Skip to content

GOTHIC: is it all shit?

Archived

24 replies · 842 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

inspired by the cocteau twins thread....

the much maligned genre of goth(ic) music has been...err...much maligned (but not without reason). still, there seem to be a handful of quality bands that are either goth or at least partially dabbling in the genre.

i invite you to submit personal preferences of bands, albums, or songs that might be characterized in the goth vein (usually an opened vein) but are--surprise!--actually worth listening to.

0 likes

Gothic, in it's purest form (such as Poe, architecture etc) can produce some of the most stunning imagery you've ever seen.

Goff, as in 'My daddy won't buy me a car so I'll dress in black and cut myself', is hilarious.

0 likes

The second scenario sounds more emo than goth.

Bauhaus, Siouxsie and the Banshees, and others are what I consider goth. There is an excellent website at www.myspace.com/postpunk if you want to access some of the links of classic and new post-punk artists. Most of the artists on there are gothic.

0 likes

I have absolutely no idea (actually I don't really care that much) if Einstürzende Neubauten is included in the genre or not, but Halber Mensch is an album I never tire of listening to. Some, of course, may question whether or not it's actually "music" that they make, but I don't give a toss about that either.

The sound of things falling apart while the world at large is falling apart.....you know it makes sense. :laugh:

0 likes

Siouxsie And The Banshees claimed to be punk, not goth... but... anyway, I'd suggest that if you don't like the whingeing emo idiots and want to hear some interesting music not previously mentioned, I'd go for:

March Violets

Death In June

Skeletal Family

Blood And Roses

0 likes

[magenta]cozmonite61[/magenta] wrote: The second scenario sounds more emo than goth.

Pah, a seppo media label, nothing more than rebadged Goth, like Lenovo is IBM.

0 likes

[darkgreen]Green[/darkgreen] wrote: I have absolutely no idea (actually I don't really care that much) if Einstürzende Neubauten is included in the genre or not, but Halber Mensch is an album I never tire of listening to. Some, of course, may question whether or not it's actually "music" that they make, but I don't give a toss about that either.

The sound of things falling apart while the world at large is falling apart.....you know it makes sense. :laugh:

All I can say is.... New mode, new age, advanced, ambient motormusic machine.

fuckin nutters.

0 likes

Awe... I love goth.... got all my black stuff in the back of the closet...... Now , I just get it out for halloween (never thought I'd say that !) or a concert....

Still love wearing thrift finds....

early, early - The Cure -is my old time favorite .......

I just found this great double CD by Dead Moon Great stuff !!! More early grunge than goth : )

Check um' out ! :wink:

0 likes

mossy wrote:

I just found this great double CD by Dead Moon Great stuff !!! More early grunge than goth : )

Check um' out ! :wink:

"54/40 or fight! ALL RIGHT!!"

0 likes

Most of the stuff I see as Goth is probably more Industrial but I admit "Floodland" by Sisters of Mercy of Mercy is brilliant-always will be.

Industrial that always felt dark and doomy with anger and outsider intent (therefore Goth-ish to me) was like

"Psalm 69" Ministry "Land of Rape and Honey" Ministry

"Front By Front" Front 242

"Burning Empires" VNV Nation

0 likes
  1. Bauhaus, the early Cure - though musically it's pure post punk.

  2. Depeche Mode - yes, I've been surprized they are labeled Goth in music media. But then there's Front 242...

I really don't give atoss abut HIM, Evanessence, etc. Actually they make me vexed.

0 likes

I love being a Goth

Thats me and the mrs..

:laugh:

0 likes

Gazfella wrote: I love being a Goth

Thats me and the mrs..

:laugh:

fookin 'ell - that's the first time i've ever seena fat goth! bob smith excluded, natch :evil4:

0 likes

I wanna be a goff I wanna be a goff I wanna wrap meself in a big black cloth I wanna meet a guy who dresses in lace Big black eyes and a long white face.....

So...... who is gonna break the news to Milky.....

0 likes

there's nowt wrong with a bit of black eyeliner.

0 likes

First band that comes to mind is local band Mira.

A nice sample: Passerby [currently my favorite song at the moment].

ETA [edited to add]

:\peek:

Siouxsie and the Banshees, Bauhaus, early Cure. --excellent examples of goth.

Depeche Mode --band that doesn't deserve to be in 'goth' catagory.

My Chemical Romance, and all those modern 'goff' bands --sorry excuses, falling under 'emo'.

AFI, around 'Sing the Sorrow' era --decent, acceptable post-modern goth. I'll leave it at that.

Joy Division and pre-EGG New Order --a class of goth by itself.

:\peek:

0 likes

What about Christian Death???

0 likes

Sisters of Mercy were amazing, and some stuff by fat bob was alright

I much prefer industrial to actual goth music

0 likes

I bet you all £40 that Biginoil has shagged one (1) goth

0 likes

£40 is yours!

Answer to the question is Yes.

0 likes

Kath wrote: £40 is yours!

Answer to the question is Yes.

Are you a Goth??

0 likes

I have, indeed, shagged one (1) goff :nod:

0 likes

BIGINOIL wrote: I have, indeed, shagged one (1) goff :nod:

What was his name ?

:evil4:

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗