Skip to content

review(newsday)nyc show-long island newspaper

Archived

5 replies · 364 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

POP MUSIC REVIEW New Order's new wave sounds truly new

BY GLENN GAMBOA STAFF WRITER

May 7, 2005

With new new-wave all the rage this year, it only makes sense that there be a new New Order to lead the movement again.

In their first New York concert in more than a decade, the new-wave pioneers moved past their mysterious cool image that bands from Interpol to Franz Ferdinand work so hard to cultivate today. Instead, the band's 100-minute set was a celebration of its brilliant past, recast to reflect its still-potent future.

"We hope you enjoyed that as much as we did," singer Bernard Sumner said after a soulful rendition of "Run Wild," revealing the underlying theme for the evening. New Order's past is filled with misfortune - from the suicide of Ian Curtis, lead singer of the band's previous incarnation, Joy Division, to its battles with bankruptcy and substance abuse. Yet nothing but joy is evident onstage these days, from Sumner bouncing around like a schoolboy and busting out some break-dancing moves to bassist Peter Hook's triumphant poses in the spotlight, as he coaxes his unique melodies from his low-slung bass.

For years, New Order has straddled the line between dance music and rock, a move it continues on its new album "Waiting for the Sirens' Call." The one-two punch of new songs - "Hey Now, What You Doing?" and the current single "Krafty" - showed how it leans toward rock, especially with the addition of guitarist-keyboardist Phil Cunningham, who, along with drummer-keyboardist Stephen Morris, gives the band a beefier-sounding core.

The sound is reminiscent of the more rock-oriented days of Joy Division, which eventually became New Order after Curtis' death on the eve of the band's first American tour. Sumner marked the 25th anniversary of Curtis' passing with a pair of Joy Division encores, "She's Lost Control" and "Atmosphere," which still sound current today.

The strongest tribute, though, came earlier during "Love Will Tear Us Apart," which Hook called "an old-fashioned sing-along." The band seemed to feed off the crowd's frenzied reaction to the song, picking up its pace as Sumner screamed "Faster!" while the crowd sang the chorus. That high point was quickly surpassed by a roaring, set-closing version of "Temptation," restored to its manic dance-anthem version rather than the dirge-like version Moby recorded on his current album.

Of course, no New Order show is complete without "Blue Monday," the biggest-selling 12-inch single of all time and the song that launched a new genre by combining British new wave with American hip-hop rhythms and production techniques. Sumner maximized the song's drama, singing the signature line, "Now I stand here waiting," then crossing his arms and tapping his feet, while a swirl of synthesizers and Hook's memorable bass riff sped past him. There's even a nod to the current generation of "Blue Monday" lovers, as they slip in a bit of Kylie Minogue's "Can't Get You Out of My Head," which incorporates "Blue Monday" into its remix.

It's a sign of how the band continues to move forward. After all, opener Dragonette showed how easy it is to get stuck in the past. Aside from their first single "I Get Around," the British sextet's 30-minute set was mostly bland synth-pop that could have come out in 1985 - teal-blazered drummer, portable-keyboard player and all.

Dragonette's failure only reinforces how grand New Order's success is at keeping electronic music from becoming too sterile and at keeping rock music from becoming too navel-gazing. It's another innovation that today's new new-wavers need to nick from the masters.

NEW ORDER. Heeding "Sirens' Call" leads the new-wave pioneers back to artistic high ground and mainstream success. At sold-out Hammerstein Ballroom on Thursday. With Dragonette.

Subscribe to Newsday home delivery | Article licensing and reprint options

0 likes

Funny... I have yet to see a bad review of any of the shows....

I now remember Bernard standing and waiting in Blue Monday... that was funny :lol:

Did you see any picture? their photographer was with him, I've been telling him all along who was who.. and asked to send us his pictures if he wanted to, those not published of course.

0 likes

There was a photograph to accompany the review in the sunday edition. I must of misplaced it. The website did not include the photo.

He was so right on dragonette. The band was complete shit. There the exacted polar opposites of new order. Thats right new order are the masters.

Anybody know if there was a review of the show in the sunday new york times? I dont wanna pay to get on the

0 likes

The band seemed to feed off the crowd's frenzied reaction to the song, picking up its pace as Sumner screamed "Faster!" while the crowd sang the chorus

did anyone catch the word "faster" on Bernards teleprompter during LWTUA?

0 likes

http://www.longislandpress.com/?cp=146&show=article&a_id=2749

New Order Takes Hammerstein Legends of Club Pop and Indie Rock Try To Tap Into Their Youth Kenny Herzog 05/06/2005 1:08 pm

I’m not quite sure what I was expecting by seeing New Order Thursday night, May 5, at the Hammerstein Ballroom. Perhaps something like what I pictured listening to them on record all these years: A maddened crowd of hundreds dancing euphorically to unlikely club hits like “Bizarre Love Triangle” and “Blue Monday.” Maybe a vast sea of clapping bodies singing along to “Temptation” and “True Faith,” resulting in an experience that would leave everyone in attendance breathless and fulfilled.

All the aforementioned classics were unleashed, in addition to no less than three Joy Division tracks (in honor of Ian Curtis having committed suicide 25 years ago, as singer/guitarist Bernard Sumner reminded the crowd). But it ultimately amounted to what my pragmatic self should have braced for: a bunch of really cramped, largely stoic New Yorkers sporadically bursting with energy for a group of guys beginning to show their age on stage.

“We are New Order, as if you didn’t know,” Sumner joked as the U.K. legends launched into a fiery rendition of “Love Vigilantes” to open the show. A promising start, but one that would start the course for an uncomfortable, but expected, ebb and flow: a plodding rendition off a cut from their latest, Waiting for the Sirens’ Call, followed by an upbeat, audience-invigorating flashback to their ‘80s heyday.

The biggest problem facing the band was not their age (though Sumner’s frequent impromptu jig felt like watching your middle-aged dad embarrass himself at a relative’s wedding) or the set’s more low-key moments. From the first song to the last, the sound mix was muddled, and often, the only time Sumner’s vocals were crystal clear were during his abrupt and rather unwelcome yelps, screams and whistles.

Fortunately, Peter Hook and his ever-recognizable bass riffing were in full force. And Hook himself was in dynamic form, wildly pacing the stage and frequently prodding the audience with good-natured ribbing like, “This is the ugliest f**king front row I’ve ever seen in me life…I feel right at home.”

And for sure, any lulls in the set were quickly forgotten when “Regret” got the crowd rocking or Joy Division’s “Love Will Tear Us Apart” sent poignant shivers of nostalgia up the crowd’s collective spine.

The encore, which also featured a rare performance of JD’s “She’s Lost Control,” ended on the highest of notes, as the thumping beat of “Blue Monday” had even the pretty-boy VIPs (including Interpol’s Carlos D and radio/MTV personality Booker) on their feet, with Hook wildly bashing away on upright drum machines for one final, triumphant bit of clamor.

I may not have come away with the dance party of a lifetime, and technical issues and the perils of age and a less-than-idyllic set list may have kept the show on an uneven keel, but when they hit their mark, New Order reminded me of just how important, innovative and euphoric they can be.

0 likes

Hooky was by far the most dominant person on the stage lol

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗