Skip to content

New Order...HARD ROCK?

Archived

9 replies · 1,292 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Perhaps I was hallucinating, but I heard a live tape of New Order some years ago where the band was ROCKIN' HARD!!! Songs were loud, fast, distorted. It was really just rrrRRROOOAAAARRRRRRR!!! Quite uncharacteristic, I thought at the time. Anybody know of a show or period during New Order's history where they presented music such as this live? Again, I may be mistaken but the friend with the tape INSISTED that it was New Order, and indeed, they were New Order songs. Am I talkin' outta my ass? Can anyone help me here? Anyone have a show like this?

I'm new to this forum, BTW!

0 likes

it was probably The New Order

a completely different band.

0 likes

Even New Order's rockier (rock influenced) songs don't sound that hard...I can handle New Order's rockier songs, but not heavy metal or any of that... So maybe this band you're talking about is a band with a similar name or something.

0 likes

It was probably Lame Biscuit, Link In The Park, or Alien Fanny Farm.

0 likes

It was The New Order, a completely different band. Online retailers like Amazon frequently get them confused.

0 likes

If you mean the band started by Ron Asheton of The Stooges, they didn't perform New Order songs.

0 likes

New Order do have a much harder, rock-oriented sound live, more then you'd expect if you're not that familiar with them and only really know their famous 80s dance stuff.

Their live cover of 'Sister Ray' from the BBC in concert album is about as hard as they've ever been. One of my favourites of theirs.

0 likes

doctorx0079 wrote: If you mean the band started by Ron Asheton of The Stooges, they didn't perform New Order songs.

0 likes

The New Order with Asheton is not very common. I suppose your friend could have been confused.

Maybe it was Joy Division. Maybe you are confused. Maybe he was confused. Maybe your friend was a liar or idiot.

Listen to some New Order or Joy Division songs, the internet has many resources to compare to. New Order is not all gay disco, but then what do you mean by hard rock?

0 likes

No, friends. Thanks for all your help, but I'm quite familiar with the post-Stooges New Order project and this certainly wasn't that band. My only other thought is that perhaps it was a band doing New Order covers (I can't remember which ones, but they WERE New Order/Joy Division songs!), but if so, they were doing an ENTIRE SET of their material. Though this wouldn't be out of the question, it's rare for a band to do something like that. However, I've seen a few bands do long cover sets. I saw the Afghan Whigs in a club do half-a-dozen or more songs from Pink Floyd's "The Wall", for instance. Indeed, as someone pointed out, New Order tends to come off heavier live, but as I said, what I heard at the time was uncharacteristic for them even at their hardest and loudest. Not heavy metal sounding, just really revved up, aggressive, and distorted.

Of course, it doesn't help that what I heard was on a cassette tape (pre-CD burners!) with no details on it whatsoever. Nor does it help that I'm only bringing this up now, years after the fact! While I may not be the world's biggest New Order fan, these were undoubtedly New Order songs, being performed live, to a considerable crowd. Anyway...no big deal, really. It will perhaps always remain a mystery, but I thought perhaps someone out there would know what I was talking about. Thanks again, though, to those of you who stopped to help!

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗