In recent TV appearances, she looks MUCH better than on the horrid promo video for Jetstream, when she looked like the imaginary Andy (Erasure) Bell´s sister. It´s nice to get a female presence once again, despite the song not being that good. Perhaps she deserves another chance on the forthcoming album?
Dates
· UTC
Should Mrs. Matronic become a NO member?
Archived30 replies · 6,745 views
This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.
Should Ana Matronic become a NO member?
Closed-
YES - Get her off Scissor Sisters 0 (0%)
-
YES - and get rid of Phil 4 (8%)
-
NO - Leave her alone 37 (73%)
-
NO - and get rid of Phil 10 (20%)
51 votes · voting closed
.I guess Im in the "please don't speak to Ana where music is concerned,guys"club.Phil,I suspect is in the band because he brings something to the table
Why did this poll move to this forum and there are polls still on the other one? I just don't understand....
michael brown wrote: Phil,I suspect is in the band because he brings something to the table
Food? Or money because he paid to get in?
Bere wrote:
michael brown wrote: Phil,I suspect is in the band because he brings something to the table
Food? Or money because he paid to get in?
Geeetar I believe,particularly on Turn if its not Barney
FAC103 wrote: erm...is this a SERIOUS question???
I hope not...
yeah I stuff all the kiddy questions in here.
Anyway leave phil alone. He only subbing for Gillian but until her child gets better or hopefully not worse, she would have to sit it out. Plus she needs to take care of the children. Steve has to bring home the dough to pay bills. And I am not speaking as a "man has to keep his fort up." remark, its Steve and Gillians way to do things. Plus no one can drum like Steve and a keyboardist is easily replaced. So thats why Phil is important.
frank smarra wrote: not only don't let her in the band, kick out phil and shoot the both of them
Like I said.
Spotnick wrote: She would leave the best selling group of 2004 for New Order?
Scissor Sisters Have sold 1.8 million copies of their album in the U.K. alone.
Buffer Low wrote:
Spotnick wrote: She would leave the best selling group of 2004 for New Order?
Scissor Sisters Have sold 1.8 million copies of their album in the U.K. alone.
Thats bloody shocking, they're dump
Noel Breaks wrote:
Thats bloody shocking, they're dump
Yes it is, who would have thought an Elton John tribute band would be so big?
Adding Ana would only destroy New Order's style. Keep her out. Phil is fine. He just needs to use the keyboards a little more.
No - not if it means more J-E-T type outcomes!
If any female is going to be adopted it should be DAWN 'why do you guys keep me hanging around for half a decade without letting me in' ZEE.
No way, she's a member of the Scissor Sisters, you know and I don't think Ana would "go" well, so to speak, with New Order's music.
Hello Folks, Sorry to say this but, in my very humble opinion, there should be no way of letting Ms Matronic 'in' NEWorder... I mean, come on, Scissors sisters are just plain awful, and besides, she just CAN'T sing properly or act once onstage, geeezzz ! I know some might add that dear old Barney 's not the best singer in the world, but for me, he , as the rest of 'em anyway, always had something very special (all in all). Again, it was very nice to see the lads being that open minded and absolutely unpretentious (considering their unique stature), but no, definitely... And Phil is great, he's a good decent bloke within the band and he does very well, but i'll always miss Dear Gillian, in my mind she'll always remain a NEWorder member (how else anyway !).
We'd just end up with a series of Piss Streams. I'd never be able to listen to New Order again 
