I became a Joy Division fan first after hearing Twenty Four Hours on an indie radio in 1988, and it's still my favourite Joy Division song.
When I bought New Order's Substance of course I liked Ceremony but I couldn't really get the other songs.
Unfortunately I was also influenced, as a 15 years old kid could be, by stupid journos and goths which revered the cult of Joy Division but they all basically were saying New Order sold out to the dancefloor.
I bought Movement and I liked the most of the tracks, the difference between that album and the other tracks on the vynil Substance prevented me even more from accepting their evolution. Movement, to me, was their last good album, though not as good as Closer, before selling out, so I couldn't really call myself A New Order Fan.
They were releasing Technique by then, and hearing Fine Time on the jukebox didn't really help.
But one day I was walking and all those keyboard layers from Blue Monday came back to my mind and I just realized their greatness.
I ran back home and heard Substance many more times and I started to adore every track apart from the weakest ones (you know which ones, the unholy "S" trinity).
Perfect Kiss and True Faith became second and third favourites because they just had those huge tunes of keyboards and bass, and that rhythm I hated now I was loving.
EGG was the perfect bridge between Movement and Blue Monday, Temptation and Confusion (even in those versions which weren't better than the original ones) and BLT became other favourites.
Power Corruption And Lies became my favourite album because it had just everything, great electro tracks and great guitar pop tracks, I just found it all amazingly inspired.
I loved the other albums as well, and the same Fine Time I hated became one of my favourites, I told the silly goths to fuck off and when I was ready to love World In Motion I knew by then that I became A New Order Fan! 