Skip to content

Worst live track ?

Archived

37 replies · 1,062 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Originally posted by Paul Roy I actually liked the fooked up keyboards of LWTUA from Les Bains as well as Isolation/Decades from still. But then I am a strange fellow so...Somebody already mentioned True Faith from '97. I will give them a bit of slack cause Barney did warn the audience.

strangely enough I like those keyboards too. The songs are MEANT to be unsettling!

0 likes

[Content deleted by still point on 11/27/2002 3:49:25 PM EDT]

0 likes

I'm gonna open myself to hate mail and ask a VERY VERY VERY newbieish question here -

On the 316 dvd, on the 1981 gig, they play Temptation at the end. it's about 13 or so minutes long and the lyrics are all just...wrong. Did they make it up on the spot? What?!

0 likes

At that stage, Temptation was very much "work in progress". It had been played as an instrumental a couple of times prior to that tour, and it was on that tour that Barney started to conjure up some of the words (at that stage in his lyric-writing career, he made them up on stage and sifted through live tapes to see what he liked). When I saw them in January 82, Temptation had the words that we came to recognise instantly. He's done this over the years until Technique, when the songs were written primarily in the studio rather than allowed to evolve naturally from live jams.

0 likes

sister ray - bbc radio 1 live in concert 87. they just played the same f***ing riff again and again for about 10 minutes. steve´s out of tempo, barney fights (and loses) with his guitar... and he´s singing a total different thing than Ian on SR-Still version. never heard the original but I guess barney f***ed up as he usually does.

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso sister ray - bbc radio 1 live in concert 87. they just played the same f***ing riff again and again for about 10 minutes. steve´s out of tempo, barney fights (and loses) with his guitar... and he´s singing a total different thing than Ian on SR-Still version. never heard the original but I guess barney f***ed up as he usually does.

Ian knew the words !! JD's version was an authentic attempt at a cover version, whereas the NO take on it is a random jam...

0 likes

Originally posted by Benny's Cobweb Eyes At that stage, Temptation was very much "work in progress". It had been played as an instrumental a couple of times prior to that tour, and it was on that tour that Barney started to conjure up some of the words (at that stage in his lyric-writing career, he made them up on stage and sifted through live tapes to see what he liked). When I saw them in January 82, Temptation had the words that we came to recognise instantly. He's done this over the years until Technique, when the songs were written primarily in the studio rather than allowed to evolve naturally from live jams.

and he STILL gets them wrong to this day!! :laugh:

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso sister ray - bbc radio 1 live in concert 87. they just played the same f***ing riff again and again for about 10 minutes.

that's exactly what the original's like, only it's 17 mins!!!

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗