Skip to content

If Martin Hannett could have produced more New Order tracks?

Archived

8 replies · 629 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

I have just finished reading Colin Sharp's excellent biography of Martin Hannett (which I got for Xmas). This has got me thinking - if Martin could have produced one more New Order track what should it have been?

My vote would be "Murder" which I think would have suited Martin's style. Also if New Order had done a full Control Soundtrack album with Martin it might have been interesting? I realise Martin died in 1991 but then what the heck - this is only a hypothetical exercise.

So any ideas for tracks - what do you folks think?

0 likes

Please no. For me the real New Order starts post Martin Hannett.

0 likes

NOOLigan wrote: Please no. For me the real New Order starts post Martin Hannett.

Yes I agree up to a point - I can't imagine Temptation or BLT produced better by Hannett for instance. However, there has always been more than just the pop side to New Order. Tracks like Elegia, Peter Saville Soundtrack etc have demonstrated New Order's wide palette of music.

0 likes

Shellshock :nod:

0 likes

hannet was a man of his time so its difficult to see what he would add to later tracks.....

pherhaps regret?

save it for another day.

0 likes

Thieves Like Us...

Snorri xxx

0 likes

Martin Hannett was responsible for the sound Of Joy Division... So I don't think that that he should have produced more New Order songs ....

0 likes

Well I do think he did a good job on Ceremony which does sound very New Order. Just imagine though if Movement sounded like FACTUS 8.

0 likes

Adam Tate wrote: I have just finished reading Colin Sharp's excellent biography of Martin Hannett (which I got for Xmas). This has got me thinking - if Martin could have produced one more New Order track what should it have been?

My vote would be "Murder" which I think would have suited Martin's style. Also if New Order had done a full Control Soundtrack album with Martin it might have been interesting? I realise Martin died in 1991 but then what the heck - this is only a hypothetical exercise.

So any ideas for tracks - what do you folks think?

"Murder" is a good choice.

I think "We All Stand" and "Ultraviolence" would have suited Hannett as well. "Ultraviolence", in particular, tended to have way more interesting live mixes than what appeared on Power, Corruption & Lies.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗