TT vrs WFTSC

Notice I did not leave both or none. I want you to think, or I rephrase the question. We are not 2 year olds. So I stuff this poll in this forum.

I prefer Twisted tenderness, I do like the guitar oriented tracks on there more than sirens.

What kind of comparison shall this be?

Like we in germany say: You can't compare appels to pears...

Anyway I voted pears...

I think long term it will be TT (most of the time).

love Hooky's bass so it has to be WFTSC

if you are comparing the albums, wftsc by far. however if you are comparing the songs, i'd say twisted tenderness although it was really the only song i liked on the album. no Neil Tennant? just doesnt feel right :dead:

WFTSC for me, but TT has 3 or 4 tracks on it as good as anything on Sirens (Make It Happen, Vivid, Flicker, TT), even though I think some of them would seem out of place on Sirens, especially Make It Happen and the title track. The closing bars of acoustic guitar on Sirens' title track has a VERY Electronic feel to it. If TT turns out to be Electronic's last album, it's a damn good one to finish with.

Still don't like TT,on second play.But I won't part with it,it makes up the collection.

Very tough call. If there was a third choice which allowed me to wimp out, I would have taken it. At the moment, though, I will go with TT. It has three songs I really love, and all the other songs are OK. WFTSC has two songs I really love, though its "other" songs are maybe slightly better than TT's. So, I am going with Twisted Tenderness. I like the fact that some of the songs have a bit of a Smiths sound to them, IMHO.

Definitly WFTSC

I replaced TT into my collection recently, hadn't listened to it for a few years - I wasn't impressed, I remembered it as being better than it now sounds.