Home Community Forums Digital Republic Which JD song should NO bring back to the setlist?

Dates

· UTC

Which JD song should NO bring back to the setlist?

Archived

47 replies · 771 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Which JD song should NO bring back to the setlist?

Closed

A Means To An End 1 (2%)
Atrocity Exhibition 1 (2%)
Colony 1 (2%)
Day Of The Lords 2 (4%)
Dead Souls 4 (7%)
Decades 5 (9%)
Disorder 5 (9%)
Glass 0 (0%)
Heart And Soul 2 (4%)
Insight 0 (0%)
New Dawn Fades 7 (12%)
Novelty 4 (7%)
Passover 1 (2%)
Shadowplay 7 (12%)
Something Must Break 1 (2%)
The Eternal 0 (0%)
The Sound of Music 3 (5%)
These Days 2 (4%)
Twenty Four Hours 5 (9%)
Other (Specify) 6 (11%)

57 votes · voting closed

← Back to Digital Republic

Showing posts 31–48 of 48 ↑ First post Latest post ↓

16 Nov 2003, 20:36

Originally posted by Grigori can I vote for none of the above???I would really prefer to only hear order choons at an order gig!!!come on, flame me...I can take it!!!

well, i agree with you jeff. not because i don´t like JD ones. but because i´d hate them to become their "best tribute band". they used to surprise and to take concerts as an artistic creation. and they were different for that. now they´re just like any other band. they just put a "greatest hits" show, the "politically correct" decision. and i just hate it happens. :nonono:

16 Nov 2003, 20:41

I think A Means to an End wouldn't be at all out of place at a NO show. It's definitely one of the danciest JD songs, so it would fit right in at a New Order gig.

16 Nov 2003, 23:01

Originally posted by Grigori can I vote for none of the above???I would really prefer to only hear order choons at an order gig!!!come on, flame me...I can take it!!!

Couldn't agree more.

17 Nov 2003, 02:48

seconded on the "none of the above vote", they are NOT JD now and would only do inferior versions, punctuated by barneys annoying whoops and whistles, I'm not sure they could even do their own early stuff justice anymore so forget JD

17 Nov 2003, 03:34

Originally posted by His Holiness, The Pope I think A Means to an End wouldn't be at all out of place at a NO show. It's definitely one of the danciest JD songs, so it would fit right in at a New Order gig.

Barney could never play it properly in those days, and that was before the E and Pernod !

17 Nov 2003, 11:48

SHADOWPLAY.

I would like to hear it with Barney, it is my favourite JD song. :clap:

17 Nov 2003, 17:27

None. Don't get me wrong I like JD. But I feel they've done their JD thing. There are heaps on NO songs I'd like to hear. After all when I go see NO I want to see NO. At first I thought it was great they played JD songs, but these days I tend to skip them on my live recordings.

17 Nov 2003, 20:50

Not to be too much of a geek, but I've got a pretty good idea of what the ultimate NO setlist would be (for me at least). Decades as the opening song on the encore is the only JD track included. In my opinion, it's the only JD track that I've heard NO do that is better than the JD version. Of course, they haven't done them all, and the only live JD take is that piss poor effort from Still, but still it has all the makings of a great NO track. Bouncy melancholia.

18 Nov 2003, 03:32

Originally posted by Ronald Kirsch None. Don't get me wrong I like JD. But I feel they've done their JD thing. There are heaps on NO songs I'd like to hear. After all when I go see NO I want to see NO. At first I thought it was great they played JD songs, but these days I tend to skip them on my live recordings.

At last, someone on my wavelength !!

18 Nov 2003, 11:44

DECADES.

19 Nov 2003, 14:02

Forget Joy Division songs , how about some of their own classics;

Hurt Age Of Consent Sunrise Face Up Senses Chosen Time

Mike

19 Nov 2003, 18:59

Originally posted by Mike Garrity Forget Joy Division songs , how about some of their own classics;HurtAge Of ConsentSunriseFace UpSenses Chosen TimeMike

Ditto.

Bring back Face Up, Age of Consent, Lonesome Tonight, Sunrise, etc, rather than the JD stuff.. .

20 Nov 2003, 05:11

Face Up? Christ, I'd shit me pants with joy. Remember drunkenly shouting for it at the Olympia 2001 show, and this lad next to me just grins and goes "yeah, right".

Wasn't their excuse for not doing TPK summat to do with it taking six months to program?? Well, they've had more than six bloody months now (bring back 'The Village' as well!)

29 Dec 2003, 23:08

i voted for dead souls but only if hooky does the lead vox, and i agree that any 2 of e.g.g, hurt, thieves or age of consent would be welcome back in the gig list in preference to bernie's wayward vox on atmosphere!!

29 Dec 2003, 23:22

In terms of JD, Digital would be nice. In terms of NO, bring back TPK, Ultraviolence, and This time of night.

3 Jan 2004, 03:24

I chose Disorder, though very closely behind come Insight, New Dawn Fades, Day Of The Lords, Shadowplay and Twenty Four Hours.

4 Jan 2004, 05:31

All of them !

4 Jan 2004, 14:16

still none of them!! get 'everythings gone green' out instead!

📊Which JD song should NO bring back to the setlist?

Which JD song should NO bring back to the setlist?