musicoloog wrote:
Knuckles wrote:
God damn you have an answer for everything. I like, though.
Well, these are not really answers, but just looking for explanations to sound like someone who seems to know everything... as if I don't know where these versions were used for...
So, tell me, what's the 'need' in putting a special different version on a US promo, bother to re-edit the original mix for the video...etc. etc. It just makes no sense.

of course i didn't work for factory/london..
but i did work with group KMFDM for some time,
and when i asked about why they had so many releases,
edits, etc, they told it was all due to marketing,
and different regions. the band didn't have that much
control about what got released after the label took it.
now they control their own music, so they can control
it a lot better..
the same situation probably happened for new order,
once it's out of the bands hand, the studio can
commission whatever release mixes, promo mixes,
radio edits, club mixes get done... but the actual
details of the edits are not up to them..
videos can be very complicated, as in this case
especially because the video included original
footage, and sounds not in the original song,
how are they supposed to use the same mix for that?
of course they're going to have to recut it for
the video, also, sometimes their are remix videos,
such as for world, and sometimes extended videos too.
if you have worked in the music industry,
you would know these issues..
later
-1