NotAMod wrote:
I would imagine if the band were seriously unhappy with what the Analog Loyalist was doing then they would have instructed their management and/or record label to have these (and the Recycle blog) pulled down long ago. Since that hasn't happened - Recycle's been up there for 3 years now - then I think it's safe to assume some sort of tacit approval for what's been happening. These shows would have disappeared into a rich collector's stash never to be heard again and I for one think it's wonderful all the fans get to hear them. Add to that, lower quality versions of these shows have been circulating amongst fans (for free) for decades now; bar AL's superb new mastering they're not really new content.
As for your assertion regarding Warners "Would they (release them)?" - of course they wouldn't, it just wasn't going to happen and we'd probably get another fucking "Best Of".
Plus the original band can't even agree on a release for the remaining original material (Lost Sirens) let alone come together to approve a series of obscure mid-80s gigs.
This was the only way.
Steve loved the Recycle blog, the label thought it was terrifically executed but weren't happy the stuff was downloadable for free. Bernard - as of a month or so ago - had never even heard of the Recycle blog. So I'd say they are aware.
I've not been instructed by Andy to cease/desist the Archives project - then again, it's only been up for a few days. But unless I start posting private tapes (which I won't), I don't expect any sort of direction from the label or management at all. As stated in the blog's mission statement, all material I post will be community sourced and generally-otherwise-available live stuff, except mastered to near-perfection. They'd have a bit of a project on their hands if they wanted all these live postings here, there and everywhere, stopped and removed.
As I alluded to in the "welcome" post on TNOA, the label/band had the perfect opportunity to do this themselves, with their hundreds of soundboard tapes from Rob's and Hooky's archives, in 2008. There were semi-concrete plans in place to do a series of gigs, one for each album, and the gigs were chosen, tapes mastered by me, and ultimately delivered to the band ready to go. Then the label dropped it. None of those gigs (except maybe that chosen for Technique, which came from us anyway) will be posted on TNOA.