Skip to content

Waiting for the sirens' call SURVIVOR!! - FINAL ROUND

Locked Archived

52 replies · 1,730 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Which song is the sole survivor?

Closed
  • Waiting For The Sirens' Call 62 (53%)
  • Turn 54 (47%)

116 votes · voting closed

Last match up of the game, please remember that today you are voting for a song you want to see WIN, and not for a song you wish to see eliminated.

This round will end monday.

Elimination History:

Day 1: Working Overtime Day 2: I Told You So Day 3: Jetstream Day 4: Dracula's Castle Day 5: Hey Now How You Doing Day 6: Morning Night and Day Day 7: Krafty Day 8: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 9: Who's Joe?

Immunity History:

Day 1: I Told You So Day 2: Dracula's Castle Day 3: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 4: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 5: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 6: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 7: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 8: Turn Day 9: No Immunity

Prediction: None [5/9 - 56%]

0 likes

Turn is great, but WFTSC edges it out.

0 likes

Two great songs, but WFTSC does edge out Turn.

0 likes

Turn is incredible, but WFTSC is slightly more poignant.

0 likes

Turn is fantastic, but WFTSC is rather average. Honestly, can anyone tell me what IS so special about it?

0 likes

Waiting for the Sirens'Call because it kinda sums my life up at the moment!:rolleyes:

0 likes

not really my two favorites on the album... but I'll stick to the Sirens'.

0 likes

IMO, "Turn" deserves to survive. WFTSC is good but I find it a bit "academic".

0 likes

Turn is the best song on the album (IMHO) & should therefore survive.:music:

0 likes

Out of those two - TURN:thumb:

Neither is my favourite - but both are prety good

0 likes

Yes,Turn. :thumb:

0 likes

Well, Turn is the second best. Right behind Guilt Is The Immune Emotion. :P

0 likes

Turn.

Isn't it strange that, although many people here were very critical (before its release) about the fact that the album might sound techniquey and lack innovation, the two remaining songs are the most Techniquey off the album? certainly Turn, which could have been on Technique.

0 likes

This is possibly the hardest choice of any poll we've done so far, as both of these tracks are already up there in the oldmonkey top ten.

Waiting, by a whisker.

0 likes

Spotnick wrote: Last match up of the game, please remember that today you are voting for a song you want to see WIN, and not for a song you wish to see eliminated.

This round will end monday.

Elimination History:

Day 1: Working Overtime Day 2: I Told You So Day 3: Jetstream Day 4: Dracula's Castle Day 5: Hey Now How You Doing Day 6: Morning Night and Day Day 7: Krafty Day 8: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 9: Who's Joe?

Immunity History:

Day 1: I Told You So Day 2: Dracula's Castle Day 3: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 4: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 5: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 6: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 7: Guilt Is A Useless Emotion Day 8: Turn Day 9: No Immunity

Prediction: None [5/9 - 56%]

GOD DAMMIT...You changed the rules on me!!!

Someone please change my vote for WFTSC...I hit turn to eliminate it!!!

e CK o H

0 likes

Thank you very much, E! :bow2: :evil4:

0 likes

Beatrix Kiddo wrote: Thank you very much, E! :bow2: :evil4:

You do the same thing??

I like NObabe better just FYI

e :thumb: :crazy: :baby:

0 likes

Sirens'

0 likes

wow it's a dead heat at 23/23.

0 likes

Not an easy choice as on my first listen i was blown away by WFTSC.

BUT i've just voted for Turn as its pure vintage New Order

Turn now leads by 24 votes to 23

I therefore declare this poll closed!! :evil4:

0 likes

The best track on the album is Guilt. Turn has some melancholic beauty. Although the intro reminds of the cure. WTFSC is great especially the intro.

0 likes

had to go with WFTSC...

0 likes

It is interesting, as both of these songs are not 'classic' new order, and both push new territory for the band....

Turn is a classic lp closer, you can picture the video with sumner on his yacht sailing about with a setting sun or whatever... (ironic cause WFTSC actually speaks of boating)

WFTSC is almost Sonic Youthish with its punky start, primitive kitwork, and lack of effects.... very honest song, stripped down, almost something a college indie rock would compose...

I voted for WFTSC, as it is less polished, and more sincere, less cinematic certainly, but the one i would play with my girl in the car on a sunny day....

0 likes

let's hope my vote makes Turn the winner (28/27).:clap:

0 likes

Tracey Spivey wrote: let's hope my vote makes Turn the winner (28/27).:clap:

I've just tied it at 28 each! :thumb:

0 likes

Two all-time NO classics, but judging by which one I play more, Sirens' just edges it. Really hope it's the track they open this summer's sets with.

0 likes

Thanks for resetting my vote to keep it fair

Now it's 32/28 WFTSC

e C K o H

0 likes

Turn, it's a tough call but I think the only thing to seperate them in my mind is WFTSC has an overlapping verse/chorus making it hard to sing along to and will fuck up the live version, petty I know, but with wo fantastic songs to choose from, you've got to find a reason somehow.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗