Skip to content

JD Spotting in Article about GRUPS

Archived

13 replies · 263 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

This is a fantastic article about 30-40 somethings who act like they're 22. But not what 22 was when THEY were 22, but what 22 is now. In other words, annoying fuckers who won't grow up.

http://newyorkmetro.com/news/features/16529/index.html

The Grup Music, or the Brand-new Sound of Twenty Years Ago Once upon a time, pop culture, and in particular pop music, followed a certain reliable pattern: People listened to bands, like the Doobie Brothers or Cream or Steely Dan, that their Frank Sinatra–loving parents absolutely despised. Then these people had kids, and their kids became teens, and they started listening to bands, like the Clash or Elvis Costello or Joy Division, that their Cream-loving parents absolutely despised. And, lo, the Lord looked down and saw that it was good, and on the eighth day, He created the generation gap.

And then these Clash-listening kids grew up and had kids of their own, and the next generation of kids started listening to music, like Franz Ferdinand and Interpol and Bloc Party, that you might assume their parents would absolutely despise. Except it doesn’t really work that way anymore. In part, because how can their parents hate Interpol when they sound exactly like Joy Division? And in part, because how can their parents hate Bloc Party when their parents just downloaded Bloc Party and think it’s awesome and totally better than the Bravery!

What does it mean that I listen to the Clash, Elvis Costello, and Joy Division? That I'm really 40 trying to be 22 or that I'm 25 trying to be 40 trying to be 22? because I can't fucking stand interpol.

0 likes

I'm 18 and listen to The Clash, Joy Division and Interpol.

What does that supposedly make me?

0 likes

I'm 40 soon, and don't listen to The Clash or Interpol. Or Bloc Party. Or Elvis Costello as much as I used to. Joy Division? Never heard of 'em!

0 likes

Woah, talk about Generation X. Still, I'm proud to be part of Generation Y. How bad can we be?

0 likes

I'll take the heat: Antics is a good album.

0 likes

I saw the Editors tuesday night. After a couple of songs I thought to myself - It's Joy Division - without the mistakes!

I agree with the article though - I have had conversations with the babysitter about Radiohead.

All the teens/young 20 somethings in the local are into rock - Rolling Stones/Rory Gallagher/Aerosmith - stuff that once upon a time I considered old persons music.

0 likes

How were (the) Editors? Watching them Monday, can't wait :thumb:

0 likes

JonnyMac wrote: I saw the Editors tuesday night. After a couple of songs I thought to myself - It's Joy Division - without the mistakes!

I agree with the article though - I have had conversations with the babysitter about Radiohead.

All the teens/young 20 somethings in the local are into rock - Rolling Stones/Rory Gallagher/Aerosmith - stuff that once upon a time I considered old persons music.

god it's still old people's music

there are so many kids I went to high school with that would listen to the doors and other such shit.

I wonder if they listen to interpol now.. or the classic rock station going OMG ZEPPLIN MAN!!

0 likes

I'd say the Doors are pretty important to JD...

0 likes

this is so typical of American journalism, media, and attitudes towards peoples expected roles in society.

0 likes

[magenta]Jem[/magenta] wrote: How were (the) Editors? Watching them Monday, can't wait :thumb:

Editors are great live, you shouldn't be disappointed!

0 likes

[magenta]Jem[/magenta] wrote: How were (the) Editors? Watching them Monday, can't wait :thumb:

Really, really good. The lead singer is a ball of energy. The two guitarists are amazing musicians - incredibly tight.

All in all very impressed.

0 likes

oldmonkey wrote: I'm 40 soon, and don't listen to The Clash or Interpol. Or Bloc Party. Or Elvis Costello as much as I used to. Joy Division? Never heard of 'em!

Neither do I :rolleyes:

0 likes

I, along with a good chunk of my friends, listen almost exclusively to older music (pre-1991 bands). I think it's a major part of the members of Gen Y who don't like rap...

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗