6 replies · 524 views
Out of curiousity, I'm filling the discography on the site (it's far from over, trust me) and I've manage to discover that Temptation and Blue Monday on the 24 Hour Party People Soundtrack are exclusive versions...
In fact, they are edited versions of the Substance Versions...
Anyone can confirm this? or tell me if they have seen those versions elsewhere?
Temptation is definately an edit of the 87 version, they've chopped out about a minute from the middle.
Don't think Blue Monday is any different 
My Substance version of BM is 7'28'. I think it's the same as the original 12'. Do you have a special copy, mr. webmaster?
Originally posted by Bart Dupré My Substance version of BM is 7'28'. I think it's the same as the original 12'. Do you have a special copy, mr. webmaster?
No, I rely too much on the New Order Discography website I guess...
Alright, I will pop up my CDs in the future to get the right timing... I must wat T. Ivarsson about the errors in his discography site though, after all, we're "partners"... (sharing info)
I noticed that Blue Monday was remastered, and there's a different mix of She's Lost Control that I haven't heard before. It sounds like they mixed the 12" version from the box set with the 12" version from Substance.
Now, I've tried to go over this once at "another site", but all I did was confuse everyone. So hopefully you guys can see what I'm talking about...
Ok, the 12" of She's Lost Control from the Heart and Soul box set is quite different than the Substance version. It sounds like it has more effects added to it, and it ends with a bass line.
The version on Substance sounds less produced and more raw, the creepy synth solo is longer and begins earlier than the box set version, and the song fades out at the end after Ian says "when here we come".
Originally posted by Low-Life I noticed that Blue Monday was remastered, and there's a different mix of She's Lost Control that I haven't heard before. It sounds like they mixed the 12" version from the box set with the 12" version from Substance.Now, I've tried to go over this once at "another site", but all I did was confuse everyone. So hopefully you guys can see what I'm talking about...Ok, the 12" of She's Lost Control from the Heart and Soul box set is quite different than the Substance version. It sounds like it has more effects added to it, and it ends with a bass line.The version on Substance sounds less produced and more raw, the creepy synth solo is longer and begins earlier than the box set version, and the song fades out at the end after Ian says "when here we come".
Indeed, there are two versions of "She’s Lost Control" 12" (or at least two different mixes). The full version (4:56, no fade out, ends with a keyboard solo) can be found on "Martin" compilation, "Heart & Soul" boxset and some versions of "Substance" (vinyl only?). The fade out version (4:44, longer keyboard solo) can be found on FACUS2 12", FACUS2UK 12", "And Here Is The Young Man" compilation, some versions of "Substance" and "24 Hour Party People" OST. The latter sounds just a remastered version of the fade out version, with higher volume and clearer sound from the instruments, that's why you're thinking it's a mixed version.
Still confused?
