Home Community Forums Digital Republic If anyone were to replace Gillian, who would it be for you?

Dates

· UTC

If anyone were to replace Gillian, who would it be for you?

Archived

54 replies · 942 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Who would make a good replacement for Gillian?

Closed

Bono 0 (0%)
Johnny Marr 15 (33%)
Robert Smith 4 (9%)
Keith Richards 0 (0%)
King Morrissey 0 (0%)
Edward Scissorhands 17 (37%)
Other 10 (22%)

46 votes · voting closed

← Back to Digital Republic

55 posts ↑ First post Latest post ↓

7 Oct 2003, 15:18

Inspired from a dream last night were I was at a new order concert where Keith Richards was singing "Your Silent Face"

7 Oct 2003, 15:28

Tim Jauncey

His bad humor will bring New Order boring phase back from 1984 or 1985.

7 Oct 2003, 15:30

I am only joking,Tim. :evil4:

But that's not a bad idea if you join the band :D

7 Oct 2003, 15:31

ed would increase the bands overall sex appeal.

7 Oct 2003, 18:19

As a huge fan of JM :guitar: , I would choose him, but I don't think he would fit in with them, in particular, Hooky. :skeptic:

Keith Richards singing "Your Silent Face," what a hellish nightmare!

7 Oct 2003, 18:35

this is a joke...right???

7 Oct 2003, 19:19

It's got to be a girl, right? So my vote goes to Roberta Smith. :evil4:

7 Oct 2003, 20:14

Porl T. Knows keys, plays guitar. Just keep the sax out of it.

7 Oct 2003, 20:58

Phil "Cunnilingus" Cunningham is the best choice. he does it all and he does it well. besides did you noticed how the old guys enjoy his stage pressence? he definetely is what´s called "new air" to the band.

so go Phil!

7 Oct 2003, 21:44

Alan Wilder

7 Oct 2003, 22:26

Originally posted by twist Porl T. Knows keys, plays guitar. Just keep the sax out of it.

The problem with Porl is the fact that he usually plays lead guitar, instead of just a few chords and a few one-fingered keyboard parts.

7 Oct 2003, 22:52

Paul Clark.

8 Oct 2003, 03:48

No one can replace our Gill`s, but if it has to be someone, let it be a talented female of a similar age, Samantha Fox for instance.

8 Oct 2003, 04:00

How about that burd from Ladytron?:D

8 Oct 2003, 04:33

Vince Clarke from Erasure.

Failing that, Jay Darlington from Kula Shaker. :evil4:

8 Oct 2003, 04:34

Bez.

Although he might have to 'dumb down' his act a bit.

Nicer knees though!

8 Oct 2003, 06:52

kylie

la la la

8 Oct 2003, 09:30

From those little known NO impersonators: Carolyn allen of The Wake. Definately :nod:

8 Oct 2003, 11:24

Taco hasn't had any work in a while :D

8 Oct 2003, 13:03

Me.:D

8 Oct 2003, 13:27

Alan Wilder

8 Oct 2003, 14:26

Ian Curtis. He's not done anything in years.

8 Oct 2003, 14:56

Johnny Marr! The Prime Minister of Guitaring! :D

8 Oct 2003, 15:32

This is a crisis I knew had to come...

Perhaps they could rotate it, a new keyboard player every week. They could audition them from Pop Stars or Fame Academy or some other great talent show.