The NO Cup Second Round - DOUBTS EVEN HERE vs WAITING FOR THE SIRENS CALL

Poll closes 8pm GMT Friday 24th March.

WFTSC... Everything thats good about NO stuffed into 5 or so minutes... As much as I like the early stuff, DEH is not one of my faves...

Snorri xxx

WFTSC is luuurvely. doubts even here is mediocre.

Doubts even here! No doubt. Definitely prefer Movement over WFTSC...

WFTSC- Very retrospective, insightful

i like some songs off WFTSC, but the title track is not one of them Doubts Even Here is amzingly haunting, and a great track

grrrrrr

A week ago I wouldnt have thought twice, but been playing DEH a bit this week.

I'll have to sleep on this one.

ok, WFTSC :)

DHE, 'cos it seems to be more authentic. WFTSC is good but looks like a kind of "academic exercise" or "summary" of NO.

Did we ever work out exactly what the ship was bringing to bernard?

Captain Nemo wrote: DHE, 'cos it seems to be more authentic. WFTSC is good but looks like a kind of "academic exercise" or "summary" of NO.

and us and he's and I'll fall. even with... Doubts.. here gotta catch this midnight train. first to Paris then to Spain. ha.

WFTSC.

No. 2 (in a good way) off the album of the same name.

Ruined in a day wrote: Doubts even here! No doubt. Definitely prefer Movement over WFTSC...

+1

Captain Nemo wrote: DHE, 'cos it seems to be more authentic. WFTSC is good but looks like a kind of "academic exercise" or "summary" of NO.

+1

WFTSC every time. This is everything New Order should be in the modern era...Hooky's bass is class, the beat, Barney's vocals....etc

i like both!!! however, if i had to choose the one song i could more easily listen to on a daily basis...WFTSC

Certainly WFTSC, even though Doubts has grown on me a lot ever since I first heard it.

go the sirens.

WFTSC is a lovely song, but a bit NO by numbers. DEH was the sound of a new band finding their feet, and creating something beautiful along the way. So no doubts here.....

No doubts here, Waiting For The Sirens Call wins this one hands down for me.

Doubt Even Here: a great 'atmospheric' song as I like.

WFTSC: not a bad song but never do it.

Ruined in a day wrote: Doubts even here! No doubt. Definitely prefer Movement over WFTSC...

100% agree

We're only in round two, and the decisions are so bloody difficult!

I'd be happy if WFTSC won the whole thing!

..perfect Movement 19-8-1- against everything New Order 2005..

has to be Doubts Even Here, although it wasn't an easy decision.

Voted for Sirens'. Close one though.

Alistair wrote: I'm having doubts (even here) whether I can remember exactly how Doubts Even Here goes The bulk of Movement just doesn't do anything for me.

WFTSC is definitely one of their strongest singles and cut from the same cloth as True Faith, Regret, Temptation etc. It's endlessly melodic and plays to all their individual strengths; the guitar, hooky bass, keyboards and drumming all shine. Also, Barney's WFTSC vocal carried over to the dancefloor really well with the Planet Funk + Tribute mixes.

Classic New Order

but both are in sense. but the ship just got it all so right.