Skip to content

The Perfect Cover

Archived

6 replies · 284 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

In the hallowed halls of pointless fan speculation, there are countless antechambers filled with the logged conversations of who should render the ultimate cover version of whom's song. This thread is no different. Tell us which artists you think could give the best performances of which NO tunes.

Massive Attack - Ruined In a Day, Everyone Everywhere

Ever since listening to the K-Class remix of RIAD, i've thought that both these songs would lend themselves well to a down-tempo trip hop remake. Add the Attack's patois-inflected vocals as well.

British Sea Power - Regret, Procession

All being said, The Get Up Kids' emo cover of Regret wasn't all that bad, despite the fact that none of them were capable enough to play the lead guitar riff on well, guitar (they used a toy keyboard).

BSP is the only group sans Echo & The Bunnymen with enough pomp and bombast to deliver an adequately operatic cover of Regret. Also, Yan's quavering vocals and the group's default sound already form a good fit for Procession's bizarre lyrics and terse, twitchy tempo.

0 likes

Personally I think Pete Wylie could do a blistering version of Regret.

The Wedding Present could possibly do justice to Ceremony.

Billy Bragg would do a great solo accoustic version of Temptation.

And for some strange reason I could see Morrissey singing a campy version of Waiting for the Sirens Call...

0 likes

Kerry Harris wrote: The Wedding Present could possibly do justice to Ceremony.

I've always thought "As it is when it was" would be perfect for a full-on Wedding Present treatment, Seamonsters-era. The slow quiet start, building up to a wall of guitar noise(well, noisier than most New Order songs anyway), and the angst-y lyrics, all seems very Wedding Present to me.

0 likes

The singer of the Wedding Present also nicely splits the difference between Ian Curtis and Barney. He's got the kind of angry gutteral Ian Curtis thing happening but with a slighty more melodic edge to it a la Barney.

As well, their bassist seems to be a natural for playing some Peter Hook lines.

0 likes

Deep-bass voice of Leonard Cohen singing "Thieves Like Us" would be smashing.

Mike Scott and the Waterboys doing a twangy version of "Lonesome Tonight"

0 likes

Sultans of Ping should do Transimission!

0 likes

I would like to hear Ozzy sing State Of The Nation. :laugh:

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗