Skip to content

Primitive Notion Appreciation Thread

Archived

16 replies · 400 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

It doesn't take a lot to confuse me, but I'm aware of the voting tendencies of many on here.

Now drink this magic potion :beer: and vote to kick out Close Range next time.

You've done it before and you'll do it again, leaving Close Range right up to the end - how can it be that you all love this song, when Primitive Notion's the best all along......

0 likes

By far, the best song on Get Ready. Just a shame the Order didn't include it in the live set - maybe next time? The song structure reminds me somewhat of TPK.

0 likes

man, all the songs left in this increasingly evil poll are great ones, including 'primitive notion'.

and i've got a message i need to send. it's coming to you straight from a friend--up against 'close range'...well...but it's a top song, no doubt. so don't look at me with your critical smile. :D

0 likes

Primitive Notion is the best New Order song of this century so far and easily in my top 5 of New Order songs of all time. Brilliant classic Hooky opening, 'driving' drums by Stephen, fantastic noisy bits, great melody, wonderful build up. There's nothing wrong about this song. It was my favourite track on GR when I heard it the first time and it still is.

0 likes

Ahhh, so many good tracks left to elimate...I can't do it :cry:

0 likes

Yeh, it's damn cool, reminds me of 24 Hours (but that's not the sole good thing about it, nor is it the point of the song)

0 likes

Brilliant track mates !!! i'm with you :beer:

0 likes

Yeah, a top track & definitely worthy of some live performances next time round - but will someone :evil: creep in and give Close Range immunity ? :skeptic:

0 likes

Luckily i spotted the poll for day 13 before anyone else (except maybe RocketMick) and got PN immunity.

I agree with all the praise for Primitive Notion mentioned above...great song. I have serious doubts about the mental state of those who do not like this masterpiece. Should be listening to that Oasis record or following NME trend setters (Strokes, Vines, et.al) rather than the Order if PN isn't your cup of tea....everything that makes the Order wonderful wrapped up in one song.

0 likes

Must admit I find PN pretty boring and can't understand what all the fuss is about.

Not a patch on a song like Sunrise which is off a similar ilk.

I much prefer SLY and Close Range it has to be said from the GR era.

0 likes

at least your man enough to admit to liking SLY. another great song that gets the shaft because of a bad chorus...and this from people who are willing to overlook even worse lyrics in Slow Jam and Rock The Shack.

I love SLY but Primitive Notion just captures a mood that they haven't captured since Low Life. Sunrise may be better but Primitive Notion is still top shelf material.

The point emerging recently is NewOrder have returned to form and are writing great music....now, if they could only get their ass in gear with regards to set lists, release dates, remixes, promotion etc..

0 likes

My favourite track on the album as well, wasnae that keen on it at first, but after a while and without realising, it was always a song I found myself singing at work:nod:

0 likes

close range is a babe of a tune. go and pick on a song yer own size...

0 likes

Originally posted by mh Yeh, it's damn cool, reminds me of 24 Hours (but that's not the sole good thing about it, nor is it the point of the song)

That's what I thought when I first heard it. It does have that JD feel about it. By far the best song of the GR era. I would have it in my favourite 10 NO songs of all time.

0 likes

Certainly my favorite track on Get Ready, beside Turn My Way (sorry!). Pure New Order sound. Pure emotion. Great production. Great lyrics.

:clap:

They should REALLY add that one on their next setlists. It would fit very well right after 'Guilty Partner' now, wouldn't it? :)

0 likes

not as good as close range, but it is up there with crystal

0 likes

Originally posted by Warm Hands, Cold Heart Certainly my favorite track on Get Ready, beside Turn My Way (sorry!). Pure New Order sound. Pure emotion. Great production. Great lyrics.:clap:They should REALLY add that one on their next setlists. It would fit very well right after 'Guilty Partner' now, wouldn't it? :)

We can dream ;) I'd even go as far as to say I'd rather they learn how to play Primitive Notion live than regurgitate an old song.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗