Skip to content

Guardian Review Of LWTUA :crazy:

Archived

13 replies · 1,045 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Joy Division Love Will Tear Us Apart(Warners)

These guys sounds like a less polished version of Editors. If Edith Bowman gets behind them and puts them on the Radio One A-list then I can see this doing something, but otherwise, bands like this just aren't going to get enough hits on their MySpace to warrant getting anywhere near Jo Whiley's show - and that's key if you want to shift units. Just ask Hard-Fi.

Andy Capper

0 likes

Old Blue wrote: Joy Division Love Will Tear Us Apart(Warners)

These guys sounds like a less polished version of Editors. If Edith Bowman gets behind them and puts them on the Radio One A-list then I can see this doing something, but otherwise, bands like this just aren't going to get enough hits on their MySpace to warrant getting anywhere near Jo Whiley's show - and that's key if you want to shift units. Just ask Hard-Fi.

Andy Capper

Quite funny though, innit!?

:laugh:

0 likes

Old Blue wrote: Joy Division Love Will Tear Us Apart(Warners)

These guys sounds like a less polished version of Editors. If Edith Bowman gets behind them and puts them on the Radio One A-list then I can see this doing something, but otherwise, bands like this just aren't going to get enough hits on their MySpace to warrant getting anywhere near Jo Whiley's show - and that's key if you want to shift units. Just ask Hard-Fi.

Andy Capper

I saw this on Saturday too and, at first, did a bit of a double take. Then I realised- Humour! :read:

Funny Guy!

0 likes

Old Blue wrote: I'm 60/40 on wether he's taking the piss, or not.

It wouldnae surprise me either :laugh:

0 likes

Old Blue wrote: I'm 60/40 on wether he's taking the piss, or not.

Gotta be surely, clive?

At first I was thinking that he was a snotty nosed upstart journo. Then I realised he WAS a snotty nosed upstart journo trying to put the cat amongst the pigeons. Maybe he wrote it for a wind up knowing about the na-na culture on here...

He's gotta know about JD. Surely?:scratch:

Anyone know if it did make the Radio 1 play list?

0 likes

I think the idea beyond taking the piss is that a lot of bands that have a JD influence sound way too 'perfect' in their product and playing, making for static slabs of cheap doom and gloom. 'A lot less polished' here=authenticity and liveliness.

0 likes

Has anyone gone out and bought it? Er again.:rolleyes:

Bit strange putting the "radio" version and Atmosphere on the cd. Would have preferred These Days.

0 likes

Taking the piss?! Then it's funny:laugh: Not taking the piss?! Sack the fooker:nod:

Can't someone ring them up,he needs a word:\ohwell:

0 likes

are you people thick?

:laugh:

0 likes

If he's working for the Guardian he's probably genuine. Soft twat! :nono:

0 likes

It's called 'irony'. Very funny comments!

0 likes

Now that's brilliant!! :clap:

0 likes

Old Blue wrote:

Andy Capper

Only 60/40?

:laugh:

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗