Music Complete: Reviews
Archived192 replies · 192,584 views
Andy wrote: TheMancunion
from that review
When keyboardist Gillian Gilbert takes joint vocals on ‘Tutti Frutti’,
Is that confirmed anywhere? She's not credited as a vocalist afaik. I'd like to think it was true.
Edit: I read 'backing' but it says joint. So this is just flat-out wrong.heh.
American magazine and online website (obviously) seems fond of it too.
http://www.metroweekly.com/2015/10/new-order-yields-yet-another-fine-crop-of-pop/
Coops wrote: Another stunning 1 star review from off of Amazon...
Really, really, REALLY poor.
I grew up listening to N.O. but, on reflection, I'd have to concede that they haven't released a thoroughly decent LP since Low-Life (30 years ago!!) & even that had a couple of Barney's trademark "Will this do?" stinkers on it.
Tellingly, the best songs on Music Complete aren't as good as Low-Life's worst ('nuff said).
No more. Please.
So, essentially, Rooksby (who grew up listening to New Order, don't forget) only likes Movement, P C & L and some of Low-Life.
HARDCORE FAN!
So they don't really even like most of New Order.
Number 5 in Q's 50 best albums of 2015 in the new issue (there's also a 2 page spread from the Q Awards, for Outstanding Contribution To Music)
And our supergiant sings and writes gloriously. Yes, Bernard is assuredly as great as any one now or before, but Bernard is for now a silent star , not yet gone galactic