I agree that New Order often sound better producing themselves. I wonder if maybe using so many different producers on WFTSC was a "name" thing pushed by the record company..you know to get more attention for the album because some notable producers worked on it. I do like the gloss that Stuart Price added to Jetstream for the final version, but this version shows that the song would have sounded fine without Ana Matronic and they did lose some of Hooky's best bits, as well as some cool Synth stuff, in the final mix.
I imagine that Ana Matronic was also added as a possible commercial consideration, as The Scissor Sisters were quite popular at the time (and are a pretty great band in my opinion, one of the best live acts I have ever seen). But New Order don't need guest singers and producers to be great. They are already great. Their fuckin' New Order!
I do like the rawer and more stripped down feel of this demo version. Feels a bit "harder", if that makes sense. It does sound very much like an Electronic song...but it's got Steve's whipcrack drums on the chorus and I really like Hooky's bass runs throughout the song. Not sure if Phil played much on this demo version, unless he put his guitar down for a synth. But I think the Demo/Bunker mix is def a bit of a lost gem.
I'd like to hear some other demo's from this period. Would be interesting to hear how the songs progressed. I may be the odd one out, but I really liked WFTSC as an album. It has some great songs on it..Who's Joe?, Road to Ruin, WFTSC, Krafty, Jetstream, Guilt Is a Useless Emotion, Turn, Morning Night and Day. That's a solid 8 track album right there.