Face Off - Rock The Shack
Archived7 replies · 200 views
Which version do you prefer?
Closed-
Album Version 3 (30%)
-
Radio 1 Session 7 (70%)
10 votes · voting closed
well...as president of the RTS fan club...I have to say...I prefer the Radio 1 version...
but they are both outstanding...in my opinion!!!
I wonder if the alternate lyrics are just Barney without tele prompter, or they are meant to be this way... 
As the vice president of RTS fan club I say the Album version.
I like both versions, but I fine the sessons version a little raw sounding. Steve did a good job mixing the song on the cd.
I prefer neither. 'Rock The Shack' is a piece of stale crap, proving that N.O need Gillian Gilbert back a lot more than they need some mop-headed, 1960`s-obsessed gobshite from Primal Screem. 
i keep forgetting to actually listen to the Sessions version of "Rock the Shack" all the way thru (the first 5 traxs totally blow away the last 4 anyway), "RTS" is such a boring song for such a suppossed "back to basics rock out in the garage" ... the Sessions version seems a little better at first, but then seems to go on forever and ever... .... so i can't decide, except that "Rock the Shack" shows that Barney shouldn't be trying to write Stoogy style rock jams during his current mid-life crisis
Originally posted by James Stephen Barnes I prefer neither. 'Rock The Shack' is a piece of stale crap, proving that N.O need Gillian Gilbert back a lot more than they need some mop-headed, 1960`s-obsessed gobshite from Primal Screem.
Amen. Rock The Shack is the biggest bag of monkey toss that the band have done in their career I reckon. 
At a push I prefer the Radio 1 Sessions version. I really hope New Order aren't going to become some Rolling Stones clones! :\ohwell:
