GIAUE and WJ Live Question...

Most of you are gonna think I am a total idiot for asking this...but its Sunday and my curiosity has gotten then better of me...

When New Order played Whose Joe? And Guilt Is a Useless Emotion live in 2006, did Phil play any of the keyboard parts live at all, such as the synth intro to WJ or the Keyboard melody on GIAUE?

I have just been wondering. I figured the Glasgow DVD would have been out by now to answer my question. But no......

Well, any help would be appreciated. I am a synth nerd, which is why I am asking.

Cheers!

Can't recall about GIAUE but at the Wolverhampton gig Oct 2006 Phil appeared to play the intro to Who's Joe? on the keyboard.Most prob miming though? A lot of dry ice was bellowing out at that moment which added to the dramatic intro but was probably to mask Phil's miming

Both played via hard disk recorder, Phil did guitars on Who's Joe and I think some keys on Guilt.

I probably played more keyboards at those gigs than Phil Did. I'm just jealous.