Skip to content

Waiting for the sirens' call SURVIVOR!! - FINAL ROUND

Locked Archived

52 replies · 1,730 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Which song is the sole survivor?

Closed
  • Waiting For The Sirens' Call 62 (53%)
  • Turn 54 (47%)

116 votes · voting closed

You know what's great is that I think most people will be happy no matter the outcome.

Although I think Guilt shoulda made it to the top three at least

:thumb:

e

0 likes

Turn without question. Great verse, bridge and chorus. A top tune but one that would have stuck out like a sore thumb on Technique. I dont think any NO songs would have fitted on technique period. WFTSC is a good song but I HATE the overlaping verse and chorus. Really wished they had done a fill or something instead. Also the keyboard on this track sounds a bit casio-ish and its a bit bland and repetitive. Turn woudl be great live.

0 likes

Did you really listen to WFTSC ??? :thumb: :clap: for voting Turn ???:confused2: :dead:

0 likes

Now 35/33 to Turn.

Love both songs, hope both are live this summer.

Gaz

0 likes

Guilt should have won; these two tracks are substandard compared to GIAUE and Morning Night and Day

0 likes

Voted for the title track, it's 38-36 to Turn at the moment.

0 likes

Turn is the survivor. WFTSC is good, but not up to Turn's quality. It's faster, catchy, great guitaring and decent lyrics. :thumb:

0 likes

Too close to call. I demand a recount. :evil4:

0 likes

Tarbox23 wrote: It is interesting, as both of these songs are not 'classic' new order, and both push new territory for the band....

What is not classic on WFTSC? It´s the most classic NO-song on the album!

0 likes

runwild 1 wrote:

Tarbox23 wrote: It is interesting, as both of these songs are not 'classic' new order, and both push new territory for the band....

What is not classic on WFTSC? It´s the most classic NO-song on the album!

Apart from Turn, of course!

:evil4:

0 likes

i really dont see how turn could win over wftsc. Turn in my opinion kinda bland. The songwriting on wftsc just not compare to turn. Turn is from the book of cliches.

0 likes

jonathan szwajkos wrote: i really dont see how turn could win over wftsc. Turn in my opinion kinda bland.

You've just answered yer own question, it's all down to personal opinion. And to be perfectly honest I'd put Road To Ruin as my second favourite with WFTSC 3rd:nod:

0 likes

My horror-finale... I love both songs... "WFTSC" won the coin toss.

0 likes

Nanne a.k.a. SkullCrusher wrote: The best track on the album is Guilt. Turn has some melancholic beauty. Although the intro reminds of the cure. WTFSC is great especially the intro.

*Ah, Nanne, those Muijs in your avatar!!! How I miss them!!! When my dad was still alive we went to visit our relatives much more often and I'd always bring back home all the Muijs I can!!! It's so delicious, I'm planning an import businness for Italy, it'll be a huge success... those pills are better than Extasy! ;) Anyway I voted the title track because it's more New Order and the verse is so wonderful, Turn is also great, but sounds a bit more generic alternative rock for the American target. It's true though, as Ben says the two safest choices are contending the victory, the most different songs like I Told You So have been underrated, so don't complain New Order aren't groundbreakingly innovative anymore at 50 if you then prefere the safest songs...

0 likes

let this play out for a little while. Im confident wftsc will comeback.

0 likes

WFTSC wins!!!!

lmao

Someone declare it already

e

0 likes

MY vote just put WFTSC ahead at 47 to Turn's 46.

I am sure it will change.

0 likes

C'mon WFTSC!! 48/47 - it's going down to the wire.

0 likes

Turn is going down. Surprising.

0 likes

LE Roberts wrote: Turn is going down. Surprising.

Well, at least it's close.

0 likes

With Joe gone it's Turn's turn to walk the plank. One of the blander songs on the album. Siren's call to win in a battle of the also rans.

0 likes

Well, at least it's close.

My two favorites so my heart isn't completely bleeding.

How you been P?

0 likes

So it's time to close this, the winner is the title track by 5 votes.

I must admit it's been one of the closest votes we had in those Survivor...

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗