motherly type on the boards I'm on - and I'd already figured I'd established interest with the BA's, just purely on my unprintable thoughts on the poor man.

Sign me on up!

As for twu wuv, I've a guy I'm converting ever slowly to the happiness that is NO. Probably can't get him into the JD side of things, but really - compared to my past track of getting people into my music - this is a win.

* "New Order? That junk? Bah" - friend "You're really thick, you know? They've influenced every band you rapture over, and yet you can't appreciate the originals?" - me *

It's the sort of thing that'll drive you mad. :nuts:

0 likes

Hooky is amazing. He has written my favorite bassline ever in my favorite song ever by my favorite band ever where on top of all that, he sings. Further more, of all the songs I've covered, that song (Doubts Even Here) is getting the most votes, almost doubling the runner-up.

You seriously don't get better than that man.

0 likes

Wasim wrote: ...I think music is about enjoyment, not impressing people with fancy playing.

I agree 100%. Hooky is the man. I can't get better than that Logan, but if I had to pick the most important element in New Order sound, I would pick Hooky's bass. IMHO he makes New Order New Order, the band that makes the best music I've ever listened to in my life.

0 likes

RøbertãoTøldYøuSø wrote:

Wasim wrote: ...I think music is about enjoyment, not impressing people with fancy playing.

I agree 100%. Hooky is the man. I can't get better than that Logan, but if I had to pick the most important element in New Order sound, I would pick Hooky's bass. IMHO he makes New Order New Order, the band that makes the best music I've ever listened to in my life.

I somewhat agree with you. But then again I consider the song World (The Price Of Love) as much a New Order song as, say, the bass-driven Age Of Consent. And World really doesn't even have Hooky's bass in it. But I do agree that without Hooky, it would lack. But then again, without Steve's drumming or Barney just being Barney, it would lack as well. Otherwise bands like Monaco or Revenge would be just as good as New Order, wouldn't they? Not to say that they're bad, but the whole of New Order just work together so well. I wouldn't replace one of em. (Even though Gillian was replaced, but whatever)

0 likes

Oh Hooky ! :love2: :bass: legend!

:nuts:

0 likes

Re: Peter Hook influences, found this quote on another board.

"I remember watching highlights of "New Order" from one of the festivals in the summer, and they were asked if they had any influences as many young bands are influenced by them. Peter Hook said "yes the Stranglers, JJ Burnel revolutionised bass playing. No one was like him".

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗