Skip to content

Best of New Order - UK or US?

Archived

15 replies · 565 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

What version of NEW ORDER's 'BEST OF' album do you prefer?

Closed
  • UK version 11 (26%)
  • US version 31 (74%)

42 votes · voting closed

I have entered a topic about this, which some people may find interesting, but I would like to know which of the two versions other NEW ORDER fans prefer.

Let me know!


'Watcha gonna do when the Novelty has gone?'


0 likes

The US version for me. I have both but I like the fact that the US one has Let's Go and the 'guitary' version of 1963 as well as AOC, DNE and LV on it. The UK version is a fine intro to New Order, but has nothing really compelling for established NO fans on it (otherwise called "International Syndrome"), save for a few updated tweaked remixes. CTB :bear:

0 likes

US-Version because of "Let's Go" and the Arthur Baker Mix of "1963". The mix of "1963" on the European-version is awful, totally butchered.

0 likes

Thats a good call!

I don't like the UK version of 1963 at all, but the US version is SPOT ON!!

KEEP EM COMING MY GOOD COLLEAGUES!!!!!!

____________________________________________________

WATCHA GONNA DO WHEN THE NOVELTY HAS GONE? :drummer: ____________________________________________________

0 likes

It's looking pretty convincing at the moment!

Keep them coming!!

I have to say, DREAMS NEVER END is a brilliant song, so in my opinion it does deserve a spot on the BEST OF album!

________________________________________________________

WATCHA GONNA DO WHEN THE NOVELTY HAS GONE? :drummer:

________________________________________________________

0 likes

The US version is better in so many ways, many of which pppl have already listed. However, US best-of doesn't have Perfect Kiss. :(

0 likes

The US label wisely altered the tracklisting for 2 reasons:

  1. The UK edition was released much earlier, and had been available in the US as an import for some time.

  2. They made efforts to distinguish it from Substance. I recall a press release from Warner Bros. stating that no tracks from the 1987 compilation were duplicated. It's true, songs that appear on both are different versions.

0 likes

Let's go, whats more?

0 likes

One thing I like about the UK version is the deeper shade of blue on the front cover. The US version's color is a little too light and makes me a little sick to look at! =)

0 likes

perfect kiss is on the 'uk' version..

thats it..

later

|| | || | | | ne g ativ e 1

0 likes

US version, which I got my mum to buy when she went to the US recently. US version doesn't torture me with Thieves Like Us and Shellshock.

0 likes

I have the UK one but it always disappointed me. I got only three "new" songs - BM 88, TBTHOG and World In Motion - back then (1994). If I had "Let's Go" then!!(which I heard for the first time on Retro only).

0 likes

since i do not have i will not vote, but will ask if it is worth getting instead???

0 likes

Jim...save you're 12 bucks for a case of cheap lager...

e-mail me my friend...

0 likes

The US VERSION...better cover too.:wink:

0 likes

I had to vote for the UK version (which is also the Canadian version) because it was the first NO CD I bought and I still remember letting it play through and wondering, "What IS that good song?" when it got to "Perfect Kiss".

I dont' have the US version but I think it would complement the UK version very well as a 2-disc set. But it has an uglier cover.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗