Skip to content

A New Order Online Tribute to NO/JD

Archived

56 replies · 852 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Would the musician member on NOOL be interested in creating a NOOL Tribute CD

Closed
  • yes 18 (78%)
  • maybe 1 (4%)
  • no 4 (17%)

23 votes · voting closed

I'm not one (not a note in me head in fact) but I think it's a smashing idea.

0 likes

i am trying to start a n.y. area no/jd tribute band but we cant find a drummer or second guitarist.

0 likes

And I'm trying to find a JD/NO cover band that needs a drummer... :drummer:

0 likes

you arent moving to New York City anytime soon are you?

:guitar: :bass: :singer:

0 likes

I'd bought a bass guitar because of JD/NO when I was a kid. I could play quite a few songs, they were easy to learn, and they sounded SOOO good. Unfortunately, I've mostly forgotten them by now. It would be nice to contribute if possible though.

0 likes

great idea! "the NOOL tribute band" :D we could make a compilation and then edit it. don´t know the "legal" terms though. but if we could, we should do it. I´m in! :thumb:

0 likes

even more. maybe we could make all NOOLers voting for the songs that should be part of it. we upload somewhere all the songs that could be a part of the tribute (20, 30 or whatever) and then we do a poll and pick 13 or 14. it´s just an idea but i think it could work well.

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso even more. maybe we could make all NOOLers voting for the songs that should be part of it. we upload somewhere all the songs that could be a part of the tribute (20, 30 or whatever) and then we do a poll and pick 13 or 14. it´s just an idea but i think it could work well.

exactly what I was thinking about doing. We can also vote on what we will call the album. I'm going to talk to some of my local record label friends about thism and check what we have to do legally to do this,

0 likes

Absolutely - I'd love to give it a crack. CTB :bear:

0 likes

I'm for it :D

Biggest part is, getting the songs...

We can do our own in-house CD, just not selling it for profit SHOULD technically be ok with London..

Then it's a matter of:

  • Mastering (to have the same sound level)
  • Desigining
  • Distributing

This can actually be fun, who knows, maybe an indie label would get interested. (Yeah right)

The only "problem" I can see here is that there is already a tribute to New Order containing 2 NOOL member songs (François-Marc Loze's project), I don't know the status on the tribute, but I sure don't want to compromise their project ;)

A printed CDR with everything would be cool, and this is not really expensive.. we can do a contest to ask people to submit their songs and everything.

Might be interested, but I'd like to know what Mr Shug and Mr Benny think about this... too foolish? :lol:

0 likes

exciting, isn´t it? :jump: about the two fellas that made the tribute we could ask them to do another song specially for "our" tribute. that way they won´t be upset and could collaborate too. it´s all about start receiving songs, and that could start right away. we could put a limit date for sending files and then all NOOLers could vote for the 15 or 17 that would fit in the CDR. about the design. i say the webmasters do it in order to keep NOOL indentity. after all NOOL is the nucleus of the project. so, what do you say? green flag?

0 likes

Apparently my mates have called me tone deaf after hearing my drunken Kareoke singing. But I would be happy to do the design / artwork, and I promise it will not be Green and White Hoops with the Celtic badge;) A NOOL CD is a great idea Nicos and very feasible, as for tribute CD's.......Francois, get in touch and let everyone know what the latest is with Project 02/03 (there were a few Onliners that took part on the demo I received last year as Nicos pointed out)):thumb: I'm sure Timbo / Jim Reilly / Marty and all those others that can play instruments will be interested.

0 likes

My best friend in Ohio has a professional sound studio, I could possibly ask him for help. I can alway help with the design. I also agree we should make the design of the CD identifible to this site in some way. So what should we do to kick this off? I guess we should determine which musicians are going to appear on the CD! Looks like we have a few people already. I guess anyone interested in contributing a song should say so now in this thread.

0 likes

We could possibly use the winners of the survivor games as the song selections. :)

0 likes

Brilliant idea - I'd be delighted to contribute. Guitar/bass/melodica/vocals/drums/some keyboards (been learning keys recently). Based in London.

0 likes

You know, while listening to Almanso's songs, I realize how good an unplugged New Order album might be.

Might be the way the tribute should go... unplugged!

0 likes

Superb idea! im in!!! :D

0 likes

Originally posted by Spotnick You know, while listening to Almanso's songs, I realize how good an unplugged New Order album might be.Might be the way the tribute should go... unplugged!

i think there´re many new order songs that could be played unplugged. but i really had a difficult time choosing a JD song for that purpose! but with imagination and talent i think some NOOLer will be capable to do it. but it´s a good idea. you know more of tributes than me but i don´t think anyone did an unplugged tribute before. that´s the first thing we have to do. decide if we do it unplugged, electronic, rocker or just free to choose. what do you think? we do our first poll about it?

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso > Originally posted by Spotnick> You know, while listening to Almanso's songs, I realize how good an unplugged New Order album might be.> > Might be the way the tribute should go... unplugged!

i think there´re many new order songs that could be played unplugged. but i really had a difficult time choosing a JD song for that purpose! but with imagination and talent i think some NOOLer will be capable to do it. but it´s a good idea. you know more of tributes than me but i don´t think anyone did an unplugged tribute before. that´s the first thing we have to do. decide if we do it unplugged, electronic, rocker or just free to choose. what do you think? we do our first poll about it?

makes sense to me. but I think an unplugged abulm is a really good idea. There are too many electronic style tributes. so this would be different.

0 likes

brilliant idea...just wish I could contribute...do you need a backup hummer???

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso > Originally posted by Spotnick> You know, while listening to Almanso's songs, I realize how good an unplugged New Order album might be.> > Might be the way the tribute should go... unplugged!

i think there´re many new order songs that could be played unplugged. but i really had a difficult time choosing a JD song for that purpose! but with imagination and talent i think some NOOLer will be capable to do it. but it´s a good idea. you know more of tributes than me but i don´t think anyone did an unplugged tribute before. that´s the first thing we have to do. decide if we do it unplugged, electronic, rocker or just free to choose. what do you think? we do our first poll about it?

I'm probably more keen on a free-to-choose approach myself. Not to say that I'm exactly Aphex Twin, but I was hoping to have a go at Elegia, which could be underwhelming on an acoustic only! Is it too early to start? CTB :bear:

0 likes

Wow, that sounds like a great idea!

I play bass guitar, drums, and keyboards...and I also sing. :)

0 likes

Originally posted by The Killer Inside Me brilliant idea...just wish I could contribute...do you need a backup hummer???

Well, you can try to sell those at the store you work for :evil4:

0 likes

Well Tim, the idea of accoustic was just an idea, of course it's not the way to go, unless everyone could do it. I was just telling how good an unplugged album would sound, although I'm not sure I could handle them (Regret or Crystal unplugged.. what would Hooky do?! can he play something else than bass? ;) )

0 likes

well, should we start sending songs?

  1. we´ll need web space for that in order to keep all the songs together in one web page. any volunteers for that?

  2. then we need a limit like june 21th or something. i think 2 months is more than enough to prepare, record and send the songs. that way the project won´t loose its original power. during these 2 months we could decide without rush if we do it commercially or not, who would design it, how many songs would be on the CD, how should NOOLers vote for the winners, etc.

  3. i think the tribute should be free-to-choose-styles. the best results would be with stylistic freedom. and everyone could be envolved so that´s fair for everyone.

well, we need to discuss the terms and start as soon as we can with the project!

0 likes

I'm up for doing a track for this, if it goes ahead. My keyboard skills are just amazing :)

EDIT: I call "World" !!

0 likes

Almanso: can the deadline be extended till the end of the summer? See, me and my group will be having exams soon that require a lot of attention and it would be a lot more fun to work on this over our long summer than rather when we should be getting ready for exams.

0 likes

Originally posted by Ben Aspinall I'm up for doing a track for this, if it goes ahead. My keyboard skills are just amazing :)EDIT: I call "World" !!

"World" is all yours, Ben - I bags Elegia, and it's sounding OK so far (started sequencing tonight). I promise to not do the 17 minute version! I am pretty excited about all this, if nothing else it's forcing me to learn more about using Cakewalk and my synth. CTB :bear:

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso well, should we start sending songs? 1. we´ll need web space for that in order to keep all the songs together in one web page. any volunteers for that?2. then we need a limit like june 21th or something. i think 2 months is more than enough to prepare, record and send the songs. that way the project won´t loose its original power. during these 2 months we could decide without rush if we do it commercially or not, who would design it, how many songs would be on the CD, how should NOOLers vote for the winners, etc.3. i think the tribute should be free-to-choose-styles. the best results would be with stylistic freedom. and everyone could be envolved so that´s fair for everyone.well, we need to discuss the terms and start as soon as we can with the project!

Maybe we first have to organize a little "commitee" to come up with the terms for this project. We'll post the term on NOOL in a poll to see if everyone here is happy with them. Of were not making laws or anything, so the term can be flexible.

So far we have 2 people who already claimed the songs: CTB- elegia Ben- World

Almanso- you never said which one your going to do, but I hope you'll submit your Ceremony.

I'll be happy to provide the webspace your all of you to upload your MP3. I'll set up a public folder on my IDISK. and create a page where you can instantly see your upload and everyone else can download. Just so I can manage the space. I would probably need you all to email me when your uploading and the files size.

After all the submission are in at the determined deadline date. we can hold some poll for all of us to vote which ones we want to appear on the CD.

I would be happy to design the CD, but i guess to be democratic about this project. We can hold a contest for the CD design. and hold a poll for the NOOL to vote on the design.

The committee will organized the production, distribution, mastering, and research the laws for this project.

Ok what do you think?

0 likes

Sorry guys, I hate to be a pain but I'll have to get back to you on what song I'm recording. Some problems came up when I was trying to start recording World and if I can't fix it I'll do another song. I'll get back to you all soon.

0 likes

We have the drive space, of course... this problem was solved with the new host.

0 likes

I'll do Love Vigilantes on acoustic guitar and melodica, but may struggle do get it sorted before June 21st, seeing as I will be on honeymoon most of the time before then !

0 likes

if any one wants to get together in the L.A. area and do a song, i'm up for it. i can sing and play guitar/bass (learned both instruments mimicking Barney/Hookey). i can play keyboards, but i'm not a great programmer. I've been in many bands in both L.A. and San diego.

0 likes

Originally posted by Benny's Cobweb Eyes I'll do Love Vigilantes on acoustic guitar and melodica, but may struggle do get it sorted before June 21st, seeing as I will be on honeymoon most of the time before then !

june 21st was just an idea because of the change of season and that. but we may change it. no problem at all. what i wanted to say is that the project better be finished sooner than later because these things usually starts with a lot of energy and then the interest begins to decrease. besides, a limit date makes you start to work as soon as possible. other way people use to sleep because "there´s still time to do it". trust me, my experience says it´s better with a finish line. and that could be any date in time that not exceeds 4 months from now. other way the project will have no end because everyone will forget about its existence.

0 likes

Maybe we should give people most of the summer to work on their songs, I know some people that would like to participate but they are in college and needs to focus on that at the moment.

But I do think we need some deadline. Maybe the first one should a deadline for all who want to participate to reply to this project. Want to say a week from today? April 23. Partcipants just need to say they want to do a cover and tell us what song they intend to cover.

Nic, could be advertise this on the front page?

0 likes

Well, send me what you want on the front and I'll put it.

You can even do a little montage pic if you want...

Will do it tomorrow, now I'm sleepy!! and tomorrow is election day here, so lots of stuff to do!

0 likes

I would enjoy to take part in this project.

I live near Paris in France and I play the keyboards.

0 likes

Originally posted by Spotnick Well, send me what you want on the front and I'll put it.You can even do a little montage pic if you want...Will do it tomorrow, now I'm sleepy!! and tomorrow is election day here, so lots of stuff to do!

Nic, Check your mail...

0 likes

[Content deleted by WenOrder on 4/14/2003 12:16:10 PM EDT]

0 likes

[Content deleted by WenOrder on 4/14/2003 12:53:24 PM EDT]

0 likes

[Content deleted by WenOrder on 4/14/2003 12:54:05 PM EDT]

0 likes

Originally posted by WenOrder Microsoft VBScript runtime error '800a0005' Invalid procedure call or argument: 'Mid' /include/display.asp, line 415

Wow! Ain't seen one of those in a while!!!

0 likes

I dunno what going on.. I can't post for some reason

What I was trying to say, just in case you didn't see it on the front page. Nic created a forum dedicated to this Tribute project.

0 likes

I am not a musician...wat can I do for this tribute?

0 likes

for those that don´t visit the front page here´s the special forum for the tribute. there you´ll find all you need to know about it: how to be part of it, the rules, the deadlines, how to choose your favourite songs, how to choose the name of the tribute, and more. follow this link http://www.neworderonline.com/threads.asp?forum_id=10

0 likes

Originally posted by iankuramacurtis I am not a musician...wat can I do for this tribute?

say what you do best and offer your services. we´ll need designers for sleeves, CD and the flash file with winners info. if you´re a writer you could write some "tribute" lines. if you´re a singer only you could contact a musician only member to work together and viceversa. just offer the things you´re good at and participate.

0 likes

Great idea...

0 likes

Excellent but the DEADLINE is 31 st APRIL.Is this a NEW day on the calendar?:D

0 likes

Originally posted by Rocket Mick Excellent but the DEADLINE is 31 st APRIL.Is this a NEW day on the calendar?:D

yeah, we like to be different :lol: btw, where did you read that? :scratch: i´ve checked and it says April 30th

0 likes

Today I sent the files out to be reproduced. So i wanted to bring back the 2 thread that started it all

0 likes

I have just voted.........NO!:D

0 likes

Originally posted by almanso for the ones who said NO..... men of little faith!!!! :nonono::p

When do WE get the bloody CD then?:p

0 likes

Originally posted by Rocket Mick I have just voted.........NO!:D

Yeah, i voted New Order also. :D

0 likes

Originally posted by WenOrder > Originally posted by Rocket Mick> I have just voted.........NO!:D

Yeah, i voted New Order also. :D Very drole but don't give up your day job.I have..........:D

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗