Skip to content

Popjustice statement on WFTSC on review of PSB Fundamental

Archived

5 replies · 387 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Do you think this statement is fair to New order on this review?

Closed
  • Yes 1 (8%)
  • No 10 (77%)
  • Dont give a f*ck! 2 (15%)

13 votes · voting closed

POPJUSTICE review

Vital statistics time: on 'Fundamental' there are six upbeat songs, including three complete thunderers and two sort of vibey electro things. First single 'Minimal' is a vibey electro thing whose chorus is a Vocoderised chant of 'M-I-N-I-M-A-L'. The last 50 seconds of the song are everything New Order should be sounding like in 2005 instead of all that 'Waiting For The Dumper's Call' nonsense they were bandying around earlier this year.

0 likes

NO:hat:

0 likes

who the fuck is this that is writing this?

this depresses me,,,,being a big NO fan AND a big PSB fan, it pisses me off that someone seems to be trying to make a comparison..........

ITS FUCKING APPLES AND ORANGES....there is no grounds for comparing bands, at any time.

its stupid

now that I think about it, its such an inane effort that I shouldnt even react to it

it shouldnt even be in this forum

nor should I

0 likes

john dougherty wrote: who the fuck is this that is writing this?

this depresses me,,,,being a big NO fan AND a big PSB fan, it pisses me off that someone seems to be trying to make a comparison..........

ITS FUCKING APPLES AND ORANGES....there is no grounds for comparing bands, at any time.

its stupid

now that I think about it, its such an inane effort that I shouldnt even react to it

it shouldnt even be in this forum

nor should I

I am with you there. Comparing bands especially 2 who are legends in their own field (minds) is the dumbest way of doing reviews.

0 likes

How can a review of one album possibly have a bearing on another. Just because of some supposed link between the artists. In my opinion its not an issue.

0 likes

i love that song. then again all opinions a subjective. bear in mind how many times we bag other bands here.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗