can anyone categorically confirm this performance? supposedly there is an audio recording of it in existance (mp3 anyone?). someone must have taped it if it ever happened at all!
Dates
· UTC
she's lost control on Granada TV
Archived22 replies · 460 views
This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.
← Back to Digital Republic
23 posts
Originally posted by johnny james ....that would be a no then?
She's Lost Control was on BBC TV only (same night as Transmission). Shadowplay was on Granada TV. Unless I've missed something these last 25 years !
They supposedly did SLC on a Granada programme called "What's On" (I think). One of the books mentions it, and no-one has really ever confirmed it's existence, other than a very poor quality incomplete bootleg which could have come from anywhere.
Or 31/7/79 BBC Studios,Maida Vale,London : John Peel Session 1.But there was no tv camera there :D
Originally posted by Love Will Tear Us Apart Or 31/7/79 BBC Studios,Maida Vale,London : John Peel Session 1.But there was no tv camera there :D
Julio.....Granada TV is specifically for the Manchester region, which is nowhere near London......
Originally posted by Old Blue They supposedly did SLC on a Granada programme called "What's On" (I think). One of the books mentions it, and no-one has really ever confirmed it's existence, other than a very poor quality incomplete bootleg which could have come from anywhere.
I'd always had that down as a mistake by the author, confusing the Granada Reports appearance with the Something Else songs.
I was wrong it really exists.Ricardo sent me a mp3 cd including it. It sounds different from Something Else and The Peel Session but it is cut before its end.
Originally posted by KnownPleasures > Originally posted by Old Blue They supposedly did SLC on a Granada programme called "What's On" (I think). One of the books mentions it, and no-one has really ever confirmed it's existence, other than a very poor quality incomplete bootleg which could have come from anywhere.
I'd always had that down as a mistake by the author, confusing the Granada Reports appearance with the Something Else songs.
Entirely possible.
Hi folks...
...what I have on Granada TV mp3's is 'Celebration' broadcasted on Jun. 18, 1981, recorded on Apr. 23, 1981...
...tracklist: DNE, ICB, Chosen Time, Denial, Ceremony, Truth...
...what is Granada TV ?
; thx 4 answer...
Greetz, Floyd Anderson.
chatmaster1@gmx.at
moving onto Celebration on Granada TV, can anyone upload the other non-broadcast tracks from that session (including I believe a brief take of 'digital')
Originally posted by Floyd Anderson Hi folks......what I have on Granada TV mp3's is 'Celebration' broadcasted on Jun. 18, 1981, recorded on Apr. 23, 1981......tracklist: DNE, ICB, Chosen Time, Denial, Ceremony, Truth......what is Granada TV ?
It is a Manchester's(?) TV Channel.A programme called So It Goes whose presenter was Anthony Wilson on this channel,revealed the talents of punk and pos-punk scene,including Joy Division and New Order on this channel of course 
Did you watch 24 Hour Party People,Chris ?
My friend converted your video to super VCD.I was watching it almost now.
Great quality image 
Originally posted by Love Will Tear Us Apart > Originally posted by Floyd Anderson> Hi folks...> > ...what I have on Granada TV mp3's is 'Celebration' broadcasted on Jun. 18, 1981, recorded on Apr. 23, 1981...> > ...tracklist: DNE, ICB, Chosen Time, Denial, Ceremony, Truth...> > ...what is Granada TV ?
It is a Manchester's(?) TV Channel.A programme called So It Goes whose presenter was Anthony Wilson on this channel,revealed the talents of punk and pos-punk scene,including Joy Division and New order of course
Did you watch 24 Hour Party People,Chris ?
WRONG,,,NEW ORDER never appeared on SO IT GOES...shown on TV years before NEW ORDER had even started.Now come on JULIO..get your FACTS correct!
;)
Originally posted by Love Will Tear Us Apart My friend converted your video to super VCD.I was watching it almost now.Great quality image
...if u'r talking 'bout JD's 'HATYM', yes indeed - good quality, but I haven't got the time 2 see it yet from begin 'til the end...
:)
Greetz, Floyd Anderson.
chatmaster1@gmx.at
Originally posted by Rocket Mick > Originally posted by Love Will Tear Us Apart > Originally posted by Floyd Anderson> Hi folks...> > ...what I have on Granada TV mp3's is 'Celebration' broadcasted on Jun. 18, 1981, recorded on Apr. 23, 1981...> > ...tracklist: DNE, ICB, Chosen Time, Denial, Ceremony, Truth...> > ...what is Granada TV ?
It is a Manchester's(?) TV Channel.A programme called So It Goes whose presenter was Anthony Wilson on this channel,revealed the talents of punk and pos-punk scene,including Joy Division and New order of course
Did you watch 24 Hour Party People,Chris ?
WRONG,,,NEW ORDER never appeared on SO IT GOES...shown on TV years before NEW ORDER had even started.Now come on JULIO..get your FACTS correct!;)
When I was talking about New Order I was connecting with Granada TV not So It Goes,Mick 
Originally posted by Love Will Tear Us Apart I was wrong it really exists.Ricardo sent me a mp3 cd including it.It sounds different from Something Else and The Peel Session but it is cut before its end.
A cut and paste job from Joy Division Central may clear things a bit.
What's On: Granada TV, 20 July 1979 She's Lost Control (Unreleased) We're not sure about this one: Mark Johnson's book "An Ideal For Living" says this broadcast took place but if it did there is no known copy on video - and Granada haven't used the footage since. However, a poor quality version of this (which is cut short) does appear on bootleg audio tapes.
The low quality MP3 I have has been uploaded here.
Originally posted by Love Will Tear Us Apart > Originally posted by Rocket Mick> > > > Originally posted by Love Will Tear Us Apart> > Originally posted by Floyd Anderson> Hi folks...> > ...what I have on Granada TV mp3's is 'Celebration' broadcasted on Jun. 18, 1981, recorded on Apr. 23, 1981...> > ...tracklist: DNE, ICB, Chosen Time, Denial, Ceremony, Truth...> > ...what is Granada TV ?
It is a Manchester's(?) TV Channel.A programme called So It Goes whose presenter was Anthony Wilson on this channel,revealed the talents of punk and pos-punk scene,including Joy Division and New order of course
Did you watch 24 Hour Party People,Chris ?
WRONG,,,NEW ORDER never appeared on SO IT GOES...shown on TV years before NEW ORDER had even started.Now come on JULIO..get your FACTS correct!;)
When I was talking about New Order I was connecting with Granada TV not So It Goes,Mick
But this is NOT what you INFERRED here JULIO old chum.
And what is POS-PUNK?;):DCome on you don't need to make things up do you?:p
PS after finishing the CD-Rs for MONSIEUR and SHUGZV i have now started on yours!Bet you thought i had forgotten them!
Hi Mick
Pos-Punk is a brazilian army code 
Do you remember which cds I asked you? Cause I don't
Talking serious now,check you inbox m8 :D
Originally posted by KnownPleasures > Originally posted by johnny james> ....that would be a no then?
She's Lost Control was on BBC TV only (same night as Transmission). Shadowplay was on Granada TV. Unless I've missed something these last 25 years !
I have all three of these songs on video and cassette. I got the videos off a program here called Rage and tapped them off a radio station called Triple J. I never get sick of watching and listening to them, great stuff.
...Triple J...
...doesn't they broadcasted THE CURE 'Love Will Tear Us Apart' years ago ?...
Greetz, Floyd Anderson.
chatmaster1@gmx.at
