The NO Cup Third Round - WAITING FOR THE SIRENS CALL vs ULTRAVIOLENCE
Locked Archived24 replies · 1,365 views
The toughest one of all for me, this one!
Closed-
WAITING FOR THE SIRENS CALL 68 (80%)
-
ULTRAVIOLENCE 17 (20%)
85 votes · voting closed
WFTSC is one of the best of the album which has the same name. Ultraviolence is one of the best of P,C & L.
I prefer PCL to WFTSC, so Ultraviolence for me.
not as tough as some others. Ultraviolence is good, but not quite in the same league as WFTSC !
I'm a sucker for anything nautical(but I've never been In The Navy I might add very quickly to allay any suspicions)or beach-related except Baywatch(see earlier comments re. my voting decision against Regret)so WFTSC gets the vote. UV to my ears was a little sterile on PCL and better in the live boots I've heard. It's also similar to Murder which is why NO probably flipped a coin to decide which one of those stayed on the album and why the other became the Benelux import.
Sher[gold]GOLD[/gold] Six wrote: UV to my ears was a little sterile on PCL and better in the live boots I've heard. It's also similar to Murder.
You ain't heard nuthin' yet!
Were it a battle of live versions, the underrrated UV would've gotten my vote, but as WFTSC is my favorite post-Factory track, I'll give it the nod here.
WFTSC rules, but Ultraviolence has one of the best three-note guitar riffs in it and lots of other goodies as well.
oldmonkey wrote:
Sher[gold]GOLD[/gold] Six wrote: UV to my ears was a little sterile on PCL and better in the live boots I've heard. It's also similar to Murder.
You ain't heard nuthin' yet!
Same band but not in the same field. Got to to catch this midnight train.
Man, tough choice as I am now just getting into Ultraviolence. But WFTSC has an emotional appeal to me that transcend most NO songs.
This is really difficult, because I have always been a big Ultraviolence fan, but WFTSC is just about as good a track as they have ever done, and jumped straight into the oldmonkey Top 5.