Skip to content

NO documentary in Argentina (help needed)

Archived

27 replies · 507 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

today a friend of mine contacted me because he was making a number of small documentaries for TV about bands and, as he knew i was a big NO fan, he asked me for help. the idea is taking an album and use it to understand, from various disciplines, how important it was in a certain time and space. in this case they chose Substance to understand the whole electronic/dance scene until our days. i know Substance is not really an album but what can i do? they already chose it. :shrug:

one of the sides of investigation is the sociologist one. and i don´t know much about the social/political activities of NO members. i know they were on the miners' strike concert, Academy video (Aids?) and i know about War Child last year. then i have no clue. so if anyone has anything to teach me about that i´d be more than grateful. and if anyone know exact dates and images about it please tell me where i could find them.

on the other sides of investigation i´m quite well because i already studied both NO and the punk movement in terms of image and music, so i think i can cover that with no problems. also, i have records, videos and other stuff to support the dialog with images. the basic columns are the music and the image and their causes and effects, plus some lyrics analysis and some sociopolitical context. but if anyone has any ideas to help i´m all ears. ;)

0 likes

....

0 likes

i found this:

8 February, 1986. New Order play a benefit gig in aid of the labour councilmen of theMilitant Tendency, From Manchester With Love, at Liverpool Royal Court.

what was this gig about?

0 likes

You all know how bad my memory is.....but I'll have a go.....

The benefit for the Miners was held at either the Royal Albert Hall or the Festival Hall 14-5-1984 - I forever get these muddled up! I think it was Festival Hall. Brixton Academy 4-4-87 was for International AIDS Day. When Glastonbury was a CND festival New Order played in 1981. Chorley Community Centre 1981 was to get slightly balding people jobs.

I can't think of any others - I'm sure old cunts like Tim, Rocket and Jarvo will be able to help out here;)

0 likes

The Liverpool Royal Court gig was in aid of Derek Hatton's striking Scousers. Can't remember why they were striking these days, it happened a lot under Thatcher.

As far as I can remember, they've played quite a few "benefit" gigs over the years. I think we had a thread on this before (Ricardo ?) but I do recall the following:

25/10/85 London University (Mexican Earthquake benefit) 6/12/85 Central London Polytechnic (AIDS charity) 14/6/86 Sheffield City Hall 21/6/86 Loughborough University (cancer charity) 5/12/86 New York 1018 Club (for Ruth Polska's family)

There are no doubt others that I can't remember...

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso **i found this:8 February, 1986. New Order play a benefit gig in aid of the labour councilmen of theMilitant Tendency, From Manchester With Love, at Liverpool Royal Court.what was this gig about?

Here ye go, straight from the Concerts Section:thumb:

Paul Trowell: Tickets for this gig were like gold dust...the line up explains why...the fall..new order...and the smiths.....never had such a line up been seen...this was a council benefit for liverpool entitled " from manchester with love "...the compere for the night was derek hatton... for some reason new order came on first...they played a very short set...and seemed slightly disinterested in the proceedings...the encore for the gig was a mixture of all three bands playing maggies farm...the only rep from new order was hooky...

0 likes

The band themselves were not overtly "political" in the party political sense of the word.

These quotes are somewhat iffy , Bernard : "my grandad voted labour, so I voted labour".

The background of all members should be noted: epically note the Jon savage article in "heart and soul" boxset. Bernard seems to resent the tearing down of "communities" so that people can be housed 60ft up in the sky, all because of somebody down the council.

I think that the band are just cynical, cynical of politicians (of all colour), and people in power (cops& the hacienda, etc). I cant imagine any of them on a campaign trail.

I would also say that they are socially aware (see militant gigs, aids fundraisers, miners gigs, etc). The fact they put all that money into factory shows a willingness not to disappear up their own arseholes ala bono. The band are fiercely independent minded. This shows in their not following the musical posy, and allowing themselves to act how they like onstage.

Id also imagine that they are more intelligent than they let on.

The “political” (although I would consider it more social) element of the band proberbally came from the Wilson / Gretton element . Gretton was a Situationist and libertarianism seemed to be the order on the day around the factory offices (see 511), howevermuch this informed the band is debatable. I cant imagine Hooky sitting around talking about détournement, and have always suspected that Wilson was more new labour than old French intellectual. This “quirky” outlook proberbally suited the image more than the substance.

Remember, once signed to London, they “sold out” as the hippos would say, in the most spectacular fashion, and every car / trainers advert around here seems to have new order on it, so it cant be said that they are hardened leftists by any means. More Moby than Radiohead!

So basically, Id read the Jon Savage article. He describes how JD filled the gap between old labour and new Tory. His book “England’s dreaming” is really really good too. I presume they didn’t change much between 1980 and 87.

More socially aware than political, I think NewOrder’s Politics could be summed up in steve’s sardonic smile! :D

0 likes

What about the Alan Wise benefit gig?

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso **i found this:8 February, 1986. New Order play a benefit gig in aid of the labour councilmen of theMilitant Tendency, From Manchester With Love, at Liverpool Royal Court.what was this gig about?

Email me your address Alejo and I'll send you a photo copy of the Program.:)

0 likes

I seem to remember the Liverpool Royal court Gig was for 49 councillors, why I'm not sure, on strike or fired.Tickets were like gold dust got mine through a friend at poly there.I didn't even know they were playing before I was told I had a ticket. Hatton was not well recieved he was under the misguided impression we were only there for the politics!The Fall were also on blinding form that night and the Smiths were shite.so was the singalong to Maggies Farm.

0 likes

thanks, conor. very interesting what you pointed here

Originally posted by Clockwork C The “political” (although I would consider it more social) element of the band proberbally came from the Wilson / Gretton element . Gretton was a Situationist and libertarianism seemed to be the order on the day around the factory offices (see 511), howevermuch this informed the band is debatable. I cant imagine Hooky sitting around talking about détournement, and have always suspected that Wilson was more new labour than old French intellectual. This “quirky” outlook proberbally suited the image more than the substance.

is there any evidence of Gretton´s political actions? i mean, articles, interviews, anything that could confirm this? because the members of the band could have not been strictly political although "neworder" as a whole, as a concept, as a separate entity was managed by Gretton. then (i´m thinking out loud here) the image we perceived over the years was what Gretton wanted to show us, with his ideas and thoughts. as Neil Tennat said in NOstory Rob was NO´s attitude, he was the consciense that made them stay with their original ideals. what do you think? is this possible or iam pushing too far?

So basically, Id read the Jon Savage article. He describes how JD filled the gap between old labour and new Tory. His book “England’s dreaming” is really really good too. I presume they didn’t change much between 1980 and 87.

you mean the Heart & Soul booklet? i´d have to find someone who has that one...

0 likes

Didn't they also do WOMAD?

I always thought it was for charity, shame on me ;) I just checked, it's World of Music, Arts & Dance... :skeptic:

I also think the Manchester United album 2-3 years ago was for charity (the exclusive remix of Touched By The Hand of God)

0 likes

WOMAD stands for World of Music, Arts and Dance, expressing the central aim of the WOMAD festival - to bring together and to celebrate many forms of music, arts and dance drawn from countries and cultures all over the world.

WOMAD was originally inspired by Peter Gabriel: "Pure enthusiasm for music from around the world led us to the idea of WOMAD in 1980 and thus to the first WOMAD festival in 1982. The festivals have always been wonderful and unique occasions and have succeeded in introducing an international audience to many talented artists.

"Equally important, the festivals have also allowed many different audiences to gain an insight into cultures other than their own through the enjoyment of music. Music is a universal language, it draws people together and proves, as well as anything, the stupidity of racism."

As an organisation, WOMAD now works in many different ways, but our aims are always the same - at festivals, performance events, through recorded releases and through educational projects, we aim to excite, to inform, and to create awareness of the worth and potential of a multicultural society.

The WOMAD Festivals

Since the first festival in 1982, WOMAD has presented more than 90 events in 20 different countries and islands.

Having established its presence in the UK, WOMAD's unique nomadic indentity evolved gradually during the eighties. In 1988, the festival began to be presented internationally, with initial events in Denmark and Canada. Since then, WOMAD's worldwide profile has grown quickly, now embracing events in Australia, North America, South Africa, Japan and in several European countries each year.

The festivals are often weekend-long, family-oriented, active and diverse musical events, featuring simultaneous performances on two or three stages, including participatory workshops and special events for children, as well as musical and dance sessions hosted by many of the visiting artists.

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso sorry to ask, but what exactly is a "councillor" and what do they do? :scratch:

It was, or is a local government position I believe. Some kind of conflict Militant affiliations if memory serves.

0 likes

I was refering to the Heart and soul boxset book. The Savage article is really good in it. its not online but you really should try to get your hands on it.

Anything Ive ever read about the gretton mentions situationism. He named the Hacienda from a line in formulary for a new urbanism , and was famed for cossing the football hooligan/surburban press divide.

He proberbally gave them attitude, and a concience, but i doubt he could just dictate that to them. they must have been agreable. I also read somewhere that in the 80s,the band seemed aloof in interviews, but in reality they "had nothing to say", so rob told them to keep their mouths shut. maybe they were more malleable than id have thought.

0 likes

thanks again, conor. i just read the whole article about Rob. really interesting and "educational".

now i have doubts is the band played in those charity gigs because they were fully concerned or because Rob told them to. or at least helped that concern to grow. you know, i always read about the band´s political apathy and all the testimonies confirm that. Rob seemed to be more "emotional" about those matters. though i could be wrong. :shrug:

0 likes

Sounds like an interesting project, Alejo. Another thought came to mind, from NewOrderStory, when Barn is being interviewed (while having a haircut), he says he fancied writing a song about James Anderton once, as he was becoming "a particularly annoying spot on the behind of Manchester" or some such, however Barn said he just couldn't write a song 'about' something (hugely paraphrased, apologies). You can find out more about Anderton here: http://www.manchester2002-uk.com/celebs/politicians6.html Not sure this is of help, but it might be worth a look. CTB :bear:

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso **i found this:8 February, 1986. New Order play a benefit gig in aid of the labour councilmen of theMilitant Tendency, From Manchester With Love, at Liverpool Royal Court.what was this gig about?

Alejo.

At this time there was a deputy leader of our local council called Derek Hatton. He was a memeber of one of the main plitical parties called Labour (they were not in charge at the time it was Maggie Thatchers Conservatives who robbed the North of England of everthing). But he was also a member of a sub section called Militant. They spent too much ofthe governments money and nearly bankrupted Liverpool City. The 48 people in charge were n=banned from holding office after that. The concert was to raise money for there legal defence.

Dave

0 likes

Originally posted by CTB Sounds like an interesting project, Alejo. Another thought came to mind, from NewOrderStory, when Barn is being interviewed (while having a haircut), he says he fancied writing a song about James Anderton once, as he was becoming "a particularly annoying spot on the behind of Manchester" or some such, however Barn said he just couldn't write a song 'about' something (hugely paraphrased, apologies).You can find out more about Anderton here: http://www.manchester2002-uk.com/celebs/politicians6.htmlNot sure this is of help, but it might be worth a look.CTB:bear:

So who wrote Flicker? :shrug:

0 likes

the happy mondays wrote a song about anderton: gods cop

i think the band themselves were socially aware, perhaps gretton was more socially and politically (or social theory) aware. the front pag of www.cerysmaticfactory.info has some nice stories aboout him these days. check it out.

lotta continua

0 likes

well, thanks to Mr. Paul Henderson who sent me the program of the 8thFeb1986 concert for the 47 Liverpool councellors. really interesting.

it has the whole explanaition of the facts that lead the councellors to make that protest. it´s a very left oriented speech (i´ll paste the facts, if you want). but New Order´s attitude is not really what i expected. in fact i kind of find it naive. look for yourself what they decided to say in the program:

in a way it´s very "neworderish" but... well, you know! :shrug:

btw, those NO pics are great! something like drawings or cartoons. they don´t seem "real" pictures. more like someone drawing them from them pictures.

0 likes

it seems more like a photocopied version with some sort of "vertical simetry" effect (check the nose shadow on both sides...make it easier, put your hand on each picture in a way you only get to see half a face...)

0 likes

Originally posted by substance it seems more like a photocopied version with some sort of "vertical simetry" effect (check the nose shadow on both sides...make it easier, put your hand on each picture in a way you only get to see half a face...)

you´re right, i didn´t notice that! :thumb: i really like the effect

0 likes

Originally posted by Detweiler 3.63 5/12/86 New York 1018 Club (for Ruth Polska's family)

i couldn´t find any info about Ruth Polska and family. anyone knows what was the problem here and why they needed a benefit concert for?

0 likes

Wasn't Ruth Polska something to do with Factory New York and she was killed in a car accident???

0 likes

I believe it is Ruth Polsky I think she was killed by an errant Taxi cab that she wasn't actually in at the time. I think it did get mentioned in a couple of articles about new Order but which ones I don't remember. her connection with the band also escapes me.

0 likes

Didn't she book their U.S. shows?

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗