The NO Cup - First Round BROKEN PROMISE vs HOMAGE

Poll ends 9pm GMT Wednesday 1st March

I'll admit ... seem to remember liking Homage but can't exactly think of the tune just now

Have to admit, I always thought Homage showed a lot of promise - would have liked to have heard it done in a better studio, when the band had found their feet a bit... Broken Promise is just filler, never really liked it or Way of Life for that matter... Just to be controversial, I'll go for Homage...

Snorri xxx

Homage was very promising while Broken Promise is just an average song from an average album.

Broken Promise was the first chune from Brotherhood I heard. Always loved it.

Ben wrote: Homage was very promising while Broken Promise is just an average song from an average album.

Damn, I was going to highlight that "joke", but decided that the probability of getting a laugh just wasn't 'promising' enough... :\ohwell:

Snorri xxx

The things that mean so much to me Don't mean that much to (84% of) you.

Homage.

BP

Broken promise for the guitar work.

Broken Promise. Homage is neat, but that's about it.

Broken Promise

Homage sounds like nothing

it's gotta be broken promise, it's definitely one of the highlights on brotherhood.

Homage's ghost is whipering in the background, "NOOL, why have you foresaken me?"

Ugh, two groaners I have to pick from, eh?

Homage is nice and demo-y, BP is the most souless attempt at a tune I have ever seen, including Republic. Barney must have been taking the piss, hadn't he?

HOMAGE! Where's my long mac.

I had to listen to homage again.

I would have went for BP anyway.