NotAMod wrote:
I wouldn't say people are "obsessed" with remixes but they tend to be liked by those who are fans of dance/electronic music.
For a band of New Order's stature in electronic music that's not an entirely unsurprising thing.
Some remixes are good, some are admittedly shite and some have even improved on the originals; Krafty and Jetstream are good examples.
Personally, I'd rather the band do proper "song" B sides but as Lost Sirens is an outtakes album in the first place we clearly won't get that.
If someone like Richard Morel did an extended version of Hellbent I wouldn't say no to it, he's got good form in that area.
Taking Krafty as an example,
The Glimmers removes some of the melodic elements and guitars and Hooky basslines and stretches the track out but can hardly be called an improvement.
The Phones Reality remix is fine for the first 60 seconds and then becomes (to me) unlistenable.
The Andy Green remix is close to the original with an added keyboard flourish but isn't radically different so for me the Krafty single release would have been far more interesting if it had just the Andy Green version accompanied by a different song (maybe an instrumental)
I could never muster up the enthusiasm to listen to the various mixes of Jetstream so I can't comment on whether or not any of the different version have merit.