Skip to content

Melodica

Archived

24 replies · 574 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

The Hohner Green Soprano one beats that black and white one , what do you think?

MIke

0 likes

Not for sound quality it doesn't - I play three of them, and much prefer the Piano 25 or 27 to any of the tubular ones. Best one I have is acually a soprano Bontempi kids one, much superior sound.

0 likes

Tim I bow to your superior knowledge.

Still think the Green one looks better

MIke

0 likes

Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle Not for sound quality it doesn't - I play three of them, and much prefer the Piano 25 or 27 to any of the tubular ones. Best one I have is acually a soprano Bontempi kids one, much superior sound.

Tim - could you post a picture of them?

0 likes

Originally posted by Marko > Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle> Not for sound quality it doesn't - I play three of them, and much prefer the Piano 25 or 27 to any of the tubular ones. Best one I have is acually a soprano Bontempi kids one, much superior sound.

Tim - could you post a picture of them?

If somebody buys me a digital camera !! I'm terrible with photos, still haven't had the July Bennylux meet-up photos developed yet.....

0 likes

shows how much notice i take..i thought the green one was the only one he used. slight diversion to the thread...best use of said instrument ??

imo...hurt live.

0 likes

Originally posted by Mike Garrity Hurt at the Royal Festival Hall 84MIke

:nod::nod: Nice avatars, Mike, any particular meaning.....

0 likes

in case anyone is interested, i recently bought the best Augustus Pablo album. Valley of Jehosophat. Sounds like an old dread reflecting on a long life with long shadows in the setting sun. All filtered through the melodica. Gorgeous, uplifting and reflective.

0 likes

Originally posted by Biznotic Love Trapezoid Augustus Pablo album. Valley of Jehosophat

Thanks for the tip!

0 likes

Originally posted by little boy lost > Originally posted by Biznotic Love Trapezoid> Augustus Pablo album. Valley of Jehosophat

Thanks for the tip!

And then get "King Tubbys Meets Rockers Uptown". Oh yeah.

0 likes

got it...and Ital Dub....but Valley of Jehosophat blows them both away.

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso btw, i heard a story that the first melodica was originally from Ian. is that true? :skeptic:

Augustus Pablo's first melodica ? :nonono: :evil4:

Barney played it at school, it was the only instrument he knew. Ian liked the use of the Melodica from his Caribbean records, and it was a natural progression that the band were beginning to incorporate it at the very end. It was always Barney's melodica though, Ian wasn't an exponent.

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso btw, i heard a story that the first melodica was originally from Ian. is that true? :skeptic:

I think so - there was a piccy of it and a write-up from that magazine out earlier on this year (can't remember name), but it was an A5 magazine! :scratch:

Somebody help me out here! :smoking:

l8rs,

Nick ;)

0 likes

Originally posted by Nick King > Originally posted by almanso btw, i heard a story that the first melodica was originally from Ian. is that true? :skeptic:

I think so - there was a piccy of it and a write-up from that magazine out earlier on this year (can't remember name), but it was an A5 magazine! :scratch:

Somebody help me out here! :smoking:

l8rs,

Nick ;)

Aye, that'll be the first of the "Jack" NO special, Barney said the green 'un was Ian's, and said he loved the look of it, but doesn't use it now 'cos the keys always jam.

0 likes

Just quoting Bernard and Peter, Jack magazine, January 2003.

Barney: It's a lovely colour, unfortunately they're not the best ones as the keys jam, they just look the best. The melodica we inherited from Ian. He was an Augustus Pablo fan and introduced it to us.Hooky: He used it on "In A Lonely Place" with us just before he died.

0 likes

And there was me thinking that we all knew by now that if they say something in the media, the chances are that it is a wind-up and is almost certainly not true.

Trust me, there is a big difference between being a fan of an instrument or a style of music and being able to play it. There is very little chance that Ian was able to play IALP in that way for that demo - nowhere is there any reference to him learning to play it, and they don't just play themselves, there are breathing control issues here for a start ! It's not the easiest thing to perfect, and certainly not something you can pick up and play properly instantly. When you watch Barney play it, you can see that he can play it easily, and could back in 1981. The legacy of learning to play it at school I guess.

0 likes

Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle And there was me thinking that we all knew by now that if they say something in the media, the chances are that it is a wind-up and is almost certainly not true.

Fair enough, I was only trying to help... :nonono::nono:

0 likes

Is it really that difficult to play? The melodica part in the IALP demo is hardly complex.

0 likes

Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle And there was me thinking that we all knew by now that if they say something in the media, the chances are that it is a wind-up and is almost certainly not true. Trust me, there is a big difference between being a fan of an instrument or a style of music and being able to play it. There is very little chance that Ian was able to play IALP in that way for that demo - nowhere is there any reference to him learning to play it, and they don't just play themselves, there are breathing control issues here for a start ! It's not the easiest thing to perfect, and certainly not something you can pick up and play properly instantly. When you watch Barney play it, you can see that he can play it easily, and could back in 1981. The legacy of learning to play it at school I guess.

Fair points, but who was playing the synth in the JD demo?

0 likes

Originally posted by Atrocity Exhibit > Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle> And there was me thinking that we all knew by now that if they say something in the media, the chances are that it is a wind-up and is almost certainly not true. > > Trust me, there is a big difference between being a fan of an instrument or a style of music and being able to play it. There is very little chance that Ian was able to play IALP in that way for that demo - nowhere is there any reference to him learning to play it, and they don't just play themselves, there are breathing control issues here for a start ! It's not the easiest thing to perfect, and certainly not something you can pick up and play properly instantly. When you watch Barney play it, you can see that he can play it easily, and could back in 1981. The legacy of learning to play it at school I guess.

Fair points, but who was playing the synth in the JD demo?

Same fooker who played it on She's Lost 'Er Marbles at wherever it was :evil4:

0 likes

Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle Same fooker who played it on She's Lost 'Er Marbles at wherever it was :evil4:

Fat Bob?

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗