Skip to content

Hooky gets some respect in Adam Clayton Interview

Archived

24 replies · 874 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Here is a little snippet from an interview in the recent bass player magazine interview with U2's Adam Clayton.

What other bass players do you feel are really good at that?

I’ve always been hugely respectful of Peter Hook. He’s always managed to weave a melancholic, melodic thread through Joy Division and New Order. The problem is that sometimes the root isn’t there, and that’s not U2—we need the root for what we do. I adore anything [Motown’s] James Jamerson ever played on. His playing had such feel, flair, and personality. [The Who’s John] Entwistle is on the edge of being technically too perfect for me. Sometimes it’s hard to see the humanity in that. He’s like an athlete. I’m drawn to R&B—players like Duck Dunn. I like the heaviness of those grooves, and I love those melodies.

On Boy, you played open-string drones like Peter Hook on “Out of Control” and “The Electric Co.”

Early on, we didn’t have very good equipment, and the bass was rarely in the PA. So I always figured if two strings were going instead of one, you get a bit more volume. Also, at the time Edge was playing very minimal guitar melodies, and this was a way of getting more power into those songs. That was great for what we were, which was essentially a three-piece band.

The whole article is posted here if you are interested.

http://www.bassplayer.com/story.asp?storycode=12388

0 likes

Adam Clayton sucks, but at least he give's Hooky his "Props" entwistle is too perfect? whats that mean? the OX was the man

0 likes

adam clayton sucks ass i can play bass better than adam clayton

john entwistle oh my god hes amazing, r.i.p the ox i love the who :love2:

0 likes

I was reading an interview with The Edge the other day. He said "I'm not really a guitarist".

Has anyone seen articles where Clayton and Bono admit that they are crap too?

0 likes

U2 has a bassist?

0 likes

Every band as its disposable member...

For the Beatles it was Ringo For U2, it's Adam Clayton For Depeche Mode, it's Andrew Fletcher

... and for New Order, it was Gillian apparently (ducking to avoid beer cans)

0 likes

And for Black Sabbath, it was Ozzy.

Or so they thought.

0 likes

Christopher Owens wrote: And for Black Sabbath, it was Ozzy.

Or so they thought.

the must have though very little of Ozzy they Replaced him with a dwarf!

0 likes

You take that back you daft bastard. Gillian took one for the team. Want Steve to quit? Think Bernard can care for others' children? Hooky?

0 likes

twist wrote: You take that back you daft bastard. Gillian took one for the team. Want Steve to quit? Think Bernard can care for others' children? Hooky?

Relax, it was irony...

It's impossible to think Gillian wasn't involved AT ALL in the WFTSC process, damn it, she's married with Steve...

0 likes

It's easy for U2 to claim that they are shit.....

a) they are b) they've got the money and fame to stick two fingers up at those who made them rich by now telling the punter that they are wrong to have bought their records!

0 likes

My bass heroes have always been Hooky, JJ Burnel, Mr Entwhistle and Cliff Burton (in that order). They've all influenced the stuff I've recorded with bands in some way or another. :thumb:

0 likes

I've gone off U2 completely since their last album which was funnily enough "About As Welcome As An Atomic Bomb" and Bono's charidee antics, he can fuck right off.

I've never rated Clayton as a bassist. He talks of U2 needing a "root" in this interview, well if needing "a root" is code for "play my bass as ploddingly and as boringly as possible" then he's hit the nail on the head there. If you listen to any U2 song the bass is 'there' but it's never doing much, it's just "dum dum dum" up and down whatever melody the song has; coma inducing.

Didn't they replace Clayton with a roadie at one Achtung gig because he was too pissed to go onstage? Somehow I can't see a roadie being musically able to substitute for Hooky at any New Order gig.

Despite my dislike of U2 I can see that The Edge and Mullen Jnr. are good players. Edge's guitar has gone a little too "cliched U2" of late but Mullen is a great drummer. It's just a pity their frontman is a messiah-like arsehole :nonono:

0 likes

From the interview excerpt, I hope that things between NO and U2 patch up. The Clayton interview surprised me since I have been holding a "celebrity grudge" about what Bono did in NewOrder Story. Actually, I'm very ambivalent about it; I like U2 too. However, I respect NO more.

0 likes

Alistair wrote: I've gone off U2 completely since their last album which was funnily enough "About As Welcome As An Atomic Bomb" and Bono's charidee antics, he can fuck right off.

I've never rated Clayton as a bassist. He talks of U2 needing a "root" in this interview, well if needing "a root" is code for "play my bass as ploddingly and as boringly as possible" then he's hit the nail on the head there. If you listen to any U2 song the bass is 'there' but it's never doing much, it's just "dum dum dum" up and down whatever melody the song has; coma inducing.

Didn't they replace Clayton with a roadie at one Achtung gig because he was too pissed to go onstage? Somehow I can't see a roadie being musically able to substitute for Hooky at any New Order gig.

Despite my dislike of U2 I can see that The Edge and Mullen Jnr. are good players. Edge's guitar has gone a little too "cliched U2" of late but Mullen is a great drummer. It's just a pity their frontman is a messiah-like arsehole :nonono:

Yeah, the first '93 ZOO TV gig in Sydney was the one where AC was missing in action- of course he was all well and good for the second gig, which was televised and later released on video.
0 likes

Gawd! Adam Clayton is one of my fave bassists, along with PH, Stefan Olsdal (Placebo), and Bob Babbit (motown guy - replaced JJ).

The guy isn't nearly as adventurous as Hooky, but he helps create a great rhythm groove with the drummer. Exactly what a bassist should. I mean the pre-millenium U2, that is. New stuff is crap. :\ohwell:

0 likes

Jack_H wrote: adam clayton sucks ass i can play bass better than adam clayton

You didn't have a helping hand did you?

i have to agree though, you have mature taste for a sprog.

0 likes

Jack_H wrote: adam clayton sucks ass i can play bass better than adam clayton

john entwistle oh my god hes amazing, r.i.p the ox i love the who :love2:

:nod:

0 likes

Clayton's style is like Paul Simmonon's except on heavy sedatives. I'm surprised U2 haven't bastardized "Straight to Hell" yet for their cover routine.

Oh yeah, and Ringo wasn't so disposable. Lennon always told his session drummers to play like him. And if you listen to what Paul McCartney does as a drummer, it's all Ringo except he's reverted to a closed hi-hat.

0 likes

Swifty wrote: Gawd! Adam Clayton is one of my fave bassists, along with PH, Stefan Olsdal (Placebo), and Bob Babbit (motown guy - replaced JJ).

The guy isn't nearly as adventurous as Hooky, but he helps create a great rhythm groove with the drummer. Exactly what a bassist should.

I would like to be one of the few to give Adam Clayton some respect. Mad props, even. I think the man is utterly fantastic.

:bow:

Seriously folks -- if you've ever been in a band, Adam Clayton is the kind of guy you want on bass: rock solid, egoless, and dead on it. And face it -- the guy's working in range of Bono's radioactive ego. Fuck that. I couldn't hold that gig for a day.

Hooky? Also fantastic, but to the point where any record he's on will sound like a NO record to some extent.

Again, I bow to you, Adam Clayton. Please join my band.

:bow: :love:

0 likes

Spotnick wrote: Every band as its disposable member...

For the Beatles it was Ringo For U2, it's Adam Clayton For Depeche Mode, it's Andrew Fletcher

... and for New Order, it was Gillian apparently (ducking to avoid beer cans)

I'd have thought it was Ian Curtis :rofl:

0 likes

Gnu Odor wrote:

Swifty wrote: Gawd! Adam Clayton is one of my fave bassists, along with PH, Stefan Olsdal (Placebo), and Bob Babbit (motown guy - replaced JJ).

The guy isn't nearly as adventurous as Hooky, but he helps create a great rhythm groove with the drummer. Exactly what a bassist should.

I would like to be one of the few to give Adam Clayton some respect. Mad props, even. I think the man is utterly fantastic.

:bow:

Seriously folks -- if you've ever been in a band, Adam Clayton is the kind of guy you want on bass: rock solid, egoless, and dead on it. And face it -- the guy's working in range of Bono's radioactive ego. Fuck that. I couldn't hold that gig for a day.

Hooky? Also fantastic, but to the point where any record he's on will sound like a NO record to some extent.

Again, I bow to you, Adam Clayton. Please join my band.

:bow: :love:

Give it a rest, he's sucks. of course he keeps quiet, he might be the worst bass player ever, but he is making tons of money and even gets praised as a friggin Demi-God by people like you. sorry i never got caught up in that U2 gimmick. sorry for being so harsh :thumb:

0 likes

frank smarra wrote: sorry for being so harsh :thumb:

Don't be sorry for being so harsh... be sorry for being so wrong. ;)

Sometimes I set the old stereo to simulate the sound I got when playing gigs; that is, wearing earplugs and standing directly in front of an 18" woofer tearing out of its cabinet.

My man Adam passes the test; another fave is Gary Beers from INXS. Solid through and through. And when you've got some guy named the Edge diddling though a delay box as "your band's sound," you need to provide a solid foundation.

0 likes

Gnu Odor wrote:

frank smarra wrote: sorry for being so harsh :thumb:

Don't be sorry for being so harsh... be sorry for being so wrong. ;)

Sometimes I set the old stereo to simulate the sound I got when playing gigs; that is, wearing earplugs and standing directly in front of an 18" woofer tearing out of its cabinet.

My man Adam passes the test; another fave is Gary Beers from INXS. Solid through and through. And when you've got some guy named the Edge diddling though a delay box as "your band's sound," you need to provide a solid foundation.

Well I bought the Vertigo tour dvd and watched it yesterday for the first time and you can say what you like, those guys work well together and have some good songs in their catalogue. And that's despite their knob of a singer..!

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗