Skip to content

Get It Riiiiiight......

Archived

33 replies · 1,165 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Joy Division songs in the set.....yea or nay?

Closed
  • But of course, they wrote them, they should play them 16 (31%)
  • Maybe as an occasional treat 21 (41%)
  • Yes, but only as the encore, rather than every 2nd or 3rd track in the set 7 (14%)
  • No way Jose! 7 (14%)

51 votes · voting closed

Let Hooky take a shot at Means to An End! Decades, LWTUA, Transmission, Atmosphere and Shadow Play. But not all on the same night unless they are going to play for 2 hours.

Frankly, I wanna hear Denial, Procession, Hurt, Leave me Alone, Lonesome Tonight, The Village, EGG, Sunrise, TPK, AIIWIW, Sooner Than you Think, Broken promise.....ect ect and Primative Notion.

0 likes

The JD songs don't bother me - I actually like their take on Isolation better than the JD version - but if they can play New Order songs instead, I'd go for the latter.

0 likes

'Maybe as an occasional treat' because less is more, or so they say. I would keep Transmission though as I think that's one of the JD songs that probably suits Barney's voice most in my opinion.

I think I would savour them more, if they were an occasional treat rather than the norm.

They've got such a brilliant back catalogue, I really wish they would vary things more anyway. Having said that, i'll still be a happy girl if I get to see them live, regardless of what they play :)

0 likes

Originally posted by Tristan > Originally posted by Jason Rosero> r:> > How could anyone NOT want to hear JOY DIVISION SONGS?? WOW!!:confused2:

If New Order can barely play their own songs how do you expect them to properly play a JD tune? :p Who played guitar,bass,and drums in Joy Division then?:laugh: I'm happy for them to play whatever they feel like.:smoking:

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗