Skip to content

Stupid Question....

Archived

7 replies · 1,014 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

or maybe not...soooo...here goes...

Scott Carson gets a red card for bringing down Carlos Tevez...goes straight red...and he's suspended for one match...

Cristiano Ronaldo got his straight red and misses three matches..

what's the difference???

other than the fact that CR is a diving, cheating cnut???

0 likes

well, usually refferees write down everything that happened on the game and deliver the info to the authorities. they make the decision of how many games a red card deserves. it depends on many factors like if it was 2 yellows or a straight red, if the intention was to play the ball or not, if they were any insult from the player before or after the red card, etc. that´s information we usually don´t get to read, not even the press, only the authorities. :shrug:

0 likes

never knew Carson got one game.

hmmmm!!! :skeptic: :shrug:

0 likes

Jeffari-al-Texani wrote: or maybe not...soooo...here goes...

Scott Carson gets a red card for bringing down Carlos Tevez...goes straight red...and he's suspended for one match...

Cristiano Ronaldo got his straight red and misses three matches..

what's the difference???

Ronaldo's red card was for violent conduct, Carson's red would be for foul play. I'm only guessing here... :shrug:

0 likes

All depends on the offence, as recorded by the referee in his match report. Violent conduct carries a mandatory 3 match ban for the first offence in a season. This can be appealed against by the player's club. Ronaldo thus picked up a three match ban. If he is sent off a second time this season for violent conduct, he'll get a five match ban.

A straight red card for a "professional foul", denying a clear goalscoring opportunity, or "serious foul play" constitutes a one match ban. This can be appealed against by the player's club. Again though, if the player has already been dismissed this season, whatever that dismissal was for (including two yellow cards in the same game), the ban for subsequent red card will be longer.

If a player gets a red card as a result of two yellow cards in the same game, the ban will be one match, unless it's a second such red card, whereby it will be a longer ban. There is no appeal against a red card for two cautionable offences, though either of the cautions may be challenged at appeal.

0 likes

ahhh...okay...thanks for the responses...

I thought any straight red went straight to three matches...

imagine that...I'm wrong again!!!

0 likes

oldmonkey wrote: All depends on the offence, as recorded by the referee in his match report. Violent conduct carries a mandatory 3 match ban for the first offence in a season. This can be appealed against by the player's club. Ronaldo thus picked up a three match ban. If he is sent off a second time this season for violent conduct, he'll get a five match ban.

A straight red card for a "professional foul", denying a clear goalscoring opportunity, or "serious foul play" constitutes a one match ban. This can be appealed against by the player's club. Again though, if the player has already been dismissed this season, whatever that dismissal was for (including two yellow cards in the same game), the ban for subsequent red card will be longer.

If a player gets a red card as a result of two yellow cards in the same game, the ban will be one match, unless it's a second such red card, whereby it will be a longer ban. There is no appeal against a red card for two cautionable offences, though either of the cautions may be challenged at appeal.

And all that from a cricket fan...:evil4:

:laugh:

0 likes

Gazfella wrote:

oldmonkey wrote: All depends on the offence, as recorded by the referee in his match report. Violent conduct carries a mandatory 3 match ban for the first offence in a season. This can be appealed against by the player's club. Ronaldo thus picked up a three match ban. If he is sent off a second time this season for violent conduct, he'll get a five match ban.

A straight red card for a "professional foul", denying a clear goalscoring opportunity, or "serious foul play" constitutes a one match ban. This can be appealed against by the player's club. Again though, if the player has already been dismissed this season, whatever that dismissal was for (including two yellow cards in the same game), the ban for subsequent red card will be longer.

If a player gets a red card as a result of two yellow cards in the same game, the ban will be one match, unless it's a second such red card, whereby it will be a longer ban. There is no appeal against a red card for two cautionable offences, though either of the cautions may be challenged at appeal.

And all that from a cricket fan...:evil4:

:laugh:

now that is going into a set of rules, even for those who play it. kept wicket for 12 years and all i know is he got an edge.:)

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗