The New Order Cup 2012 Last 32 - Tie 7 Your Silent Face vs The Perfect Kiss

tough away tie for one of the pre-tourney faves?

That's a nasty one...

You are mean

Too fucking close for comfort mate..... how do you choose?

kiss

TPK only because it was the opener at my first ever gig for that reason only.

fuc 123 the perfect piss off

Your Silent Face is an awesome tune, it gets my vote.

Two of my favourite but YSF gets the nod. One of my all time favourites

The full symphonic majesty of TPK gets my vote.

It's more a question of which of the two has the bigger climax and which one of those climaxes really moves mountains. In this respect it's Fac 123 every time. I think that is the one with BY FAR the biggest ever ending of ANY New Order single. It's simply colossal. And it really gets the hairs on the back of my 'eck neck standing upright when you crank up the volume. A total wall of synthesised sound, the like of which New Order will never ever better. Just awesome and orgasmic!

TPK

I hated KW1 for years as they always played it when I was hoping for something a bit different, seemed to be ever present.

TPK has been the finest 8 minutes plus of music I've heard in the last 30 years, and is still unprecedented. Nobody has bettered that ending ever.