Skip to content

Well They Started It!!!

Archived

15 replies · 1,314 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

From the front page of today's Guardian (not a newspaper that's widely read amongst zenophobic footie hooligans)...

Quit the Nazi thing says our man in Berlin

Andrew Culf Nuremberg

A minority of English football fans who have been singing songs about the second world war were yesterday criticised by Britain's ambassador to Germany as fat and uncouth.

Sir Peter Torry, who has been based in Berlin for three years, said a tiny proportion of England fans were guilty of "plain bad manners" and appealed to the 99.9% of well-behaved fans to put pressure on them to behave. The ambassador said that songs such as 10 German Bombers were "rude and plainly offensive".

"If only the people singing them could see themselves — great fat, uncouth, bad-mannered people," he said.

His comments came on the eve of England's second World Cup match against Trinidad and Tobago tonight in Nuremberg. German police yesterday circulated an etiquette guide for fans which said chanting football songs was OK, but Nazi salutes and insignia were not. It added: "Goose-stepping or wearing joke Nazi helmets are not criminal offences, but insulting for most Germans."

Asked why it was necessary for German police to hand out cards explaining that goose-stepping was insulting, Sir Peter, in an apparent reference to Prince Harry's visit to a party in Nazi uniform, said: "Things which are in England a bit of fun, like going to a fancy dress party dressed up in Nazi insignia, are criminal offences here." He added: "When people get drunk, as I know from personal experience, they tend to do things that, with the benefit of hindsight, they later regret."

German police took the names and details of several England fans who gave Nazi salutes from the grandstand at the Zeppelinfeld parade ground where Hitler addressed his followers — and they could face prosecution. The police presence at the historic rally grounds adjacent to the match stadium is being stepped up.

Gerhard Hauptmannl, president of the Nuremberg police, said: "We hope the presence of police officers will deter people from repeating this kind of thing. We think these instances are largely based on ignorance or stupidity … sometimes re­ sulting from the fact that the sense of humour on these matters seems to differ from ours."

Fans spotted making Nazi salutes would receive warnings, he said. "We will not be very strict on the first incident … if they repeat the offence after they have been admonished, they will be prosecuted," Mr Hauptmannl said.

Sir Peter said: "Nuremberg has a Nazi past, but no city anywhere in Germany has done more to come to terms with what happened. This represents an opportunity for England fans to see the way in which modern Germany has come to terms with the past, which is something to be welcomed."

He said that his criticisms applied to a tiny percentage of the 70,000 people who visited Frankfurt and "were otherwise a great credit to the country".

By lunchtime yesterday about 5,000 England fans had arrived in Nuremberg, with campsites around the city already full. British police estimate that up to 70,000 could be in the city by kick-off tonight. The capacity of the Franken-Stadion is 44,000 and only about 3,000 Trinidad and Tobago fans were expected.

Police said there had been one serious incident on Tuesday night, when a German was punched in the mouth in an apparently unprovoked attack by an England fan. A man was being held in police custody and could face charges if he already has a UK record of violence. Six fans arrested for climbing over the security fences around the stadium were released with no further action.

Horst Forther, Nuremberg's mayor, praised the cooperation with British police as 44 UK officers began patrolling with German colleagues yesterday.

Assistant chief constable Stephen Thomas, gold commander of the British policing operation, said the behaviour that led to the arrest for assault was "totally deplorable and should not happen". He said 3,704 people had now been prevented from travelling to Germany under banning legislation.

Meanwhile, violent scuffles broke out between police and fans in Dortmund last night before the game between Germany and Poland — long expected to be one of the biggest flashpoints in the tournament. Police said they made about 300 arrests as German and Polish fans appeared to have refrained from attacking each other and attacked the police instead. Germany won 1-0 with a last minute goal.

0 likes

So sad...

40 years ago, two wrongs don't make a right and all that!

0 likes

Why does no one make fun of british colonialism? :confused2:

Well seriously... It's really sad that such shit happens these days. 60 years later and all these dumbos still think we are Nazis here... Every country has it's corpses in the cellar.

0 likes

Bere wrote: Why does no one make fun of british colonialism? :confused2:

Well seriously... It's really sad that such shit happens these days. 60 years later and all these dumbos still think we are Nazis here... Every country has it's corpses in the cellar.

its just unfortunate, that at a time of bad recession in the 30's, the Nazi Party came along and offered hope to the German people. The People weren't to know what the terrible outcome would be.

0 likes

the guy is largely correct. Those doing the salute are an embarrasment to 99% of the nation.

still funny though :uhoh:

0 likes

Barney Army wrote: the guy is largely correct. Those doing the salute are an embarrasment to 99% of the nation.

still funny though :uhoh:

"fan" on GMTV this morning. straight outta Dads Army. with grey tache. classic

0 likes

Ah, it's good to know that football hooliganism is alive and well.

0 likes

Bere wrote: Why does no one make fun of british colonialism? :confused2:

Well seriously... It's really sad that such shit happens these days. 60 years later and all these dumbos still think we are Nazis here... Every country has it's corpses in the cellar.

I think part of it is that it's just such an easy thing to pick on. If someone feels like picking on the Germans, the easiest thing is to do a Nazi salute. It's ignorant and unoriginal, but it's such a powerful symbol, and still recent enough that it still resonates with many people. It's tougher to pick on something like British colonialism. Maybe you could wear a red coat and carry around a tea set, but most people probably wouldn't quite get it.

0 likes

Not noted for their sense of humour the Germans.... I think if anyone took the piss out of British Colonialism,we either laugh along or quite possibly not even give a rat's tits:shrug:

0 likes

Boatraceface wrote: Not noted for their sense of humour the Germans....

True, as we noted on the "a few great things about America" thread.

0 likes

Barney Army wrote: the guy is largely correct. Those doing the salute are an embarrasment to 99% of the nation.

still funny though :uhoh:

You go to jail if you do that here :brow: . We are not proud of what happenend back there (except of some idiots), so we are still a bit angry if someone takes it too easy. It even took us up to this WM to dare to show german flags in gardens, on cars etc. And just slowly there are german films coming up that dare to make fun out of the "man" (at last there was one last year)...

0 likes

Barney Army wrote: the guy is largely correct. Those doing the salute are an embarrasment to 99% of the nation.

still funny though :uhoh:

it's the truly funny things that wind up embarressing the most. it's the situation at that point and not necessarily the content.

still i don't think i'd be willing to be arrested to make fun of a bunch of germans. even though i'd be laughing all the way to the clink

THAT'S WHERE I DRAW ZEE LINE!

0 likes

It's shocking that when asked to decorate the cover of their exercise books at the beginning of the year, most of the kids I teach German to will use pictures of swastikas, Hitler, and 'war', despite being fully aware of some of the German-speaking world's positive contributions to the world... We do change things and end up with a lot of kids having positive images and experiences of Germany, but the media is still only too willing to perpetuate the stereotypes... :shrug:

SHEDi xxx

0 likes

Leave Me A Gnome wrote: German-speaking world's positive contributions to the world...

which positive contributions should that be??? :lol:

0 likes

Ruined in a day wrote:

Leave Me A Gnome wrote: German-speaking world's positive contributions to the world...

which positive contributions should that be??? :lol:

beach towels

0 likes

ChrissMari wrote:

Barney Army wrote: the guy is largely correct. Those doing the salute are an embarrasment to 99% of the nation.

still funny though :uhoh:

it's the truly funny things that wind up embarressing the most. it's the situation at that point and not necessarily the content.

still i don't think i'd be willing to be arrested to make fun of a bunch of germans. even though i'd be laughing all the way to the clink

THAT'S WHERE I DRAW ZEE LINE!

That's the main problem: The lack of other countries tactfulness. We still don't think that time was funny and I think that is not bad to do. The Neo-Nazi-idiots here are still a kind of problem. That's another reason why that is really not funny... I may laugh about putting us all in Lederhosen, but there are things that should be handled in a more serious manner. Germany needs quite some time more to get over that. And we need to get rid of those Neo-Idiots...

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗